A Study Of The Multiple Sign-In Feature In Web Applications

Nowadays, more and more web applications start to offer the multiple sign-in feature, allowing users to sign into multiple accounts simultaneously from the same browser. This feature significantly improves user experience. Unfortunately, if such a feature is not designed and implemented properly, it could lead to security, privacy, or usability issues. In this paper, we perform the first comprehensive study of the multiple sign-in feature among various web applications, including Google, Dropbox. Our results show that the problem is quite worrisome. All analyzed products that provide the multiple sign-in feature either suffer from potential security/privacy threats or are sacrificing usability to some extent. We present all issues found in these applications, and analyze the root cause by identifying four different implementation models. Finally, based on our analysis results, we design a client-side proof-of-concept solution, called G-Remember, to mitigate these issues. Our experiments show that G-Remember can successfully provide adequate context information for web servers to recognize users' intended accounts, and thus effectively address the presented multiple sign-in threat.