Discerning Subsets of Breast Cancer with Very Low and Absent HER2 Protein Expression

Breast cancers are currently eligible for treatment with anti-HER2 therapies if they exhibit amplification of the gene ERBB2 and overexpression of its protein product HER2. Recently, breast cancers with low HER2 expression have shown response to novel anti-HER2 antibody-drug conjugates, and the lower end of "low-HER2" tumors has not yet been clinically delineated. The historically binary approach to HER2 scoring will need to evolve and reporting of HER2 status may require refinement to better stratify low-HER2 statuses. We performed a quality review of HER2 immunohistochemical (IHC) scoring of breast carcinomas with low HER2 expression (71 core biopsies and 51 excisions). We also investigated the feasibility of discerning cases with total lack of HER2 expression from those cases with "very low" HER2 expression that did not meet current criteria for a HER2(1+) score. Rescoring HER2 achieved substantial agreement when performed at 200×, and near-perfect agreement at 400× magnification. Examination under 400× magnification led to recognition of more cases with HER2 expression. Less than 10% of cases showed complete lack of HER2 protein expression by IHC. Cases with "very low" expression were readily identified, and such a category would be feasible to implement in pathologist workflow.