Time to Pain Relapse After Palliative Radiotherapy for Bone Metastasis: A Prospective Multi-institutional Study.

BACKGROUND/AIM:Low risk asymptomatic bone metastasis (LRABM) without gross osteolytic changes tends to be out of indication for radiotherapy. The aim of this study was to evaluate the time between the end of palliative radiotherapy of bone metastasis (BM) until the start of new pain, in patients with painful BM. PATIENTS AND METHODS:Patients with BM were prospectively assessed for location and strength of pain every month for one year after radiotherapy. The correlation of pain relapse at irradiated site, and pain onset outside the irradiated site was evaluated with sex, age, primary tumor, pathology of tumor, visceral metastases, baseline scores for Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status (PS), and baseline verbal rating scale (VRS). RESULTS:A hundred and thirty-two patients were included (79 males and 53 females). Median age was 66 years. Primary sites were lung (n=60), breast (n=17), colon (n=12), prostate (n=11), and others (n=33) (one patient had two primary sites). Median follow-up was 185 days. Pain relief was observed in 92 patients (86.0%). Out of them, pain progression was observed in 69.6%. Median time to pain progression was 75.5 days. Pain onset outside the irradiated site was observed in 57 patients (43.2%). Median time to pain onset was 109 days. Out of the 57 patients, 13 (22.8%) had LRABM which existed before the start of radiotherapy. There were 54 patients with LRABM in this study and because many patients had more than one LRABM, the total LRABM sites were 123. Out of them, pain onset was observed within one year after irradiation in 44 (36%) lesions. Median time to pain onset was 67 days, which was the shortest of the three: irradiated site, out of the irradiated site, and LRABM site. Risk factors for high probability of pain onset within one year in LRABM lesions were female sex (showing a trend in univariate analysis), and pelvic, skull and spine metastasis (significant in multivariate analysis). CONCLUSION:Time to pain onsets in LRABM are relatively short, especially in female patients with pelvic, skull and spine metastasis. In these patients, prophylactic radiotherapy could be an option to consider.