Global trends and decision-making in the management of arachnoid cysts

Objective In pediatric patients, middle cranial fossa (MCF) arachnoid cysts are often discovered incidentally on imaging in asymptomatic patients during workup for other indications. This study aims to describe current management gestalt and threshold for surgical intervention by surveying an international cohort of neurosurgeons. Methods A web-based survey was circulated via email list of attendants of the 2019 Canadian Pediatric Neurosurgery Study Group (CPNSG) and International Society of Pediatric Neurosurgery (ISPN) mailing list. The survey consisted of 8 clinical scenarios involving patients with MCF arachnoid cysts. Demographic variables of respondents and their decisions regarding management for each scenario were analyzed using R computing software. Results A total of 107 respondents were included. Cysts in asymptomatic patients (92%), younger age at diagnosis (81%), and presence of a mild learning delay were predominantly managed non-surgically (80.7 ± 9.4%). Patients with cyst enlargement, headaches, new seizures, or hemorrhage were divided between non-surgical (55.8 ± 3.3%) and surgical (44.2 ± 2.9%) management. Patients with contralateral hemiparesis were treated predominantly surgically (67%). For both Galassi I and II, papilledema was favored as the primary indication for surgical intervention in 54% of patients. Those inclined to surgery ( n = 17) were more likely to practice and train outside North America compared to those not pro-surgical (adjusted P = 0.092). Conclusion Incidental MCF arachnoid cysts in asymptomatic patients and younger age of diagnosis are predominantly managed non-surgically. Mild learning delay was not considered an indication to intervene. In contrast, radiological progression, hemorrhagic evolution, or non-focal neurological deficits lead to uncertainty in management, while focal neurological deficits and papilledema with MCF cysts were favored to be intervened surgically. Among the provider level factors, only location of training and practice trended towards a pro-surgery approach.