ortho-Fluoro or ortho Effect? Oxidative Addition of Zerovalent Nickel into the C-CN Bond of Substituted Benzonitriles

A recent study of the oxidative addition of zerovalent Ni to the C-CN bond of F-substituted benzonitriles showed significantly increased stabilization of the C-CN oxidative addition products with o-F groups (-6.6 kcal/mol per o-F) compared to m-F groups (-1.8 kcal/mol per m-F). To answer the question of whether this is an o-F effect or an ortho effect, in this study the effect of CF3 and CH3 groups on the oxidative addition of the [Ni(dmpe)] fragment [dmpe = 1,2-bis(dimethylphosphino)ethane] to the C-CN bond of benzonitriles has been studied. A density functional theory study of the reaction pathway between eta(2)-CN complexes and the C-CN oxidative addition products shows stabilization of the C-CN oxidative addition product with the electron-withdrawing CF3 group and destabilization with the electron-donating CH3 group in both tetrahydrofuran and toluene. There is a slightly larger ortho effect with CF3 (-7.4 kcal/mol) than with F. However, due to steric crowding, two o-CF3 groups did not show considerably more stabilization than one o-CF3 group. There is a linear relationship between Delta G degrees and the number of meta groups (2.0 kcal/mol stabilization per m-CF3 and 0.8 kcal/mol destabilization per m-CH3). On the basis of natural population analysis, as the C-CN bond becomes more polarized, the stability of the C-CN oxidative addition products with respect to the eta(2)-CN complexes increases.