Magnetic effects of non-magnetic impurities in gapped short-range resonating valence bond spin liquids

We study the effect of a small density n_v of quenched non-magnetic impurities, i.e. vacancy disorder, in gapped short-range resonating valence bond (RVB) spin liquid states and valence bond solid (VBS) states of quantum magnets. We argue that a large class of short-range RVB liquids are stable at small n_v on the kagome lattice, while the corresponding states on triangular, square, and honeycomb lattices are unstable at any nonzero n_v due to the presence of emergent vacancy-induced local moments. In contrast, VBS states are argued to be generically unstable (independent of lattice geometry) at nonzero n_v due to such a local-moment instability. Our arguments rely in part on an analysis of the statistical mechanics of maximally-packed dimer covers of the diluted lattice, and are fully supported by our computational results on O(N) symmetric designer Hamiltonians.