Spatial transformation offers a crucial lens for addressing the intertwined socio-ecological challenges of the 21st century. While spatial planning has significant potential to guide sustainability transitions in urban development, mobility, energy systems, and land use, it remains underutilised in many frameworks. The 2024 ARL International Summer School “Spatial Transformation from a Planning Perspective” that took place at the University of Vienna, brought together advanced doctoral students with different disciplinary backgrounds to examine this role. This special issue presents selected contributions from participants of the summer school that highlight how governance, knowledge, and spatial perspectives can strengthen collaborative, multi-level approaches to navigating sustainability.
This article develops the concept of energyscapes to examine the production, governance, and transformation of socio-material spaces for tar sands extraction, distribution, and consumption in Canada. We argue that energyscapes is a helpful concept to understand the key but understudied role of competing material-discursive practices in shaping tar sands spaces. Connecting research on energy geographies, settler colonialism, and political ecology, this work considers settler and Indigenous assertions of jurisdiction over land as key drivers of tar sands spaces. Through the lens of energyscapes, we analyze the dispute over the controversial Trans Mountain Pipeline Expansion Project (TMX) in British Columbia and Alberta between the federal government and a First Nations-led movement. Using document analysis and participant observation, we discuss the influence of conflicting land claims, discourses on fossil fuels, and knowledge systems in (re)producing and disrupting the physical spaces and sociopolitical arenas through which the TMX is governed. A focus on the political ecology of struggles against tar sands infrastructures opens research avenues to explore the challenges of dismantling the colonial and capitalist logics underpinning tar sands spaces.
Determining appropriate mechanisms for transferring and translating research into policy has become a major concern for researchers (knowledge producers) and policymakers (knowledge users) worldwide. This has led to the emergence of a new function of brokering between researchers and policymakers, and a new type of agent called Knowledge Broker. Understanding these complex multi-agent interactions is critical for an efficient knowledge brokering practice during any given policymaking process. Here, we present (1) the current diversity of knowledge broker groups working in the field of biosecurity and environmental management; (2) the incentives linking the different agents involved in the process (knowledge producers, knowledge brokers and knowledge users); and (3) the gaps, needs and challenges to better understand this social ecosystem. We also propose alternatives aimed at improving transparency and efficiency, including future scenarios where the role of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies may become predominant in knowledge-brokering activities.
Protected areas are crucial for landscape-scale conservation, but striking a balance between centralised guidance (heteronomy) and local autonomy (self-determination) is essential. This balance is particularly important for parks that cross administrative boundaries or impose land-use restrictions, as these factors can impact local acceptance and actors’ responsibilities. Analysing governance structures can unveil communication effectiveness, power distribution and collaboration levels within protected areas. This paper presents a network analysis intended to obtain empirical evidence of the above. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first such analysis to be conducted in a German conservation context. This approach reveals responsibility distributions and motives behind spatial interventions. In the pilot study of the Lüneburg Heath Nature Park, 34 actors were identified. In the core group, data was generated from 12 semi-structured expert interviews. We identified existing communicative and collaborative structures between key actors, local rights holders and stakeholders facing implementation challenges. Leveraging structures like the ‘Nature Conservation Coordination Group’, which has the status of a higher-level assembly, can encourage an open communication culture and affirm each actor’s value. We conclude that strengthening existing governance structures and implementing them on the ground, even on an informal basis, is essential for fostering a shared understanding and greater acceptance of landscape-scale conservation issues.
The urgency of fundamental socio-ecological transformation is scientifically uncontested, yet institutions – including spatial planning – predominantly act sluggishly, reinforcing existing paths of unsustainability. Despite normative orientations such as the sustainability principle within the German spatial planning law, planning practice has so far struggled to enable and accelerate socio-ecological transformations towards sustainability. This comment highlights the tensions between planning’s ambitions and its realities, emphasizes the importance of exnovation and unlearning as key dimensions of socio-ecological change, and argues for a reflexive reorientation of spatial planning. Only by critically examining its own role between stabilization and transformation can spatial planning become an active agent of change.