This work of historical theology profiles the unique role of Sergius Bulgakov (1877–1944) in the unfolding of Russian Orthodox theology over the last century. It narrates the role in his thought of the contested figure of Sophia (the personification of divine wisdom), with special focus on to how his creative appropriation of this ancient concept led him to propose modifications of the church’s doctrines of creation and deification. Our focus on deification acknowledges that patristic sources regarding this topic were only made ready for Russian theological research in the first decades of the twentieth century. Concurrently, another novelty came into vogue among the Russian intelligentsia during these same years: the evocation of both esoteric and biblical versions of Sophia, along with the promulgation of an original theological framework known as sophiology, a development pioneered by Vladimir Solovyov. These unique cultural and religious vectors, deification, creation theology, and sophiology, and their relation to Orthodox trinitarianism, converged around the year 1910 in the life and scholarship of Sergius Bulgakov, while also being firmly resisted by conservatives. A brilliant, wide-ranging, and independent thinker, Bulgakov began as a Marxist economist whose midlife conversion led him to the priesthood and a professorship at a prominent Russian seminary. Bulgakov went on to create one of the last century’s most ambitious and creative Orthodox systematic theologies, an endeavor made possible through his sheer mastery of numerous scholarly sources that, over three decades, he explicated in light of the emergence of sophiology, the worldview of which he became the leading proponent. Against opposition by colleagues at the St. Sergius Theological Institute, where he served as dean, Bulgakov expanded sophiology into a panentheistic theological system that highlighted and integrated concepts of religious living, deification, and cosmology within a vast panoply of other Christian theological dogmas that he examined. This introductory historical account summarizes a selection of Bulgakov’s pioneering innovations, with special emphasis on the reception of his ideas during his lifetime and the decades since.
Buddhist teachings first made contact with psychoanalysis almost one century ago. Carl Jung famously grew interested in Buddhist psychology, with its obvious resonant orientation toward the mind as an ultimate resource. Clinicians from Erich Fromm, to Karen Horney, Wilfred Bion, and many others began integrating the tradition into their analytic work. However, it took another 75 years for Buddhist teachers and spiritual mentors to acknowledge the role of psychodynamic methods and insights for students of the Dharma (Buddhist teachings). Perhaps informed by scandals among revered Buddhist teachers, who seemed to be re-enacting unworked-through trauma histories, and students who brought a full spectrum of developmental struggles, interpersonal traumas, psychiatric illness, and addiction to their spiritual pursuits, contemporary Dharma mentors began to slowly appreciate the need for more active conversation between the traditions. Today, there is widespread awareness, primarily among Western Buddhist teachers, that many Dharma students need both spiritual and psychological support. But still, there remains a struggle to more fully grapple with the impact of developmental interpersonal experience on a student’s relationship to their spiritual practice. In this paper, I will explore through the lens of both my psychoanalytic practice and my role as a Dharma teacher, how Buddhist spiritual care in the West across lineages will continue to benefit from increased understanding of psyche, and how even foundational and widely taught Buddhist methods such as mindfulness and concentration can become sources of distress, or merely ineffectual, when these perspectives are ignored. I will reference clinical vignettes of two long-term psychoanalytic patients and their evolving relationships to the Dharma as a portal into this ever-evolving conversation.
Abstract This essay addresses the historical diaspora of peoples in Abya Yala due to the prevailing colonial matrix sustained by religious dominance. Religious dominance alienated relational spiritualities, shaped the ontological notion of non-being, and exalted the superiority of those who wielded power. This dominance was endorsed in colonial biblical texts of the chosen people and their colonizing re-readings and entailed the seizure of the land. Thus, we discuss the ambivalence of the Bible—of death, but also life—to the extent that its re-readings foster an approach to the sources that strengthen the ancestral spiritualities, which are preserved in creative ways. Such creativity paves the way for the integration of Christian symbols, like liturgy, into the cosmogonic notion of the peoples.