
Abstract Computational thinking (CT) is a critical skill for the 21st century. To enhance students' engagement in CT‐related learning activities, educational games are considered an effective tool, especially for younger students. However, the absence of individualized feedback may limit their potential. To address this challenge, a generative artificial intelligence (GenAI)‐empowered contextual gaming environment was developed. A quasi‐experimental study was conducted with two intact fifth‐grade classes at an elementary school in eastern China. After controlling for pretest scores, the experimental group showed a modest but statistically significant advantage in self‐reported CT tendencies compared with the control group, whereas no significant between‐group difference was found in algorithmic knowledge. Students in the experimental group valued the opportunity to ask questions of GenAI‐powered non‐player characters (NPCs). The qualitative findings suggest that GenAI primarily functioned as motivational and cognitive scaffolding by encouraging inquiry, supporting problem clarification and sustaining engagement, rather than as a direct mechanism for improving algorithmic knowledge during the short intervention. These findings should be interpreted cautiously because CT tendencies were measured through self‐report, the intervention lasted 3 instructional weeks, and the sample was drawn from a single school. The study therefore provides preliminary evidence regarding the potential of GenAI‐supported contextual games to foster CT‐related tendencies and inquiry behaviours among elementary school students. Practitioner notes What is already known about this topic Game‐based learning (GBL) has been shown to support student development, particularly in enhancing primary school students' CT‐related tendencies and problem‐solving orientations. Generative AI (GenAI) has the potential to support personalized learning support within a GBL environment to facilitate learning. What this paper adds After adjustment for pretest scores, students in the GenAI‐enhanced condition showed a modest but statistically significant advantage in self‐reported CT tendencies compared with those in the conventional GBL condition. Interaction with GenAI‐powered NPCs in a GBL environment can stimulate students' inquiry, engagement and problem‐solving awareness. Implications for practice and/or policy: This study highlights the importance of engaging students in exploration, dialogue, reflection and repeated practice for fostering CT tendencies. Role‐playing contextual educational games, when integrated with GenAI, can effectively nurture students' CT tendencies while sustaining their motivation and engagement.
Abstract Generative artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly available as a source of interactive academic support, raising questions about how it shapes learning. Research has focused on performance outcomes, with less attention to learners' behavioural and affective responses to academic challenge, even though productive engagement with challenge supports deeper learning. In this randomised between‐subjects experiment, students aged 16–18 at an English sixth‐form college worked on two sections of challenging mathematics questions with one of three forms of support: one‐to‐one human tutoring, a GenAI tutor or unguided internet search. Measures included self‐reported effort and perceived difficulty, questions attempted, post‐task stress and subsequent challenge‐seeking. Support condition was associated with different response patterns. Students using the GenAI tutor reported higher effort and perceived difficulty than those receiving human tutoring by the second section. Descriptively, post‐task responses showed a lower proportion of stressed responses under GenAI tutoring than internet search. Human tutoring showed the lowest perceived difficulty and highest number of attempts in both sections, although significant pairwise differences varied by section. It also showed descriptively the lowest proportion of stressed responses. Challenge‐seeking did not differ by condition and was instead strongly associated with trait challenge‐seeking. The findings suggest that the GenAI tutor used in this study offered a form of support distinct from both human tutoring and unguided internet search, with potential value during independent practice rather than as a replacement for human teaching. They demonstrate the importance of evaluating AI‐supported learning beyond performance outcomes and through behavioural and affective responses to difficulty. Practitioner notes What is already known about this topic Productive struggle with challenging tasks is important for learning, but its benefits depend on how learners respond when difficulty is encountered. Human tutors can support productive responses to challenge through scaffolding and co‐regulation, helping learners manage effort, difficulty and emotional responses. Generative AI tools are increasingly used by students during independent study, but much existing research has focused on performance outcomes rather than learning processes or learner behaviour. What this paper adds This study provides experimental evidence comparing a human tutor, a generative AI tutor and independent internet search in how students respond behaviourally and affectively to academic challenge. Working with the GenAI tutor was associated with higher reported effort than human tutoring in the second task section, alongside higher perceived difficulty. Post‐task responses also showed a descriptively lower proportion of stressed responses than under unguided internet search. By contrast, human tutoring was associated with the highest number of attempts in both sections, lower perceived difficulty and descriptively the lowest proportion of stressed responses, indicating a distinct and more supportive role when students encounter difficulty. Findings suggest that different forms of support may shape how students experience and work through challenge, while subsequent challenge‐seeking was more closely associated with students' pre‐existing dispositions. Implications for practice and/or policy Support choices shape learners' engagement with difficulty and should therefore be treated as pedagogical decisions rather than neutral sources of help. The pattern observed with Khanmigo Lite suggests that GenAI tutor support may help sustain engagement during challenging academic work without resolving difficulty. The GenAI tutor examined here may offer a more supportive alternative to unguided internet search during independent practice, although designs and capabilities vary and evolve. Such tools should supplement rather than replace human teaching, with educators supporting learning and addressing unresolved difficulty. Evaluations of AI‐supported learning should attend to learners' behavioural and affective responses to challenge, rather than focusing solely on end products or task completion.
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has become a routine source of feedback, explanation, drafting support and task guidance in higher education. This study examined how individual students' self-reported GenAI reliance and perceived human agency co-varied over time in an AI-supported collaborative writing course. Three-wave data were collected from 342 undergraduates working in 85 fixed groups. A traditional cross-lagged panel model (CLPM) and a random intercept cross-lagged panel model (RI-CLPM) were estimated to distinguish observed-level associations from within-person temporal relations after stable between-person differences were separated. The CLPM indicated reciprocal observed-level associations. In the RI-CLPM, higher-than-usual reliance was associated with lower subsequent agency, whereas agency-to-reliance paths were weaker and not statistically supported. Equality-constraint tests were consistent with directional asymmetry, while 95% confidence intervals and Monte Carlo sensitivity analyses showed that small reverse effects remain possible. Backend logs showed that self-reported reliance corresponded to AI-use intensity, although log indicators could not distinguish strategic consultation from cognitive offloading or deference. The findings highlight the importance of designing AI-supported collaboration so that students' responsibility for interpretation, judgement and authorship remains visible.Practitioner notes What is already known about this topic GenAI systems can provide timely feedback, explanation and drafting support in collaborative learning environments. AI support may help students generate ideas and revise work, but reliance on system-generated suggestions can reduce opportunities for judgement, negotiation and ownership. Traditional cross-lagged models can conflate stable between-person differences with within-person temporal associations. What this paper adds The study examines individual students' self-reported GenAI reliance and perceived human agency across three waves in an AI-supported collaborative writing course. After stable between-person differences were separated, RI-CLPM estimates provided stronger evidence for paths from higher-than-usual reliance to lower subsequent agency than for the reverse direction. Equality-constraint tests were consistent with directional pattern asymmetry, while confidence intervals and Monte Carlo sensitivity analyses indicated that small agency-to-reliance effects remain possible. Backend logs showed that self-reported reliance corresponded to AI-use intensity, but log indicators could not distinguish strategic consultation from cognitive offloading or deference. Implications for practice and/or policy AI-supported collaborative tasks should make students' responsibility for interpretation, judgement and authorship visible throughout the learning process. Instructors can ask groups to form an initial position before invoking AI and to explain why AI suggestions are accepted, revised or rejected. GenAI tools may better support agency by offering critics, asking questions and prompting reflection while leaving decisions about task direction to students. Learning analytics dashboards should not equate high AI-use intensity with over-reliance unless log data are interpreted alongside discourse, reflection, revision or decision-making evidence.
Young children increasingly engage with digital media tools for purposes of education, entertainment and communication. This study examines children's digital media activities within the context of their larger home learning environment (HLE). Using data from two different samples (N = 289), we looked at digital media use and found that caregivers reported that children most frequently engaged in watching content and playing literacy games compared to STEM-related activities. This more comprehensive view of the HLE aligned with three distinct factors: analog activities, digital learning and watching content. Analog activities were significantly and positively associated with children's language comprehension and vocabulary skills, whereas digital learning activities were significantly and negatively associated with their vocabulary skills. Watching content showed no significant associations with children's learning outcomes. In our data, digital learning activities, as currently used, did not confer the same benefits as analog activities; guidance on selecting high-quality tools and on supporting co-use may be required to realize digital benefits.Practitioner notes What is already known about this topic In this digital age, young children engage with digital media tools (smartphones, tablets, e-readers and apps) more often than in the past. Digital media is often used as part of children's home learning environment (HLE). There are concerns that too much digital media is negatively related to children's outcomes. What this paper adds Young children who are from low-income households are more likely to engage in watching content and playing literacy games in comparison to STEM-related activities and games. Data uncovered three factors associated with the HLE: analog activities, watching digital content and using digital learning activities. Analog activities were positively associated with children's language skills, but digital learning activities were negatively associated with their vocabulary. Watching content was not associated with any child skills. Implications for practice and/or policy Educators and families may benefit from guidance on prioritizing analog learning activities while also carefully incorporating digital activities. Future research should investigate the quality and the characteristics of the digital activities children engage in to better understand their role in supporting children's skills.
Generative AI (GenAI) is increasingly integrated into collaborative inquiry to provide metacognitive prompting that scaffolds socially shared regulation of learning (SSRL). Understanding how such GenAI-based metacognitive prompting is taken up through student-GenAI interactions is therefore critical. However, although learner-GenAI interaction processes have been widely examined, little is known about how learners' preconceptions shape their engagement with GenAI-based metacognitive prompting. This study examined how groups with different or similar preconceptions about energy forms and conservation differed in their engagement with GenAI-based metacognitive prompting during collaborative inquiry. Participants comprised 14 small groups, including eight groups with different preconceptions (D groups) and six groups with similar preconceptions (S groups). The distribution of learner-generated inquiries directed to the written metacognitive AI (MAI) was largely comparable across groups. Lag sequential analysis revealed contrasting patterns in how groups evaluated the metacognitive prompts: D groups showed sustained positive or neutral evaluation of the prompts, whereas S groups showed sustained negative evaluation. Process mining further showed that AI query negotiation served as a hub in D groups' collaboration, connecting their conceptual discussions and task coordination. In S groups, by contrast, it formed part of a simpler, linear sequence of querying the AI and processing its responses. This study advances understanding of how preconception diversity shapes the processes and dynamics of human-AI collaboration. The findings show that AI-mediated regulation varies depending on group-level knowledge configurations.