
Abstract Despite the passage of three constitutional amendments and two civil rights Acts in the postbellum years, African Americans continued to face daily injustices, especially as the North and South accelerated reconciliation in the latter years of Reconstruction. This situation compelled the Black population to attempt securing citizenship rights through actions that could potentially embarrass white America into honoring its commitment. China provided them with a convenient trope through which they could critique white society while endorsing its objective to civilize supposedly less developed races. Black American commentators emphasized China’s perceived lack of civilization to align themselves with America’s civilizing missions and prove their communities’ civilized status, or at least their rapid progress toward it. In so doing, they aimed to portray white Americans’ ongoing anti-Blackness as both irrational and unjustified. China’s alleged inferiority transformed from a marker of despicable character into an antiracist tool for Black Americans.
This article argues that Shirley Geok-Lin Lim’s memoir, Among the White Moon Faces: An Asian-American Memoir of Homelands , theorizes subjectivity through “the gap,” a borderland space defined by loss as much as by gain. Hybridity is approached not as a resolved or coherent condition but as an unstable and incomplete framework shaped by contradiction and ongoing negotiation. Engaging with Gloria Anzaldúa’s concept of mestiza consciousness alongside a recontextualized understanding of presence and absence as lived and relational processes, the analysis shows that Lim’s project is not one of synthesis but of sustained reworking of essentialist notions of homeland and self. The absence of maternal, linguistic, and national origins functions as a structuring condition that compels a continuous negotiation of identity. Situating Lim’s work within late twentieth-century discourses of hybridity and borderlands identity, the article demonstrates both their historical specificity and their continued relevance for contemporary configurations of migration and transnational subjectivity. Lim thus reconceptualizes the gap not as a void, but as a generative site of transnational becoming.