
ABSTRACT The structural or functional distinctions and ties between soldiers and civilians were matters of common knowledge when George Washingon accepted command of the Continental Army. That America’s “Revolution” was “also a Civil War” did not wait for President Lincoln to expiate on the subject at Gettysburg. But few of the sophisticated analytics now embedded in those facts likely troubled students at the “College of Philadelphia,” or the “University of the State of Pennsylvania,” preparing for history exams in 1795 or 1895. The adjacency of bitter American defeat in Vietnam was still hot during planning for the Bicentennial in 1976. The aerial destruction of small Caribbean watercraft said to be carrying “terrorist” immigrants and drugs, or the 2026 militarization of federal law enforcement in California and Minnesota, will stingingly inflect with Tercentennial festivities in 2076. Time matters in more ironic ways than even academic scholars of the past can comfortably describe. The American Revolution will doubtless always be both a lightning rod and a measuring stick.
ABSTRACT This article reflects on the lessons and limitations of five decades’ worth of scholarship on class and class formation in Revolutionary Pennsylvania. After reviewing the historiography, it suggests that our longstanding focus on working people’s politics has obscured subtler forms of class interest and behavior. Using the experiences of poor, rural laborers-turned-soldiers, the article considers the possibility of locating expressions of class that lie outside the realm of politics. By searching for self-activity and struggle at the margins of our prevailing narrative, it finds opportunities to think differently about how we tell the story of class in Revolutionary Pennsylvania.
ABSTRACT As the nation prepared to celebrate its bicentennial, scholars interested in women’s history sought to determine if the Revolution benefited women or not. Though this question has continued to shape the field, scholars have also expanded their investigations, considering the multiple ways that women experienced the revolutionary era. They have incorporated a range of historiographical subfields and put Pennsylvania and the mid-Atlantic into their studies. Still, scholars could do more to investigate the role women played in revolutionary Pennsylvania. As historians look toward the next fifty years, they should continue to diversify the women they study, think beyond southeastern Pennsylvania, examine the lives of ordinary women, and consider how studying women’s experiences can reveal something about the state’s Revolutionary history.
ABSTRACT This article argues that political history is not dead in the scholarship on the American Revolution—particularly in Pennsylvania—but fundamentally reimagined. Responding to long-standing declension narratives that portray political history as exhausted, overly narrow, or eclipsed by social and cultural approaches, it situates recent work within the methodological and interpretive commitments of #VastEarlyAmerica. Far from displacing politics, this scholarship expands it, redefining political history through scale, connection, contingency, and inclusion rather than through jurisdictional borders, linear timelines, or elite institutions alone. By examining newer research on Indigenous nations, frontier settlers, women, enslaved and free African Americans, wartime mobilization, and state formation, the article demonstrates how Pennsylvania’s Revolution looks markedly different when decentered from Philadelphia and re-embedded within broader spatial and temporal frameworks. These approaches challenge inherited narratives of democratic ascent and counter-revolution, complicate familiar periodizations, and foreground the contested, coercive, and often violent processes through which political authority was negotiated and enforced.
ABSTRACT Discussing Benjamin Franklin in a Revolutionary context presents several challenges because of the scope and volume of his international correspondence, the difficulty in establishing a starting point for his “revolutionary” activity, and his self-fashioned identities. Early Franklin scholarship often took those identities at face value and tended toward hagiography. The last half-century of scholarship has been marked by peeling away aspects of the historical person from these more iconic images, and have been as varied as Franklin’s own pursuits, with studies of Franklin’s science, domestic politics, international diplomacy, philosophy, and literature, all receiving multiple book length studies and hundreds of scholarly articles. Franklin studies will continue to be marked by interdisciplinarity, as many of Franklin’s relationships, connections to important figures of the era, and the intensively allusive nature of his writing remain underexamined. More work also needs to be done on how Franklin’s writings have been received, adapted, and interpreted by readers in his time and since, and studies of Franklin’s status as an icon in the internet era would help elucidate what Franklin can mean to people 250 years after the Revolution.