
This roundtable discussion brings together a panel of scholars to unearth and examine shared concerns and questions across this special edition, focused on God-representations, imagining God and the implications for practice. The conversation considers: the underlying values that form interdisciplinary research; the relationship between God-representations and practices; the significance of interdisciplinarity for reaching seldom-heard populations; the disciplinary goals and limits of psychology and theology; and creativity and affectivity in the future of research. Certain themes also recurred across these discussions, which map the disciplinary distinctiveness of theology and psychology while speaking to shared concerns with power, underlying epistemologies and the (ultimate) significance of the research. These reflections bring the practical importance of research on God-representations into sharp relief. Not only do God-representations interact with cosmologies, actions, identities and so on, the discourse about those representations (and how they interact with practical concerns), shapes our research practice too. The intersection of psychology and theology offers an imaginative and practical model for good practice in interdisciplinary research.
Psychological research on the self-concept shows people seek to acquire skills, traits, and behaviours that reflect their ideal selves. In Christian theology, humans are understood to be made in God’s image ( imago Dei ), suggesting a prototypical ideal self (albeit individually unique and marred by sin). Psychology distinguishes “God concepts” (intellectual understandings and beliefs about God) from “God images” (emotional experiences of God): “God representations” combine both. Recent converts to Christianity reported aspiring to reflect particular attributes of God, motivating their faith adoption. Similarly, recently baptised adults had ideal selves that matched the attributes of God that they appreciated. This consonance between Christian participants’ ideal selves and their God representations warrants further investigation, and this study similarly found matches between appreciated attributes of God and personal aspirations, reported qualitatively, as well as statistically significant positive correlations between ideal selves and God representations, suggesting congruence. Paired-samples t -tests and Wilcoxon signed-rank tests confirmed these similarities on a number of positive attributes. Implications and future research suggestions are discussed.
This study examined the associations among beliefs in free will and determinism (or divine sovereignty and/or providence), meaning in life (MIL), and meaning judgment, as well as whether religious commitment moderates these associations. Guided by the Tripartite Meaning in Life Model, we tested a moderated mediation model using a Christian sample ( N = 239). Results revealed that at low levels of religious commitment, stronger deterministic beliefs were associated with lower MIL, which in turn predicted lower meaning judgment. This indirect effect shifted in valence and had a smaller effect size at higher levels of religious commitment, where deterministic beliefs showed a slight positive association with MIL and meaning judgment. These findings highlight that religious commitment shapes how deterministic beliefs connect to both MIL and meaning judgment, with lower religious commitment amplifying negative associations and higher religious commitment attenuating or reversing them.
This roundtable discussion, featuring a panel of scholars from both psychology and Christian theology, reflects on several different types of tensions at the intersection of these two fields. The discussion focused on four core inquiries. First, we explored the tension between interdisciplinarity vs. (hyper)specialization. Second, we discussed the tension between linguistic and cultural particularity vs. generalization and examined the importance of “functional bilingualism”— the ability to navigate the distinct vocabularies of both disciplines. Third, we considered how broad theoretical frameworks, such as attachment theory or core doctrines, are reshaped by the diverse ways they are lived out in practice. Finally, we discussed the practical implications of these findings, highlighting the necessity of both religious and psychological literacy in clinical, religious, and educational settings. The panel concludes by weighing disciplinary differences in methodological approaches, specifically as they relate to the interplay between scientific objectivity and researcher subjectivity.
This editorial introduces the empirical and theoretical works in this special issue, which examine questions about how people conceive of and think about divine realities, emotional and intellectual understandings of the divine, and the relationship between God representations and outcomes such as coping, health, faith development and leadership, and artistic expression. These examples are situated within a broader conversation about the tensions, concerns, opportunities and benefits of cross-disciplinary research between psychology and theology, including mutual theoretical refinement and exchange of methods, and the research posture involved in developing successful research. Key among these is the value of a researching community to which we suggest this special edition contributes in a modest way, especially through curating roundtable discussions on the two themes of “Cultural and psychological resources for well-being” and “Imagining the Divine and the implications for practice.” This editorial aims to illuminate entryways for scholars thinking about the challenges and features of research across these disciplines and support the emergence and growth of new researchers working at this frontier.