
Overgaard et al. recently published national recommendations for history taking, examination and clinical management of infants in Danish chiropractic practice. Such recommendations can shape clinical practice, education and regulation, so their development methods and evidentiary basis warrant scrutiny. This letter examines the recommendations against established standards for consensus methodology and guideline development, and against the existing pediatric chiropractic literature. We raise five concerns. First, describing the recommendations as “consensus-based” is difficult to reconcile with the reported method of gathering clinical perspectives, which did not follow a formal consensus technique such as the Delphi or RAND/UCLA method; “expert-informed” would describe the process more accurately. Second, the claim of novelty overlooks a published Delphi-derived best-practice guideline for pediatric chiropractic care whose domains overlap with the Danish recommendations. Third, the force recommendations rely on tensile-strength extrapolations that are not validated clinical safety thresholds, express force as a percentage of an unspecified adult reference, cannot be measured by chiropractors during treatment, and leave infants aged 4 weeks to 2 months without guidance. Clinical measurements of chiropractic forces in children support lower forces for infants but do not validate percentage-based thresholds. Fourth, the recommendations detail the exclusion of serious pathology but do not specify the positive examination findings that justify manual intervention or how these findings inform clinical decisions. Fifth, the authors report neither a systematic literature review nor a formal assessment of evidence certainty or recommendation strength; adherence to the RIGHT reporting statement cannot substitute for systematic evidence synthesis or an evidence-to-recommendation framework such as GRADE. The Danish recommendations address an important area of practice, but their consensus claim, novelty, force guidance, clinical indications and evidence base require revision or qualification. Aligning future recommendations with formal consensus methods, systematic evidence synthesis and explicit grading of recommendations would strengthen their credibility and support safe, evidence-informed chiropractic care of infants.
Abstract Background Musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs) are highly prevalent, costly, and burdensome. Over 40% of United States military veterans are diagnosed with chronic pain related to the spine. Various clinical practice guidelines recommend nonpharmacological treatments for the management of chronic MSDs including spinal pain. During the COVID-19 pandemic, face-to-face healthcare was diverted to telehealth platforms to minimize exposure of communicable disease. To address barriers to in-person treatment, veterans experiencing pain associated with MSDs at one Veterans Health Administration Medical Center were offered a novel evidence-based approach incorporating patient education and experiential movement through a telehealth modality. Methods We describe a novel telehealth clinic for self-management of MSDs offered from February 2021 to September 2021. The clinic consisted of a one-hour class offered weekly for four weeks, and included didactic lecture content and movement therapy. The classes were offered by a chiropractor and a yoga instructor. We retrospectively evaluated implementation of the telehealth clinic, including program attendance. Attendance of three or more of the four sessions (75%) was selected as a pragmatic descriptive indicator of patient participation. Results Seventeen veterans participated in three cohorts over six months. The mean age of participants was 54.8 years (SD: 14.6; range 34 to 80), and 12 (70.6%) were male. Seven participants (41.2%) attended at least three of the four sessions, including five (29.4%) who attended all four sessions. Participants represented a geographically diverse population, with varying distances from VA facilities and VA facilities with chiropractic services. Conclusions We describe a clinical demonstration of a telehealth clinic for MSDs offering evidence-based content with experiential movement. This program was delivered through video telehealth and a subset of participants sustained attendance across most of the four-session series. The preliminary information reported could be used for development and expansion of this type of clinic for telehealth chronic MSD management. Future studies are needed to determine the impact of telehealth delivery of MSD care on outcomes, cost, and patient preference. Expanding telehealth delivery of MSD care may be particularly valuable for rural veterans, those lacking access to transportation, or patients who experience barriers to attending in-person appointments.
Abstract Background Chronic non-specific back pain (CBP) is a leading cause of disability worldwide and is commonly associated with limitations in movements such as lifting. Although spinal manipulation (SMT) and exercise therapy (ET) are recommended treatments for CBP, their effects on objectively measured movement performance remain insufficiently explored. Open-label placebo (OLP) has gained attention for engaging placebo-related mechanisms ethically. This study aimed to investigate the immediate effects of SMT, ET, and OLP on lifting performance and pain in individuals with CBP, and to evaluate the add-on effects of OLP. Methods A motion laboratory–based crossover randomized controlled trial included 50 individuals with CBP. Participants were recruited between April and July 2025 and attended a single laboratory session between September and October 2025. Participants performed lifting tasks using light and heavy loads before and after SMT, ET, and OLP interventions in randomized order. Three-dimensional motion capture was used to assess temporal, spatial, and spatiotemporal aspects of lifting performance. Subjective outcomes included pain intensity, perceived effectiveness, willingness to undergo each treatment, and treatment preference. Data were analyzed using linear mixed-effects models and functional data analysis. Results Overall lifting performance changed to a small degree following the interventions. No significant between-group differences were observed at the primary endpoint. Significant within-group changes were observed following SMT, including altered intersegmental coordination during the light lift, characterized by a greater relative contribution of back movement early in the lifting phase, reduced thorax–pelvis tilt during the heavy lift, and reduced pain. OLP was associated with reduced thorax–pelvis tilt and increased hip and knee flexion during the light lift. Subjective evaluations did not consistently correspond to objective biomechanical changes. Conclusion SMT, ET, and OLP demonstrated limited immediate effects on overall lifting performance in individuals with CBP. However, some within-group changes in thorax–pelvis movement and intersegmental coordination suggest that certain aspects of movement quality may respond to short-term interventions even when conventional biomechanical outcomes remain largely unchanged. The findings suggest the value of integrating subjective and objective outcomes, while advanced biomechanical analyses may provide insight into subtle movement changes in CBP. Trial registration The trial is registered at ClinicalTrials.gov (ID NCT06891625).
Abstract Background Cervical artery dissection (CeAD) is a rare but life-threatening condition that commonly presents with non-specific symptoms such as neck and head pain, complicating early recognition in ambulatory care settings. The CeAD diagnostic decision support tool (DDST) is a 4-item assessment designed to identify patients that should be referred for advanced diagnostic work-up to rule out CeAD; however, its utility in ambulatory settings has not been established. Methods This quality improvement project aimed to evaluate the accuracy, inter-rater reliability, and intra-rater reliability of chiropractors applying the CeAD DDST using clinical vignettes simulating a typical ambulatory encounter before deploying the DDST broadly as part of the clinical workflow. Five experienced chiropractors assessed 40 standardized clinical vignettes. CeAD-positive cases (n = 10) were derived from published imaging-confirmed ambulatory care case reports. CeAD-negative cases (n = 30) were developed using generative artificial intelligence and refined by senior authors to reflect common conditions encountered in chiropractic practice. Raters independently assessed cases with the DDST (score 0–4), with a cutoff score of ≥ 3 recommending referral for advanced diagnostic work-up in two rounds, beginning November 11, 2025 and January 07, 2026, with a two-week capture period. Accuracy, inter-rater reliability, and intra-rater reliability were assessed. Results Accuracy in identification ranged from 72.5% to 95.0% across raters and rounds. False positives and negatives were present across raters in both rounds, with false positives being more prevalent. Inter-rater reliability was moderate to substantial in both rounds (Round 1: κ = 0.609, 95% CI 0.432–0.806, Round 2: κ = 0.540, 95% CI 0.365–0.735). Intra-rater reliability ranged from moderate to almost perfect agreement (range 0.457–0.931). Conclusions The CeAD DDST demonstrated moderate to good accuracy and reliability among chiropractors in a simulated ambulatory setting. The presence of false negatives and inter-rater reliability falling below recommended benchmarks preclude recommendation for implementation at this time. Iterative refinement informed by end-user input and prospective ambulatory testing is warranted prior to clinical adoption of the CeAD DDST. Future evaluations should include prospective studies using real clinical data to better represent real-world settings.
Abstract Background Compensation claims represent a selective subset of adverse events in healthcare and provide insight into patient safety. Compensation claims vary between countries and jurisdictions due to administrative, legal, and clinical differences. This study aimed to describe compensation claims related to chiropractic consultations in Norway from 2013 to 2024. Methods We conducted a retrospective registry study using data from the Norwegian System of Patient Injury Compensation and national chiropractic consultation data. All completed claims associated with chiropractic care between 2013 and 2024 were included regardless of whether they were approved or rejected. Claim frequencies were calculated per 100,000 consultations and per first-assessment consultations. Descriptive analyses were used to summarise results. Results A total of 147 claims were filed during the study period, of which 17 (12%) were approved. Over 24 million chiropractic consultations were recorded for the period, corresponding to an average annual claim approval rate of 0.1 per 100,000 consultations and 0.5 per 100,000 first-assessment consultations. Most claims involved musculoskeletal conditions (89%). High approval proportions were observed for claims related to central nervous system and circulatory disturbances (60%). The most common reasons for rejection were lack of causation and absence of healthcare failure. Total compensation amounted to 21.7 million Norwegian Kroner (~ 2.2 million Euros). Conclusions Compensation claims related to chiropractic care in Norway are rare relative to consultation volume, and only a small proportion were approved. Most claimants presented with common musculoskeletal conditions, while approved cases often involve serious events temporally associated with chiropractic consultations. These findings contribute updated national evidence on compensation claims in chiropractic practice and may inform quality improvement and policy.