
For this fourth Apres Coup project, we revisit Lew Aron's classic essay, The Patient's Experience of the Analyst's Subjectivity, with translations in Spanish and Italian and discussions by Anthony Bass, Elise Geltman, Sam Gerson, Jessica Benjamin, Masha Borovikova Armyn, Alejandra Plaza Espinosa, and Gianni Nebbiosi.
I argue that before re-thinking Israeli subjectivity, its current status - centred on morality and power - should be presented. I will suggest that this prototypic identity evolved through a dialectic of denying diasporic traumatic victimhood and totally identifying with it, and that it still anchors Israeli society's diverse segments. I will argue that an unconscious melancholy attachment to this identity must be mourned in order to counter its compulsive, repetitive manifestations. I will then suggest mourning as a process that may act as a transformative third in the Israeli psyche - both individual and social.
This article refines a Levantine ethics of complex implication under perpetrator conditions in Israel. Starting from a personal dilemma about the point at which staying becomes impossible, it revisits Levantine ethics and explores its horizon through a Mizrahi identity - a hybrid, marginal yet implicated position within Israeli power. In dialogue with calls to renounce the guilty "we" or to abandon continuity altogether, the article argues that binary demands for complete renunciation of the collective "we" or full belonging risk reproducing the very asymmetries they oppose. In doing so, they erase cracks, ambivalences and conflicting identifications that are central to complex implication. In place of such binaries, the article develops an ethics of fractures and thresholds, oriented to small enclaves of non-belonging and modest practices of resistance. Drawing on autoethnographic work on activism in decline, three circles of participation under perpetrator conditions are outlined - personal-biographical, institutional-professional and social-political - and illustrated through civic, professional and institutional practices. Hope is reframed not as an image of a "happy ending," but as a difficult, long-term process of identity transformation. It is a practice of inhabiting contradictions through small acts of struggle that acknowledge perpetration, mourn broken ideals and keep open the possibility of leaving, while living in the fractures of a conflicted "we."
I explore the danger evoked by the in-person setting and argue that this threat invests the frame with a dark side. This danger is felt by some adults who suffered early caregiver absence or neglect, denying them holding and containment, and breeding forms of protection that hindered development. The danger was exposed by some patients' resistance to, or difficulties with, in-person work following the pandemic. Jose Bleger's theory elucidates the frame's maintenance of a primitive symbiotic relation, and eruption of keen anxiety due to changes in the frame. Case excerpts illustrate two forms of early anxiety provoked by shifts to in-person sessions: anxiety related to otherness, and terror realized in the breakdown of continuity of being. Despite such challenges, I argue that the in-person setting enables the patient to live childhood trauma anew with the analyst, to attain possible healing and growth. Finally, I question whether trauma in some analysts' lives led to collusion with patients in shared resistance to the in-person frame.
This discussion attempts to think alongside ideas on creative form and genesis presented in Erica Ehrenberg's paper. Is analytic (and creative) process facilitated by the right kind of space or by a more active process? How do we think about presence in facilitating psychoanalytic change? What follows is an effort to expand Ehrenberg's ideas by bringing them into rapport with concepts of the transformational object, attunement, and the aesthetic basis of therapeutic action. I present a therapeutic model where shifts in one's being-in-the-world precede and enable the availability of new perceptual windows into one's inner unconscious forms. In this model, the analyst is considered a living process, rather than an object or a set of provisions, that has the potential to induce new states of being through the aesthetic matrix of the treatment.