
ABSTRACT Although artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly used to support feedback in health professions education, little is known whether and how AI‐enabled feedback supports reflective learning and critical reflexivity. The literature encompasses generative large language models (LLMs) as well as non‐generative natural language processing (NLP), traditional machine learning (ML) and computer vision (CV). This scoping review examines the design and use of AI‐enabled feedback for reflective learning across health professions education. Following Arksey and O'Malley, Levac et al. and PRISMA‐ScR guidance, we searched MEDLINE, Embase and ERIC from 1 January 2015 to 21 November 2025. Eligible empirical studies examined AI‐enabled feedback or feedback‐related educational activities involving health professions learners or professionals in undergraduate, graduate, or continuing professional development contexts. Data were charted descriptively and classified using FACET, SAMR, Hattie and Timperley's feedback framework and Kirkpatrick outcome levels. Nineteen studies met the inclusion criteria. A total of 12 of 19 (63.2%) used LLMs, 4 (21.1%) used non‐generative NLP, 2 (10.5%) used traditional ML and 1 (5.3%) used CV. Six studies (31.6%) involved continuing professional development (CPD). Augmentation was the most common SAMR level (10/19; 52.6%). Of 15 studies that could be classified by Hattie and Timperley's framework, 10 (66.7%) provided process‐level feedback, 3 (20.0%) task‐level feedback and 2 (13.3%) self‐regulation feedback. No included study explicitly examined critical reflexivity. Reported outcomes were concentrated at Kirkpatrick Level 1 (reaction; 9/19) and Level 2 (learning; 9/19), with no demonstrated longitudinal evidence of sustained behaviour change, transfer to practice, or lifelong learning outcomes. Current evidence on AI‐enabled feedback in health professions education is early, fragmented and predominantly performance‐oriented. Critical reflexivity has not yet been adequately studied, and lifelong learning should be regarded as a future educational goal rather than a demonstrated outcome of the included evidence. Current evidence on AI‐enabled feedback is predominantly performance‐oriented, with limited examination of reflective learning and no explicit evaluation of critical reflexivity. Although AI‐enabled feedback may contribute to ongoing professional development, its effects on sustained learning, behaviour change and lifelong learning remain unestablished. Future work should use theory‐informed feedback and design, strengthen learner feedback literacy and human oversight, address bias and power, and evaluate meaningful educational and practice‐based outcomes over time.
ABSTRACT This article examines how institutional boundaries shape the positioning and legitimacy of business and management doctorates in China and the United Kingdom. Existing research has often treated doctoral reform, professional doctorates and doctoral capital as separate concerns; less is known about how degree type and national context jointly condition the recognition and convertibility of doctoral resources. Drawing on Bourdieu, the study compares 40 programmes across four positions—UK PhD, UK DBA, China PhD and China DBA—using programme, institutional, regulatory and accreditation documents. It develops a three‐level analytical model of institutional rule‐setting, programmatic formation and evaluative recognition. The findings show that UK programmes articulate doctoral legitimacy primarily through research originality and peer‐recognisable standards, whereas Chinese programmes more explicitly connect academic rigour to national‐development and innovation priorities. PhDs primarily emphasise academic‐capital accumulation, whereas DBAs seek to translate managerial experience and organisational knowledge into academically recognisable research contributions. Evaluation, accreditation and institutional prestige provide additional sources of symbolic recognition without necessarily establishing equivalent institutional standing. The resulting pattern is one of constrained hybridisation rather than convergence: academic, practical and political forms of capital increasingly intersect, but their conversion remains conditioned by institutional rules and research‐legible standards. Doctoral legitimacy is thus understood as an institutionally bounded process of capital conversion, rather than an inherent property of degree types.
ABSTRACT This article presents the results of a mixed‐method study investigating lay conceptions of critical thinking (CT) among 506 English‐ and French‐speaking participants, with a focus on beliefs relevant to the teaching of CT: its value, its teachability and participants' beliefs about their own CT skills. Our results suggest that CT is widely perceived as important and valuable, and as a skill that can be taught rather than an innate ability. However, most participants, regardless of age, tend to consider themselves more critical than others. This better‐than‐average effect is partly explained by positive beliefs about CT skills and by the idealization of CT. We discuss the implications of these results for the teaching of CT and its potential pitfalls.
ABSTRACT This study examined a new speaking task, the reading‐while‐listening speaking (IntRLS) task, in comparison to the traditional independent speaking (IndS) task. Linguistic features of oral performances and their impact on human ratings were analysed using data from 108 ESL learners. Performances were compared on fluency, vocabulary, grammar and content. Paired‐samples t ‐tests and regression analyses revealed performance differences between the tasks, particularly in fluency, vocabulary and content. Most linguistic features did not predict human ratings. However, content quality was a predictor for the IndS task, and word type for the IntRLS task. These findings enhance understanding of task demands and rater expectations, indicating that IntRLS and IndS tasks measure distinct aspects of the L2 speaking construct. Incorporating the IntRLS task in speaking assessments may offer a more comprehensive representation of learners' English speaking proficiency.
ABSTRACT The extinction of experience—the loss of direct contact with nature—has eroded ecological literacy among successive generations including primary pre‐service teachers (PSTs), challenging their capacity to deliver mandatory science curricula. This qualitative case study evaluates an interdisciplinary initial teacher training (ITT) programme where eight European PSTs conducted a coastal safari as role‐playing naturalists, subsequently reconstructing the shore via art‐integrated habitat dioramas. Questionnaires, participant observations and peer feedback revealed that first‐hand fieldwork shifted trainees towards accurate, locally specific species identification, while model‐making consolidated pedagogical content knowledge (PCK). Analysed via Murcia et al.'s creativity framework, the intervention fostered experiential learning and collaboration, offering teacher educators an adaptable, scalable model that simultaneously builds biodiversity literacy and outdoor pedagogy.