
Rural regions occupy vast territories and often exhibit spatial dispersion, limited institutional support, constrained resources, and scarce market opportunities. Yet entrepreneurial activity develops under these conditions. This coexistence creates a theoretical puzzle for entrepreneurial ecosystem (EE) research, as rural EE operate despite several conditions commonly associated with effective ecosystem functioning being comparatively weak or dispersed. We conduct a bibliometric–systematic review of 71 articles on rural EE, identifying four thematic clusters and synthesizing them into a multi-level conceptual framework and eight research propositions. Grounded in complex adaptive systems theory and informed by a multi-level mechanisms perspective, we conceptualize rural EE as compensatory cross-level systems operating under conditions of structural thinness. We theorize that structural thinness changes the functional logic of EE as available ecosystem elements assume broader, more interdependent, and compensatory roles. Whereas denser EE, often associated with urban environments, may rely comparatively more on abundant and specialized ecosystem elements, rural EE functioning becomes relatively more dependent on adaptive alignment. We conceptualize adaptive alignment as an emergent system-level mechanism through which ecosystem elements continually adjust their roles and relationships via recurring processes of coordination, feedback, resource recombination, and mutual adjustment across analytical levels. Adaptive alignment sustains rural EE functioning, thereby supporting entrepreneurial activity and shaping regional value creation. By theorizing that structural thinness changes not merely the availability of ecosystem elements but the functional logic through which they become connected and collectively sustain ecosystem functioning, we extend the boundary conditions of prevailing EE explanations and inform more context-sensitive research, policy, and practice in rural regions worldwide.
We integrate Penrose's (1959) theory of firm growth with the spinout literature to identify a previously overlooked type of new venture: the Penrosean spinout. Penrose identified the accumulation of managerial capacity as a natural byproduct of routine firm operations and a catalyst of firm growth. However, managerial capacity may also accumulate in non-managerial employees, particularly in low-tech sectors such as the trades, where workers readily observe and absorb the full range of activities required to run an enterprise. When it does accumulate, excess managerial capacity may catalyze not firm growth but new firm formation — a spinout. In a pure Penrosean spinout, employer and employee need not disagree about the product, the market, or the production process; they disagree about whether to expand the business, and on what terms. Our framework makes three contributions. First, it identifies an endogenous mechanism of entrepreneurial entry: the seeds of new firm formation are sown continuously in the normal course of business, not only in response to technological disruption or novel market insight. Second, it explains persistent industry fragmentation in low-tech sectors as a structural consequence of the routine leakage of managerial capacity through spinouts. Third, it offers a novel account of why noncompete agreements and occupational licensing are prevalent among low-wage workers who possess little proprietary technical knowledge. By extending spinout theory beyond high-tech contexts, we contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of the emergence of entrepreneurial firms.
Entrepreneurship is often understood as the pursuit of opportunities or the creation of new ventures, yet these perspectives offer limited insight into how entrepreneurs sustain coherence between imagined futures and feasible action over extended periods of time. Entrepreneurs commit resources and coordinate others around desired futures they believe can be brought into being. Emerging work reconceptualizes entrepreneurship as a process of actualization, yet we still know little about how actualization unfolds over time, particularly when entrepreneurs pursue morally and culturally meaningful futures that must be reconciled with shifting conditions of feasibility. Drawing on a historical process analysis of Adriano Olivetti and the Olivetti Corporation, we theorize entrepreneurial actualization as a recursive relationship between entrepreneurial imaginaries (historically situated, value-laden conceptions of desirable futures) and entrepreneurial visions (pathways that are feasible in the present and translate those aspirations into commitments and actualization practices). While imaginaries articulate what ought to be realized, visions specify what can be realized under existing constraints. Our process model explains actualization coherence: the extent to which evolving action remains connected to the desired future that gives it purpose and direction. We show that such coherence erodes when the capacity to recalibrate visions is lost, as occurred after Olivetti's death. We contribute to research on entrepreneurship as actualization, on entrepreneurial process, and on the extended temporal horizons across which entrepreneurial futures unfold, persist, and sometimes outlive the ventures that pursued them.
Entrepreneurship theories acknowledge that competitive conditions matter for opportunity beliefs, yet how entrepreneurs identify competitors and how this identification shapes venture concept development have received little theoretical or empirical attention. We develop a process account of how entrepreneurs identify competitors and revise opportunity beliefs and venture concepts in response. Unlike market demand or technological feasibility, competitors are strategic agents who can adapt in response to entry, and as the venture concept evolves, so does the set of competitors it faces. We theorize an adaptive cycle in which encountering a competitor prompts threat assessment, which raises perceived competitive pressure and lowers confidence in venture success while motivating venture concept adaptation that can partly restore perceived viability. A controlled experiment isolates the cycle's components and shows that identical competitive information produces widely divergent threat assessments. A behavioral simulation in which participants develop their own ventures and search for competitors shows that entrepreneurs starting from similar concepts identify largely non-overlapping competitor sets. Some reposition their ventures spontaneously in response to what they find, and adaptation attenuates the link between threat and perceived competitive pressure.
The judgment-based approach (JBA) has emerged as an important contemporary perspective in management and entrepreneurship research. The JBA offers a distinctive theoretical account of entrepreneurship, centered on the formation and implementation of subjective theories of value creation under conditions of Knightian uncertainty, which highlights resource ownership, heterogeneous capital structure, organization and the firm, institutions, uncertainty, and the overarching need to appraise and coordinate all these factors using judgment. We present and develop the JBA by articulating the uncertainty-heterogeneity nexus, in which the joint presence of fundamental uncertainty and heterogeneous resources gives rise to the need for entrepreneurial judgment and makes its exercise economically consequential. Because judgment is subjective, tacit, and difficult to communicate or contract upon, entrepreneurs must rely on ownership and residual control rights to create value, linking judgment to the combination and deployment of resources, profit and loss, and organizational structure. The purpose of this article is threefold. First, we provide a systematic statement of the JBA as a theoretical framework, clarifying its core constructs, causal mechanisms, and domain of application. Second, we engage with key critiques and distinguish the JBA from related approaches, including opportunity-based, effectuation, and bricolage perspectives. Third, we outline directions for future research that build on the JBA's emphasis on judgment, ownership, and the organization and deployment of heterogeneous resources under uncertainty. By integrating these elements, we position the JBA as a coherent and distinctive theory of entrepreneurship with broad implications for research in management, organization, and strategy.