
Teachers' growth mindset (TGM), encompassing teachers' beliefs about the malleability of their own capabilities and their students' learning potential, has attracted increasing attention in research on teachers' professional lives, teaching practice, and student learning. Yet the literature examines different malleability beliefs and connects them with teaching practice and mindset interventions, making findings difficult to compare across studies. This scoping review maps empirical research on TGM in primary and secondary education, synthesises the educational processes and outcomes examined in relation to TGM, and identifies limitations in the field. Searches of four databases and relevant reference lists identified 34 quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-methods studies conducted across 13 countries or regions. Inductive content analysis identified five themes: teacher professional processes and outcomes; teaching practice and mindset messaging; student experiences and outcomes; classroom relational and contextual processes; and organisational, cultural, and equity processes. Positive relationships were most consistent for teachers’ professional well-being, psychological resources, work engagement, and professional learning. Relationships with teaching practice varied across studies, while findings for student outcomes were positive, null, or conditional. Evidence concerning classroom relationships and direct equity outcomes remained limited. The educational significance of TGM depends on the belief examined, its expression in teaching practice, and the conditions in which teachers work. Future research should specify the malleability belief under study and trace its connections with teaching practice, student experiences, and educational outcomes.
John Hattie's Visible Learning aggregates over 2400 meta-analyses into ranked effect sizes, seeking to reveal the most impactful educational practices. Despite its global influence on education, critics highlight methodological and statistical weaknesses. This study comprehensively assessed Visible Learning's 322 influences for quality, relevance, and reproducibility. An expert panel found that 22% of the influences are highly relevant. However, only 19% meet the inclusion criteria regarding participants, intervention, comparison, and outcome alignment (PICO). Furthermore, only 2 of 301 assessed influences could be fully reproduced with respect to the reported effect size, studies, students, and effects. The assessment revealed that Visible Learning contained methodological errors that compromised both the causal interpretations and the validity of the reported effect sizes. These findings underscore significant methodological and statistical shortcomings, raising questions about the validity of Visible Learning as a basis for educational policy and practice.