
Well-executed mediation research offers unique insights into how well theoretical Human Resource Management (HRM) pathways (mediators, M) can account for observed relationships between an exogenous HRM variable, X, and an endogenous outcome variable, Y. This is central to advancing theory, as well as developing credible policy implications. However, our review shows that the value of mediation research in HRM and in related fields (e.g., organizational behavior) is significantly limited by its typical sole focus on the indirect effect and its statistical significance, often disregarding direct and/or total effects and their practical meanings. We demonstrate the importance of complete reporting and interpretation of all effects—indirect, direct, and total—as well as the percentage mediated. Doing so allows a more complete and valid assessment of the degree to which one or more indirect effects account for the HRM-outcome relationship, a central issue in mediation research. We further highlight that inconsistent mediation (i.e., when the indirect and direct effects carry opposite signs) is often overlooked and misinterpreted. In such cases, a conclusion about the X ➔ Y effect, based solely on the statistical significance of the indirect effect, can be misleading for theory and, in an applied field like HRM, for practice. We illustrate these concerns with examples from empirical work in HRM and related fields and show how more complete reporting and interpretation provides more informed and valid conclusions, thereby better guiding future theory, research, and practice.
Organizational scholars have studied equity sensitivity (ES) for nearly half a century. Yet, a lack of synthesis in the ES literature suggests important questions remain regarding our understanding of the concept, its nomological network, the theoretical role(s) it may play in shaping employee attitudes and behaviors, and its relations to adjacent theories of equity and organizational justice. In the current work, we address these questions via a theoretical and meta-analytic review of the ES literature encompassing 117 articles, 144 samples, and 36,177 participants. In synthesizing the literature, we (1) describe and alleviate existing tensions surrounding the construct's conceptualization, (2) provide empirical insights regarding the construct's associations and relative importance in the prediction of key workplace outcomes, and (3) present an integrative model of ES's potential theoretical moderating role in equity and justice relationships. Our work provides clarity regarding ES's nomological network and offers critical directions for future scholarship. Specifically, we draw special attention to opportunities for new work exploring ES's potential as a key linking mechanism among equity and organizational justice theories.
Due to technological developments, jobs disappear, new jobs arise, and existing jobs change. This leads to opportunities and challenges regarding human resource management (HRM) and the role of the HR function in the future of work. In this article, we explore how technological developments such as the use of smart technologies, artificial intelligence (AI), and robotics influence HRM and the role of the HR function. Through a scoping review, we highlight the influence of technological developments across macro (societal), meso (organization/HRM) and micro (individual workers) level work themes. We specifically focus on the dynamic interplay between technological developments and HRM. At the meso level, the analysis zooms in on how technological developments influence HRM at the strategic, tactical, and operational levels within organizational contexts. Our findings inform a future research agenda comprising avenues aimed at deepening our understanding of the challenges and opportunities associated with technological change in the context of HRM. More specifically, we propose future research to explore how the HR function can prepare the organization, itself, and other stakeholders, including line managers and workers, for the impact of technological developments to enhance HRM for the greater good.
Broad-based employee share ownership (ESO) plans are a widely used form of employee compensation. Past reviews have focused on employee attitudes and organizational performance, offering limited insight into why employees participate or the duration of their participation. Further, ESO is rarely considered as a dynamic phenomenon despite most plans being a continuing form of employee compensation. These omissions impede theoretical developments and advice to practitioners. In a review of 48 publications, across multiple disciplines, we propose an integrative framework that identifies the antecedents and mechanisms of three interrelated ESO participation decisions (i.e., buy, contributions, and holdings) within the context of employee stock purchase (and similar) plans. Building on this integrative framework, we propose an agenda for future research that we believe to be most promising for theory development and practice: the temporal dynamics of ESO participation, the influence of contextual (i.e., organizational-level) factors, and methodological innovations.