
ABSTRACT The conceptions with which students enter the classroom are widely acknowledged as a vital resource for meaningful teaching and learning. While students’ conceptions related to science content and disciplinary core ideas (e.g., force and motion, energy) have been extensively investigated, relatively little is known about students’ conceptions related to scientific practices (e.g., asking scientific questions and conducting investigations) and how these develop. To address this gap, we analyzed video data from N = 33 students working in small groups on learning material that aims to foster concepts related to the practice of asking questions. Through inductive category formation via qualitative content analysis, 16 different conceptions related to scientific questions were identified, including both productive and unproductive conceptions from a scientific point of view. Furthermore, longitudinal analysis revealed that the conceptions students construct vary considerably, even in relatively short periods of time and in similar situations. The findings demonstrate the importance of investigating students’ conceptions not only for science content but also for scientific practices. Furthermore, they provide insights into which conceptions might need to be addressed with instruction and offer implications for more fundamental questions regarding the stability and variability of students’ conceptions.
ABSTRACT This study investigated elementary preservice teachers' (PTs) experiences in planning to elicit students' ideas within ambitious science teaching (AST). The study involved 53 elementary PTs in the context of a science teaching methods course at the elementary education program at a public university in Türkiye. Data were collected through PTs' individual written reflections on their planning for eliciting students' ideas in AST and collaboratively developed group lesson plans and analyzed using thematic analysis. Findings revealed PTs' struggles, perceived reasons for those struggles, criteria used to evaluate phenomena, explanations, and questions during planning, and the support systems and navigation moves used to address challenges in phenomenon selection, gapless explanation development, and question creation. The findings also showed the interconnectedness of phenomena, explanations, and questions, with struggles in one area shaping planning decisions in others. Collaborative planning, instructor guidance, conducting research, and (pre)rehearsals emerged as important support systems in helping PTs navigate these challenges. Group lesson plans complemented the reflections by showing how planning decisions were represented in collaborative instructional products. This research contributes to understanding how elementary PTs experience, navigate, and make sense of challenges involved in planning to elicit students' ideas and offers implications for practice‐based teacher education.
ABSTRACT Teaching is often framed as neutral and apolitical, yet scholarship has long documented its entanglement with power, identity, and ideology. Despite growing attention to the sociopolitical dimensions of science education, less is known about what science teachers themselves understand as political and how those understandings shape where they locate political responsibility. This qualitative study examines how 16 secondary science teachers conceptualize teaching and gender‐ and sexual‐diversity‐inclusive science teaching (GSDST) as political or apolitical within a Midwestern U.S. state. Drawing on semi‐structured interviews and guided by ecological systems theory, we analyzed what teachers understood as making teaching and GSDST political and where they located political influence and responsibility across ecological systems. While most teachers described teaching as inherently political, GSDST was frequently framed as political because it had been politicized by others (e.g., parents, media, policy). We characterize this pattern as a displacement of political responsibility, through which teachers recognized the broader politicization of GSDST while locating its politics primarily outside their own instructional practice. Political sensemaking varied by locale, professional development participation, years of teaching experience, and identity, demonstrating how individual and structural conditions shaped where teachers located political responsibility. Neutrality functioned simultaneously as a protective strategy and as a discursive constraint that could obscure the political dimensions of instructional decisions. These findings highlight the importance of cultivating political consciousness while attending to the structural conditions that shape teachers' possibilities for justice‐oriented science teaching.
ABSTRACT For 3 days, Amy, a veteran middle school science teacher, struggled to engage students in using Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS)‐aligned curriculum designed to facilitate scientific argumentation. Amy consistently used productive framing bids or cues to redirect students from “doing school” toward sensemaking and “doing science.” Teachers may use framing bids to curate opportunities for students' epistemic agency as they shape and contribute to knowledge construction and knowledge practices of the classroom community (Damşa et al. 2010; Stroup, 2014; Miller et al. 2018). Although these types of framing bids generally “worked” in Amy's class—initiating or helping to sustain their engagement in sensemaking—they were largely unsuccessful in these lessons. We argue that, on Days 1‐3, this difficulty arose from a key mismatch: the forms of epistemic agency (students’ opportunity to evaluate and contribute to knowledge construction) invited by the curriculum differed significantly from the forms students typically enacted in her classroom. On day 4, Amy made minor adjustments to the lesson, some of which added structure. Amy restored students' ability to be “experts,” to choose sources of information, and allowed the use of familiar digital tools. These adjustments resulted in dramatic shifts in students' reactions to the curriculum: as the curriculum intended, students engaged in scientific argumentation and evaluations of model‐evidence (mis)match. By realigning the forms of epistemic agency invited by the lesson to those with which students were familiar, Amy facilitated sustained sensemaking through engagement with science practices, as intended by the curriculum. Through a single case study, we argue that the multidimensionality of epistemic agency–the multiple forms it can take– matters to students and can be recognized by teachers. Therefore, when preparing teachers to implement NGSS‐aligned curricular units, teacher educators should draw upon teachers' knowledge of their students and classroom to identify, interpret and adapt curricula in ways that attend to potential (mis)matches between the forms of epistemic agency invited by the curriculum and the forms of epistemic agency students typically enact and value in the teacher's classroom.
ABSTRACT Undergraduate science education is often understood as a process of acculturation—learning the knowledge and practices aligned with existing disciplinary norms and values. A consequence of acculturation is that it preserves the status quo and can perpetuate exclusion and oppression. Moving toward justice therefore requires mechanisms that enable the transformation of scientific communities. In this paper, we present a conceptual argument for how to support students in learning about disciplinary culture and participation in ways that create space for imagining resistance and change. This work is inspired by a design innovation that introduced examples of resistance work in science through “Spotlight” assignments that invite students to learn about the identities and scholarship of contemporary scientists. Resistance Spotlight assignments introduced students to scientists who are pushing back against oppressive norms and interrogating problematic histories within their fields. We conducted a comparative case analysis of Spotlight assignments in a computational biology course, examining how different assignments shaped students' ideas about what values are important and possible in disciplinary participation. We argue that Resistance Spotlight assignments can help students recognize the possibility and value of justice‐oriented work in disciplinary contexts, as well as the potential of such work to transform scientific communities.