
Contemporary diagnoses of politicized sociology typically ascribe the problem to individual scholarly misconduct or ideological capture. This paper argues instead that such boundary blurring represents an adaptive response to a reorganized incentive and recognition architecture. As peer validation becomes scarce, contested, or perceived as arbitrary, scholars increasingly seek recognition in expert and public circuits, independently of bad faith or ideological preference. Drawing on Raymond Boudon’s theory of the three markets of intellectual production, the paper recovers from Weber’s “Nervi fragment” the concept of Wissenswert - what is worth knowing - a criterion of relevance obscured by the Parsonian reduction of the fact/value distinction along Humeans lines. This perspective converges on the insight that peer validation, expert engagement, and public dissemination must operate in productive tension rather than as substitutes, and that understanding the contemporary crisis in scientific authority requires analyzing not individual conduct but the reorganized relational fields within which scholarly identity and legitimacy are constituted.
This essay critically reviews Alan Fiske’s recent book Representing Relationships: Modes of Cognition and Connection (2026). The book presents a sustained argument for Fiske’s conformation systems theory of human sociality. In this essay, I first reconstruct the main ideas of conformation systems theory, and then move to a topical discussion. The discussion covers: (i) why conformations take the form they do; (ii) whether conformations are conceptual metaphors; (iii) the place of mindreading (“theory of mind”) in conformational practices; and finally, (iv) applications of conformational systems theory to ancient human (i.e., Pleistocene) symbolic behavior.
Liberal democracies formally prohibit discrimination on specified grounds and in specified domains, yet disagreement about its definition and prevalence remains pervasive. Predominant paradigms treat discrimination as an objective phenomenon and thereby overlook the societal struggle over what should count as discrimination. This article makes that struggle its object. A model of the contested definition argues that the concept’s definitional architecture enables the struggle. Its six dimensions admit conflicting interpretations that actors invoke selectively, producing incommensurable arguments. Discrimination thus persists not only through hidden bias but also through group-based differential treatment openly defended as legitimate. A model of the contested reality then shows how the topic gains political salience. As a minority’s societal position improves, minority and majority members increasingly, though asymmetrically, face intergroup encounters that could count as discriminatory or not. Filtered through contested definitions, these encounters make perceptions of discrimination’s prevalence diverge between and within both groups. The divergence recedes once group boundaries fade or a shift in social norms settles, at least for a time, which treatment counts as discrimination. Ultimately, the theory recasts discrimination as an enduring struggle over where legitimate differentiation turns into illegitimate discrimination and how often that boundary is crossed.
In this article, I describe calls for a new global political economy (GPE) originating outside sociology, and identify strategies by which sociologists can answer these calls. These strategies take as their point of departure the successes and failures of sociology’s intellectual offspring closest to the new GPE: world-systems analysis (WSA). I first engage in a close reading of David Lake’s (2009) seminal statement on open economy politics (OEP), which describes the consolidation of a “bottom-up” approach to economic globalization rooted in the struggles of international political economy (IPE) to explain the changing landscape of the 1970s. I then describe a counter-rebellion to OEP initiated by Thomas Oatley (2011) and Benjamin Cohen (2017), which argues forcefully that OEP fails to consider the “top-down” global and systemic causes of the outcomes it seeks to explain. This new GPE is committed to theoretically coherent top-down explanations and methodological rigor, but varies in its fundamental epistemological and methodological assumptions. The emergence of the new GPE coincides in time with the decline of WSA in sociology, despite the centrality of the “global” and “systemic” to WSA. Moreover, sociology has scarcely contributed to the new GPE despite the deeply sociological intuitions in much of the new GPE. Thus, I analyze the rise and future demise of WSA to identify strategies sociologists can deploy to contribute effectively to the new GPE in our own discipline and beyond.
Sociologists face the pressing question of how large language model-based technologies can contribute to social theorising. Several social scientists have called for a greater integration of generative AI tools in the social sciences and humanities to speed and scale up the production of social theory. In this article, we adopt a more cautious approach, reflecting on how the adoption of generative AI raises foundational questions about the construction, refinement and evaluation of critical social theory. To make this argument, we create and critically analyse a speculative piece of dystopian sociological fiction. This enables us to explore the values and practices of critical social theory authorship. We argue that authorship must be ‘recentred’, particularly with regard to four key values of authorial practice: (1) standpoint, (2) creativity, (3) pluralism and (4) accountability. In the present moment, the use of generative AI as substitution for authorial practices redefines and potentially threatens authorship in ways that problematises its particular use in generating critical social theory. With regards to standpoint, generative AI technologies run the risk of reproducing an ‘abstract masculinity’ that feminist scholars have long written against. The relational wonder at the heart of social theory creativity is undermined by generative AI use, as is the pluralism of creativity. Generative AI also flattens and overlooks pluralism of voice, as well as dilutes authorial accountability. We sociologists need to defend and rearticulate what we contribute to social theory and its concomitant politics, both in the theories themselves and in the project of social theorising. It is with this in mind that we call for the ‘rebirth’ - that is, the recentralisation - of the human author in critical social theory creation.