
Purpose This study aims to explore the structural drivers of gold price dynamics by uncovering the hierarchical and causal relationships among economic, geopolitical and market-related factors. Moving beyond correlation-based evidence, the study seeks to develop an interpretive understanding of how these drivers interact and propagate within the financial system. Design/methodology/approach The study adopts an expert-based interpretive research design. Key factors influencing gold prices are identified through an extensive review of prior literature and validated by domain experts. A total interpretive structural modeling framework is used to establish hierarchical relationships among the factors, while DEMATEL is used to assess causal influence and interdependence. The integrated approach enables the development of a structural and causal representation of gold price dynamics. Findings The results reveal a multi-level causal structure in which geopolitical risk, energy market shocks and macroeconomic uncertainty emerge as fundamental driving forces. These root drivers transmit their influence through intermediate financial and behavioral mechanisms, ultimately shaping gold price movements. The analysis highlights the systemic role of gold as a risk-sensitive asset responding to complex interactions rather than isolated determinants. Originality/value This study contributes to the literature by introducing a theory-building, interpretive explanation of gold price dynamics. By focusing on structural causality rather than isolated factors, it advances qualitative research in financial markets and provides a conceptual foundation for subsequent empirical investigations.
Purpose This study is conducted with the purpose of investigating the causes of investors’ self-control bias in Pakistan’s stock market and to build a scale on it so that the research can be operationalized in the future. The study aims to identify potential precursors of self-control bias and to characterize the extent to which each precursor contributes to its development among Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) investors during the investment decision-making process. The self-control bias is a state in which people show a lack of ability to control their emotions. The study’s first section consists of semi-structured interviews with stock market experts. Expert responses based on semi-structured dialogues with investors are then approved, and NVivo is used on the main findings to create a word cloud that can be used to identify specific self-control bias precursors. The measures’ context and content validity are also checked by having five language experts and five market experts approve each measure in turn. In Section 2, the self-developed scale is floated to perform the following tests: the Bartlett’s sphericity test to verify item correctness; the Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (KMO) test to assess sample size; an exploratory factor analysis to reduce overloading items based on outlier detection; and a check for outliers. To examine the inter-item association between items and create a more polished scale, the third segment includes the floatation of a refined scale with a limited sample size in comparison to previous floatations of the scale. The polished scale flotation in the fourth segment uses a smaller sample size compared to previous scale floatations to assess the consistency of factors (if an item is omitted), the relationship between factors and the cause-and-effect relationship between factors. In the final section, a refined scale with a smaller sample size is proposed for comparison with the previous flotation to validate the scale factors using Principal Component Analysis. By investigating and verifying the reasons behind investors’ self-control bias, it is possible to mitigate this bias through workshops for individuals. This could result in a more efficient stock market and economy. Design/methodology/approach A qualitative study is conducted with the purpose of identifying the reasons for the generation of emotional biases of investors in the PSX. This research critically investigates the various antecedents of emotional biases toward the behavior of investors in the PSX and then develops scales on such biases based on those identified antecedents. This paper provides a comprehensive explanation of the investor’s emotional behavior in the stock market of Pakistan. While based on exploratory research, another goal of the study is to gain an understanding of the emotionally biased behavior of the stock’s investors, too, to express more detailed views about the movement of the stock market, or to learn trends of the stock market. The key notion behind the use of an explanatory study is to describe well an opinion and approach, developed by a group of people on various emotions of the investors. The explanatory study further allows for measuring the importance of the results on the total population. In this way, it emphasizes counting and categorizing features and presents statistical figures to clarify what is detected. As an explanatory study, it is objective in method in the sense that it merely pursues specific dimensions and examination of target concepts to respond to its investigation. Findings Investors with a self-control bias become more positive about the market because they believe they can make money solely through their own decisions. Investors may not control their emotions toward purchasing in the market when they do not want to listen to the advice of others and just want to decide based on their own judgment, and they also do not know how to use their available resources. Financial illiteracy is another factor that acts as a catalyst in the production of self-control bias in investors in the market. Research limitations/implications The scale developed can be used to assess emotional bias among investors. Practical implications By investigating and verifying the reasons behind investors’ self-control bias, it is possible to mitigate this bias through workshops for individuals. This could result in a more efficient stock market and economy. Originality/value The scale for emotional bias has been developed for the first time to assess emotional bias.
Purpose The purpose of this study is to examine how differences across accounting, banking, insurance and group supervision affect the interpretation of capital strength and risk capacity in bank–insurance conglomerates. Regulatory fragmentation is treated as an interpretive and supervisory problem rather than proof of financial weakness. A structured method is developed through which observable differences can be identified from public evidence and compared across financial groups. Design/methodology/approach A qualitative documentary method is applied to laws, technical standards, supervisory guidance, consultation papers, enforcement reviews and corporate reports. A Regulatory Fragmentation Risk Index (RFRI) is developed across four pillars: measurement, capital aggregation, disclosure and supervisory coordination. Each pillar is classified through structured criteria and a common evidence hierarchy. The index is applied to 30 financial conglomerates across six regulatory environments and the results are examined through descriptive comparison and external plausibility assessment. Findings The greatest divergence is found where accounting and prudential valuations are compared, sector capital rules are combined at group level and related disclosures cannot be reconciled directly. Higher scores are also found where supervisory responsibility is divided across jurisdictions. Lower scores are found where group scope is clearer and public reporting supports more direct comparison. Measurement and capital aggregation remain the most persistent sources of divergence, while disclosure and coordination concerns become stronger where reconciliation and responsibility are less clear. Research limitations/implications The study is limited to public documentary evidence and qualitative classification. Market outcomes, capital shortfalls, resolution events and supervisory actions are not tested. No causal or predictive relation is established between RFRI scores and financial distress. The findings should therefore be interpreted as evidence of comparative regulatory divergence rather than firm weakness. Future research may examine whether higher scores are associated with supervisory responses, market reactions or financial outcomes. Practical implications The RFRI can be used by supervisors, group risk functions, audit committees and users of public reports to identify where further interpretation is required. Review can be directed towards measurement differences, capital transferability, disclosure reconciliation and supervisory responsibility. The pillar structure can also support clearer allocation of review duties across finance, actuarial, treasury, reporting and regulatory functions. The index is intended to guide documentary review rather than replace confidential supervisory assessment. Social implications The clearer interpretation of group capital and risk information can support confidence in the supervision of financial conglomerates. Improved reconciliation across banking, insurance and accounting reports may help reduce misunderstanding among regulators, investors and other users of public information. Better identification of reporting and coordination gaps may also support more informed oversight of institutions that operate across sectors and jurisdictions. The index therefore contributes to clearer public understanding of how complex financial groups are assessed. Originality/value A recognised policy concern is converted into a structured qualitative index based on public evidence. The study brings accounting, prudential capital, disclosure and supervisory coordination into one comparative framework. Each pillar classification is linked to legal, supervisory or corporate sources and the method is applied across 30 groups in six regulatory environments. The value of the study lies in providing a repeatable supervisory reading method without presenting regulatory divergence as proof of insolvency, distress or failure.
Purpose Public development banks (PDBs) have re-emerged as pivotal instruments for industrial policy, green transition and regional rebalancing. Yet the effectiveness of PDBs depends not only on mandates and resources but on the local banking architecture: how credit is originated, priced, monitored and transmitted to place. This is the purpose of this study. Design/methodology/approach This paper compares two centralised PDBs – the Bulgarian Development Bank and the British Business Bank – with Germany’s dense, decentralised savings and cooperative banking pillars (Sparkassen and Volksbanken–Raiffeisenbanken) supported by Kreditanstalt für Wiederaufbau. This paper shows that Bulgaria and the UK confront a scale-and-proximity constraint: small, national balance sheets delivering primarily via programs and intermediaries versus large, locally embedded networks practicing relationship lending in Germany. Findings “Like-for-like” comparisons to single German local banks underscore the point: individual cooperative or savings banks can match or exceed the balance-sheet size of national PDBs while serving compact regions. The analysis implies that market-shaping outcomes require decentralised, spatially rich banking architecture. Research limitations/implications The study assesses institutional capacity and credit-transmission architecture rather than realised borrower- or regional-level outcomes and therefore does not identify causal effects of decentralisation on economic performance. Cross-country differences in regulation, ownership and institutional history also constrain direct comparability, while documentary evidence captures formal structures more readily than informal lending practices. Future research should combine institutional analysis with borrower-, loan- or regional-level data and practitioner interviews to examine how functional distance, decision rights and relationship-lending capacity affect credit creation and developmental outcomes across different banking systems. Originality/value This paper concludes with policy options to restructure delivery, so limited national balance sheets yield outsized place-based effects.
Purpose Although there has been a rapid rate of expansion observed in the domain of Islamic banking, there remains an inconsistent degree of institutionalisation of Islamic corporate social responsibility (ICSR). The reason is that a higher priority level has been placed on contractual and financial compliance by existing CSR and Shariah governance models, rather than broader socio-economic aspects. The purpose of this study was to develop an ICSR framework to assess the capacity of existing Islamic banking institutions to institutionalise ICSR through relevant governance mechanisms and Islamic social finance instruments, while examining their relationships with socio-economic outcomes. Design/methodology/approach In this investigation, a qualitative multiple-case study design, which involved both Maybank Islamic (Malaysia) and Bank Syariah Indonesia (Indonesia), was employed. Specifically, semi-structured interviews were conducted with a total of 20 purposively selected senior informants, with 10 from each of the two institutions, who were directly involved in the process of ICSR governance and implementation. The interviews, which ranged between 60 and 120 min, were triangulated with corresponding institutional and sustainability documents. After collecting the data, a thematic content analysis was performed through the NVivo software, which incorporated iterative coding, intercoder verification, participant validation and cross-case comparison to identify relevant patterns of ICSR institutionalisation and socio-economic value creation. Findings The findings revealed a clear hierarchy of ICSR institutionalisation, wherein zakat represented the most formally embedded instrument, supported by Shariah oversight, structured procedures, auditing and reporting. Meanwhile, voluntary instruments, including sadaqah and infaq, and developmental instruments, such as qard al-hasan and waqf, exhibited weaker and more fragmented degrees of organisational integration. Four differentiated socio-economic outcome clusters were associated with the above instruments, namely, immediate relief and redistribution (zakat), community trust and relational legitimacy (sadaqah or infaq), economic empowerment (qard al-hasan) and long-term or intergenerational welfare (waqf). Importantly, the interview results demonstrated an institutionalisation–impact paradox, in which instruments associated with greater long-term developmental potential were not equivalent to those most strongly embedded within existing structures of governance. Practical implications A policy-relevant framework was provided for existing Islamic banking institutions, regulators and Shariah boards to strengthen the governance, coordination, measurement and reporting aspects of relevant ICSR instruments that were often under-institutionalised. The proposed framework could also inform the development of Shariah-specific social responsibility indicators that were aligned with the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), which could enable more substantive and comparable assessment of ICSR beyond conventional CSR reporting processes. Originality/value Islamic ethical underpinnings, Shariah governance structures, Islamic social finance tools and various socio-economic outcomes were incorporated in this study into a consolidated and empirically grounded framework. Particularly, it was demonstrated that there were varying levels of institutionalisation and socio-economic value observed in existing ICSR instruments, which highlighted the existence of an institutionalisation–impact paradox. As such, there was a deeper understanding of how Islamic obligations are converted from religious teachings into actual organisational practice and developmental value.