
ABSTRACT We reviewed the most recent meta‐analytic literature on the criterion validity of predictors of job performance used in personnel selection. The overreliance on concurrent incumbent studies leads to meta‐analytic estimates based on data collected in conditions with non‐representative stakes and an inability to estimate and correct for range restriction based on credible information, obstructing the estimation of operational validity in actual selection contexts. Therefore, we argue that we do not need more meta‐analyses. First, we need primary studies that actually provide estimates of operational criterion validity. On a positive note, we observed increasing attention in meta‐analyses to heterogeneity of results, publication bias and open science. There is room for improvement in terms of attention to the quality and operationalization of predictor and performance measures, and reflection on the quality of the evidence. Given these issues, our stance is that the current body of research does not allow drawing firm conclusions about the criterion validity of predictors of job performance in actual, operational selection settings. To move forward, we provide recommendations for reviewers, editors, and authors of primary studies and meta‐analyses on predictors used in personnel selection.
ABSTRACT This study examined whether professional recruiters revise their hiring decisions after receiving external advice under cognitive conflict, that is, when advice contradicts their initial evaluation. In a between‐subjects experiment, 1,208 recruitment professionals evaluated two candidates, made an initial hiring decision, and then received advice whose source (human expert vs. algorithmic recruitment system, ARS), accuracy (accurate vs. inaccurate), and number of advisors (one vs. two) were manipulated across eight conditions. Results revealed widespread egocentric advice discounting. Although trust predicted advice utilization, a trust–reliance paradox emerged: recruiters reported lower trust in the ARS yet were behaviorally more influenced by it. Convergent advice was most influential, and exploratory analyses suggested that inaccurate advice degraded decision quality more than accurate advice improved it. Findings underscore the need for calibrated reliance in AI‐assisted selection.
ABSTRACT Past‐behavior questions prompt interviewees to recount past work experiences as stories. Telling a good story, however, typically relies on feedback from the audience. In asynchronous video interviews (AVIs), which lack real‐time interaction, interviewees often produce extended responses , continuing to speak after an identifiable point of closure in their response. This behavior may be influenced by longer response‐time limits and the absence of interviewer feedback. Using data from 114 mock AVIs, this study examined the prevalence and antecedents (individual differences) of extended responding, its content (i.e., disfluencies and storytelling), and its consequences for interview evaluations (i.e., performance, engagement, persuasiveness) and honest impression management. Over 75% of participants produced at least one extended response. Emotionality was positively associated with extended responding. Compared with initial responses, extended responses included more pauses but not more fillers. Extended responses contained more utterances about results and values/opinions, whereas initial responses contained more situational and task/action utterances. Extended responding was positively related to honest self‐promotion. Performance and persuasiveness ratings were higher for initial responses than for overall (initial + extended) responses. While extended responding is common in AVIs, it appears to provide limited benefits and was associated with less favorable performance and persuasiveness ratings.
ABSTRACT Leadership selection is typically attributed to ability, performance, and dispositional advantage. Yet evaluative processes may also reflect how individuals experience and engage with their work over time. We tested whether early happiness at work prospectively predicts selection into objectively assigned leadership roles under formalized selection and pronounced role scarcity in the Korea Military Academy. First‐ and second‐year cohort cadets ( N = 444) reported happiness at work in 2023, and competitive leadership appointments were assessed approximately 2 years later in the fourth year. Leadership positions comprised roughly 4% of each cohort. Penalized logistic regression showed that higher happiness at work predicted a greater likelihood of leadership selection (OR = 1.68, 95% CI [1.04, 2.72]), controlling for baseline cumulative performance score, gender, and cohort. Among the subcomponents, affective organizational commitment significantly predicted leadership selection (OR = 1.77, 95% CI [1.07, 2.94]), whereas engagement (OR = 1.63, 95% CI [1.00, 2.66]) and job satisfaction (OR = 1.34, 95% CI [0.85, 2.14]) did not reach the conventional 0.05 significance threshold. Taken together, the findings suggest that early happiness at work may play a meaningful role in shaping who is ultimately selected into positions of authority, even in systems structured to privilege meritocratic evaluation.
In this comment, we discuss the article by K & ouml;nig et al. ("Why Personnel Selection Should Target Job Performance AND Well-Being") and describe our view on employee well-being in the context of personnel selection. We appreciate several of K & ouml;nig et al.'s suggestions: they highlight how incorporating measures into the selection process that enhance person-job or person-organization fit, or may stimulate self-selection, could ultimately enhance employee well-being. We argue, however, that their approach of including personal dispositions as predictors of experienced well-being can be problematic for several reasons. We suggest that organizations that want to enhance employee well-being through a selection approach should adopt a different strategy: Organizations could orient their selection procedure towards personal dispositions that protect the well-being of other members within the organization.