
PurposeAcute inpatient mental health services operate under systemic pressures that limit staff capacity for reflective, relational work. Reflective practice groups (RPGs) are widely recommended, yet the experiences of healthcare assistants (HCAs) – who deliver much of the day-to-day relational care – remain underexplored. This paper aims to examine HCAs’ experiences of ward-based RPGs on two male acute inpatient wards and how organisational conditions shaped opportunities to attend and participate. Design/methodology/approachSeven HCAs who had attended at least one RPG in the previous six months participated in semi-structured interviews. Data were analysed using Framework Analysis. Routine operational records of RPG delivery (attendance and cancellations) across a 57-week period were also reviewed descriptively to contextualise qualitative insights. FindingsHCAs experienced RPGs as a rare, protected space offering emotional decompression, reduced isolation and more empathic understandings of patients. Participants described subtle changes in practice, including reduced reactive responding and greater consistency. Engagement was influenced by confidence, psychological safety and mixed views on leadership presence. RPG delivery was operationally fragile: across 57 weeks, only around one-third of scheduled sessions occurred, with cancellations largely linked to staffing shortages and ward acuity. Originality/valueThis evaluation provides a focused examination of HCAs’ experiences of RPGs in acute inpatient settings. Findings highlight RPGs as a valued but vulnerable resource that helps restore reflective capacity under operational pressures, underscoring the need for organisational conditions that protect reflective time.
Purpose This study aims to develop a systemic and decision-oriented model to understand the organisational factors influencing the use of restrictive measures, namely, seclusion and mechanical restraint (SMR), in psychiatric inpatient mental health services. Design/methodology/approach This study uses a modelling-based approach to identify and structure the organisational factors associated with the use of SMR in psychiatric inpatient mental health services. A qualitative coercion descriptive model (CD-Model) was constructed from literature reviews and surveys to identify influencing factors. These factors were then weighted through pairwise comparisons to develop a coercion quantitative model (CQ-Model) assessing hospitals’ capacity to minimise the use of SMR. Findings The CD-Model identified four hierarchical dimensions and 24 factors influencing coercion-related decision-making but lacked synthesis for decision makers. The CQ-Model addressed this by introducing 11 supervision indicators, derived through mathematical aggregation, providing a framework for organisational analysis. Research limitations/implications This study proposes a model-based approach that combines qualitative and quantitative methods to structure and prioritise organisational factors influencing restrictive practices. By integrating interdisciplinary expertise, the framework provides a structured and quantified representation of these factors, supporting organisational diagnosis and planning in mental health services. Practical implications The proposed framework offers a decision-support tool for organisational actors and decision makers in mental health services, linking influencing factors to specific organisational levels. The model can support institutional audits, supervision processes and quality-improvement initiatives aimed at reducing the use of SMR. Although based on data from France, the scalable structure of the framework may provide guidance for other healthcare systems. Originality/value This study introduces an original model-based approach that uniquely integrates both qualitative and quantitative methods to provide a systemic and structured analysis of coercive measures in mental healthcare, offering a scalable framework applicable across different organisational settings.
Purpose This is a companion piece to our paper on the theory and application of self-agency in the therapeutic community. In that paper we discussed the concept of self-agency, how it may be reduced in people with complex emotional needs and optimised within the therapeutic community. This paper aims to reflect on the experience of being in therapeutic communities with reference to the theoretical constructs described there. Design/methodology/approach This paper contains reflections from a staff member and group member on self-agency, based on their experience in Therapeutic Communities. Themes were generated from a number of collaborative reflective conversations. Findings We found many aspects of the therapeutic community (TC) experience had salience to the concept of self-agency. This included how the group was set up and run, staff stance, emergence of self-agency within the TC and consequences for self-agency development. Originality/value Our experiences align with theoretical concepts described in the companion paper and can be used to generate further hypotheses about the development and importance of self-agency for progress in complex emotional needs.
Purpose This paper aims to understand the lived experiences of people with severe mentalillness navigating the benefits system. The UK’s benefit system has undergone considerable changes over the last decade. The current system is associated with psychological distress for claimants, with psychological processes (e.g. stigma) hypothesised as mechanisms underlying distress. Design/methodology/approach Individual interviews were conducted with 10 people who have claimed benefits over at least five years due to their severe mental health difficulties. Transcripts were analysed using Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis. Findings Three superordinate themes “the system has become hostile,” “traumatised by contact with the system,” and “trapped: stuck between a misunderstood and unwanted reality and the longing for change” were generated. Distress associated with the system focused on experiences of powerlessness, stigma, shame and forced disclosure, deception and threat, inaccessible processes and misunderstandings of mental illness. Participants described increased symptoms of mental illness and felt unable to exit the system, despite longing for work and ’normality’. Originality/value The current system is not equipped to support individuals with severe and enduring mental health difficulties. Significant changes within the system are required to reduce the traumatic impact for these people. Both individual and community interventions may help services to become more trauma-informed.
Purpose - Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is highly prevalent among individuals receiving treatment for substance use disorders (SUD), yet trauma-focused interventions are not consistently integrated within residential addiction services. This study aims to evaluate the feasibility of implementing the Human Givens Rewind technique within a residential addiction treatment programme and to explore preliminary changes in core PTSD symptom domains. Design/methodology/approach - A quantitative practice-based pilot study using a pre-post design was conducted within a 12-week residential addiction service. Residents were screened for PTSD using DSM-5 criteria supported by the PTSD Checklist for DSM-5 (PCL-5). Participants meeting criteria for probable PTSD were offered the Rewind intervention. Pre-post symptom change was assessed using construct-aligned measures of intrusion, avoidance and hyperarousal. Paired-samples analyses and effect size estimation were conducted for participants with complete data sets. Findings - Structured trauma screening identified probable PTSD in 32.4% of assessed residents. Complete pre-post data were available for 13 participants. Significant reductions in PTSD symptom severity were observed [t(12) = 5.94, p < 0.001], with a large within-subject effect size (Hedges' g = 1.55). No adverse events requiring discontinuation were recorded. Research limitations/implications Interpretation is limited by the small sample size, absence of a control group and short-term follow-up. Findings should be considered preliminary and require replication in controlled studies incorporating longitudinal outcomes. Practical implications - The findings suggest that structured trauma screening and delivery of a brief imagery-based intervention can be feasibly integrated within residential addiction services when supported by supervision and containment structures. Social implications - This study aims to highlight the issue of trauma in SUD populations, and examines the feasibility of implementing a structured assessment and treatment for PTSD with the aim of improving outcomes for those seeking SUD treatment. Originality/value - This study provides preliminary practice-based evidence regarding the feasibility of implementing the Rewind technique within a residential addiction treatment setting, addressing a gap in the current literature.