
Introduction Richardson et al. contest the identity of oyster species that historically constructed subtidal shellfish reefs in South‐East Queensland, Australia, suggesting that “ historical drift/dredge oysters may have been misidentified as S. glomerata .” Objectives To provide historic scientific evidence pertaining to subtidal shellfish reefs along Australia's east coast, to help inform the conservation status of Saccostrea glomerata . Methods Evidence provided by Richardson et al. is reviewed and compared to historical evidence. Results Evidence provided by Richardson et al. remains consistent with historic evidence that S. glomerata is capable of recruiting to both intertidal and subtidal habitats. Increased historical survival of S. glomerata spat in subtidal areas prior to 1893 was probably due to what observers at the time described as “astronomical recruitment,” facilitated by a lack of sedimentation and eutrophication. In contrast, subtidal spat settlement today is severely constrained by sedimentation and algal turfs, Queensland Unknown disease, and possibly also by relatively increased predation due to a potential Allee Effect. Conclusions The misidentification hypothesis appears to be built on a logical fallacy arising from shifting baseline syndrome.
Abstract Introduction Shellfish reef restoration occurs across diverse ecological settings. Techniques that perform well in one habitat or species assemblage may perform poorly elsewhere. Objectives We examined how field observations, constraints, and unexpected outcomes shaped restoration structures and developed Adaptive Restoration Engineering (ARE), a framework for iterative refinement and diversification of restoration systems. Methods We assessed 1081 remnant shellfish reef bommies across five Queensland sites and reviewed five restoration structures developed from 2018 to 2026 as practice‐based design pathways: chicken‐wire baskets, mild steel Robust Oyster Baskets, Stainless Steel Robust Oyster Baskets (SS ROBs), Quilted Oyster Doonas, and Living Oyster Gardens (LOGs). Project records, field observations, design modifications, and deployment outcomes were reviewed to identify constraints, drivers, and design responses. Results Remnant reef morphology showed reefs commonly formed discrete bommies rather than continuous platforms, supporting modular design. Field observations drove shifts from galvanized and woven mesh to mild steel and welded stainless steel. Observed burial and subsidence led to seeding racks, shell foundations, and LOGs, while mussel‐dominated recruitment led to SS ROBs where cohesive reefs had not formed before mild‐steel degradation. Handling, transport, and decentralized manufacture shaped unit size and fabrication techniques. These observations formed the basis of ARE, which links observation, driver identification, design response, implementation, and monitoring. Conclusions Multiple designs can be refined for contrasting settings rather than relying on a standard unit. ARE provides a restoration‐specific application of adaptive management for translating field observations into context‐specific design responses.
Abstract Introduction Herbivory by wild animals poses a significant challenge for revegetation projects in the arid southwest. Typical caging and fencing methods can reduce herbivory in small‐scale restoration projects but are often costly and can sometimes impair plant functioning. Reactive silicon (Si) may prove a promising alternative, as it is frequently induced in plants as a chemical defense against herbivory and is well associated with improved plant and soil health. Objectives This study examines the effects of Si supplementation on plant growth in a greenhouse setting and as an herbivory deterrent in a small‐scale restoration field study. Methods We measured plant height, cover, and biomass of plants supplemented and not supplemented with Si before and after exposure to herbivory. Results We found that Si supplementation did not reduce herbivory by field herbivores. However, before exposure to herbivory, plants supplemented with Si were significantly taller and wider than plants not supplemented with Si. Conclusion Si application can aid in increasing plant growth in a greenhouse setting prior to revegetation efforts, potentially improving establishment rates due to more vigorous and robust outplanted individuals.
Introduction The commercial native plant industry is increasingly used to supply plants for ecosystem restoration. Efforts to characterize this industry are needed to evaluate common practices and their ecological and evolutionary implications.Objectives We characterized industry practices for the production of Spartina alterniflora, a widely distributed and commonly restored wetland plant species in the United States, with a particular focus on practices that could affect evolutionary processes and thus genetic variation in the resulting stock.Methods We conducted interviews of commercial nurseries that produce S. alterniflora along the Atlantic Coast of the United States. For each nursery, we characterized key practices regarding sourcing, storage, grow out, and distribution. We also used qualitative coding techniques to document nursery social networks, key sources of industry uncertainty, and nursery local ecological knowledge.Results We show that the majority of the surveyed nurseries produce their stock from seed, rather than collection of adults or clonal production of cultivars. In addition, the majority of nurseries surveyed collected seeds from multiple sites, and generally from a broad area, consistent with best practices.Conclusions The surveyed nurseries follow many of the evolutionarily informed best practices in the scientific literature. Nursery social networks and concerns regarding industry stability were representative of the broader industry.
Abstract Introduction Southern Appalachian Red spruce‐Fraser fir forests are globally imperiled ecosystems with high potential for restoration under current climate and atmospheric pollution conditions. Geospatially informed site selection is an important step toward effective and lasting restoration. Objectives We aim to identify promising locations for Red spruce restoration in the Mount Rogers Highlands, Virginia (MRH); assess connectivity among extant forest fragments; and develop a map of which restoration techniques are required based on modern land cover and Red spruce canopy density. Methods We integrate climate, land use history, Red spruce canopy, land cover, and topographic data in a geographic information system to identify and prioritize Red spruce restoration sites. We use a least‐cost path analysis to identify corridors within priority areas that could connect extant forest fragments. Finally, we identify spaces suitable for four established restoration techniques based on land cover, extant spruce canopy, and Red spruce understory. Results Approximately twice as much area in the MRH is eligible for Red spruce restoration than is currently Red spruce‐dominant. Analyses identify specific regions where restoration could be initiated and what actions that can be taken to expand Red spruce canopy coverage and reconnect Red spruce forest fragments. Conclusion Integrating land use, land cover, climate, topography, and vegetation datasets can inform restoration actions in southern Appalachian spruce‐fir forests during a critical time for their resilience under a warming climate.