
Population goals can play a valuable role in wildlife conservation by providing benchmarks to track progress and allocate resources effectively. Goals are generally guided by what constitutes a "healthy" or otherwise desirable population level and can be set in relation to a variety of reference states. Common challenges to setting goals include data limitations, arbitrary baselines, and balancing ecological needs with societal values. We describe a comprehensive, data-driven framework for setting SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) population goals and demonstrate its application to native bird species in Canada. This framework builds on approaches used to set regional and continental population goals for different bird groups in North America, including the first national goals set for all birds in Canada in 2012. Since then, the availability of survey data has grown substantially, enabled by the compilation and standardization of data on the NatureCounts platform. Our approach adopts or adapts relevant existing national management or recovery goals, and otherwise sets trend-based goals as the highest among the historical (1970s), long-term average, or recent average index of abundance. We found that 42% of the 400 species for which we set goals were below their goals. Many of these species have experienced severe declines, and potential recovery to historical levels may take several decades. To facilitate and motivate progress on conservation, we have introduced interim targets for these species to reach by 2050, in line with the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. We had insufficient data to set goals for 51 species, highlighting the need for improved monitoring, especially of marine and Arctic birds. The approach we have developed for setting population goals can facilitate a strategic and data-driven approach to conservation and land-use planning at various scales.
. Multiple monitoring programs provide data on the distribution, abundance, and/or population trends of birds in Canada. These programs vary in design, scale, target species, timing, and objectives, which may include status assessment, evaluating specific management actions, or public engagement. To maximize the value of these disparate sources for conservation, the information they provide must be synthesized in ways that account for this variation. We present an approach to bring together trends from multiple sources to assess the national population status of birds in Canada for both individual species and species groups. We assessed the reliability of all available trend sources for a given species based on their geographic coverage, suitability for the species, and precision of resultant trend estimates. We then used the most reliable sources to describe long-term population trends, set quantitative conservation goals, and assess the current population status relative to those goals. We found that a few multi-species surveys provided the best information for most species, but targeted surveys were essential for species that are rare or difficult to detect in multi-species surveys. Despite birds being among the best monitored taxa, we only had high or very high confidence in 35% of species status assessments. We also developed an approach to synthesize trends across species with shared taxonomy or life history traits to identify potential conservation challenges or successes. Among the groups we analyzed, waterfowl and birds of prey had large increases on average since 1970, while grassland birds, aerial insectivores, and shorebirds experienced large declines. To make the results widely available to support conservation efforts, we developed a user-friendly web platform, The State of Canada's Birds, to present the resultant assessments and underlying data for the 463 species that regularly occur in Canada, together with aggregated trends of selected species groups. Our analytic approaches could be useful for assessing population trends for any geographic area or taxonomic group with multiple information sources. Enabling and maximizing the use of existing data, as well as making data and the interpreted products derived from those data more available, are foundational steps in addressing the biodiversity crisis.
Piping Plover (Charadrius melodus) was among the first species recognized as being at risk in Canada in 1978. Extensive efforts to recover the coastal population breeding in eastern Canada (C. m. melodus) at the northeastern edge of the species' range have been accompanied by intensive demographic monitoring. We analyze comprehensive data collected during 1996 to 2024 on population size, breeding productivity, and survival to examine sources of annual variation, and to evaluate response to recovery efforts. The two regional breeding subpopulations in eastern Canada (Gulf of St. Lawrence and southern Nova Scotia) remain below recovery targets for abundance, and near or slightly below productivity targets. Annual survival based on banding and resighting data from 2014 to 2022 (0.70 [95% CI: 0.66-0.74] for adults, 0.41 [0.35-0.47] for juveniles) was similar to earlier estimates from 1998 to 2004. Resighting efforts throughout the non-breeding season allowed for estimation of seasonal survival probabilities, showing generally consistent survival across seasons with a notable reduction for juveniles in their first fall. There was very little exchange of marked individuals between regions, but juveniles moved extensively within the Gulf. In the Gulf, higher productivity was related to warmer spring temperatures; in southern Nova Scotia, higher productivity was related to earlier hatch dates. Population change in southern Nova Scotia was also related to hurricane frequency, demonstrating the importance of extreme weather to small populations. After 30 years of intensive monitoring and recovery efforts, little has changed for Piping Plovers in eastern Canada: the Gulf subpopulation at the species' most northern limit may always be marginal and driven by local conditions; the southern Nova Scotia subpopulation, though demographically isolated, remains small but stable. Yet without recovery efforts, further declines and local extirpations of Piping Plovers resulting from coastal pressures would likely have already occurred. Range-edge populations such as this pose unique conservation challenges and may remain conservation-dependent in the long-term, but may also be particularly important to species persistence as the climate continues to change and ranges shift.