
Teachers' digital competence depends on how professional training is designed, yet it is unknown whether the order in which theory and practice are delivered affects outcomes. This trial tested whether delivery order changes primary school teachers' digital competence, confidence and readiness, and whether teaching experience and prior digital exposure moderate the effect. Methods: We conducted a randomised, three-arm trial with 300 in-service primary teachers in Azerbaijan (100 per arm; 30 cohorts). All arms received the same six modules, contact time and trainers, and differed only in order: Theory-First, Practice-First or Hybrid (alternating). Outcomes were measured by questionnaire and a blind-scored practical task, at pretest, posttest and six-week follow-up (retention: 95% at posttest, 85% at follow-up). Order significantly changed competency (pass), F(2, 281) = 14.83, p < .001. Practice-First and Hybrid teachers scored 0.38 and 0.48 points higher than Theory-First (d = 0.54 and 0.67), with no difference between them (p = .541). This held under all robustness checks (imputation, robust and permutation tests). The effect was strongest for novices (p = .042; Theory-First gain −0.05 vs about 0.8). Confidence (p = .030) did not survive multiplicity correction (fail). Readiness (p = .163), objective skill (p = .054) and moderation by prior exposure (p = .129) were non-significant (fail). At six weeks, the competency advantage shrank by 28% (Hybrid) and 50% (Practice-First) but persisted. Starting with practice, alone or interleaved, outperformed theory-first delivery at no extra cost, especially for early-career teachers. The evidence is strongest for self-reported competence.
The pandemic has had a significant impact on various aspects of society, including the delivery of Physical Education (PE) classes in schools. In the aftermath, the perspectives and learned experiences of Physical Education and Sports Teacher Candidates in implementing online PE practices have gained importance. Given this context, the present study aimed to explore the challenges and opportunities presented by online PE courses during this period. To achieve this, a descriptive qualitative approach was employed, combining qualitative content analysis and thematic analysis. The study involved 12 PE who participated in semi-structured interviews. The results revealed that the identified themes centered on the professional experience and reputation of PE, as well as the challenges and opportunities in delivering online PE courses. The findings suggest that PE are committed to their profession and are willing to adapt to new modes of teaching. The results also highlighted that online PE could serve as an alternative tool for promoting health and fitness, especially in times of future crises. Additionally, the findings provided insights for Physical Education Teacher Education (PETE) programs to integrate technology into their curricula to help pre-service PE teach effectively in online environments.
The rapid integration of technology into global education, significantly accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic, has necessitated urgent pedagogical innovation, particularly in Mathematics education. Given the persistent global challenge of under preparedness in foundational mathematics and the widespread prevalence of mathematics anxiety across diverse educational levels, there is a critical need for transformative teaching strategies that foster both competence and confidence. This quantitative review study (meta-analysis) examines the efficacy of the Flipped Classroom-Based Learning (FC) model as a potential solution to enhance student learning outcomes in this fundamental discipline. By synthesizing data from 23 primary studies involving a total of 2688 participants, this meta-analysis was conducted to address three main research questions, focusing on the effect sizes across various characteristics and moderator variables. Specifically, the study aimed to determine: (1) the overall effectiveness of FC on student learning outcomes in mathematics (including cognitive, affective-attitude, and skill/practice outcomes); (2) how FC's effectiveness differs according to context (geographic location, educational level, content domain, and implementation duration); and (3) the specific FC designs and teaching strategies utilized in the field. The findings from this review provide a comprehensive, evidence-based assessment of the FC model's potential and its necessary adaptations, thereby offering crucial guidance for educational researchers, practitioners, and policymakers seeking to optimize mathematics curriculum reform and improve student success in the digital learning environment.
Instructors looking to support personalized mathematics learning may provide access to generative AI tutoring tools. Few studies explore the effectiveness of these systems in classroom settings. This is particularly important in mathematics, where genAI is a shift from historic adaptive intelligent tutoring systems. We evaluated undergraduate algebra students’ (n=58) use of the Socratic generative AI tutor, Khanmigo, through a quasi-experimental mixed-methods study using survey, registrar, grades, and software usage data. One course section was assigned four Khanmigo activities throughout the semester (experimental), while the other was provided access and an introductory activity only (control). A Wilcoxon Rank Sum test showed that experimental students engaged in significantly more chats than control students (p<0.05), controlling for in-class activities. Instrumental help seeking was positively correlated with Khanmigo use, while intentions of seeking help from technology sources were negatively correlated with use. Khanmigo use did significantly predict mathematics grades after controlling for prior GPA and course section. Most students reported using Khanmigo for homework help and exam prep, though lack of visuals and the Socratic design limited perceived usefulness for some students. Integrating genAI tutoring systems into class activities and setting student expectations may improve the likelihood of students using them effectively for learning.
Gamification is widely used in Arabic language teaching, and prior reviews report positive effects without weighting them by the designs that produced them. This review synthesises 33 studies from the Web of Science Core Collection and Scopus, following PRISMA 2020. Both authors verified every extracted value against the full text, and quality was appraised with five design-matched instruments. Thirteen coding dimensions recorded the evidential status of each claim alongside the claim. Feedback and scaffolding (20 studies) and progression and mastery (19) were the dominant element clusters, ahead of competition (12), which was also the element most often deliberately withheld. Elements were documented in the text in 27 of 33 records. Fifteen studies measured no achievement outcome. Of the 18 that did, 8 reported a significant between-group effect, but only 1 paired that result with a consistent effect size and no reporting defect. Conclusions exceeded the executed design in 18 records, 11 of which measured no learning outcome at all. The variety of Arabic taught went unstated in 26 of 33 studies. The evidence supports claims about engagement more securely than claims about attainment.