
Purpose Our study investigates whether the adoption of Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions (AAOIFI) accounting and auditing standards influences income smoothing behavior in Islamic Financial Institutions (IFIs) operating in the Middle East and North African (MENA) region. In particular, we examine whether Financial Accounting Standards (FASs) affect earnings behavior differently from International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) and whether institutions jointly applying AAOIFI accounting and auditing standards exhibit different income smoothing behavior from institutions not applying AAOIFI auditing standards. Design/methodology/approach Using a sample of IFIs from 2013–2018, we employ a multi-method approach combining earnings variability, benchmark-beating tests, and a classification of income smoothing into artificial, real, and natural categories. Findings Our results indicate that IFIs applying AAOIFI FASs exhibit a higher likelihood of income smoothing and lower earnings volatility compared to IFRS-adopting institutions. Institutions jointly applying AAOIFI accounting and auditing standards also exhibit a positive association with income smoothing. However, this association is weaker and less robust across alternative specifications than that observed for FASs. Practical implications Our findings indicate that regulators, auditors and Sharia governance bodies should require transparent, comparable disclosure of reserve movements and other stabilization mechanisms. Such disclosure can help investors and investment account holders distinguish sustainable performance from reporting-induced stability. Originality/value This study provides novel cross-country evidence on AAOIFI standards and income smoothing in IFIs. By separately examining FASs and the joint application of AAOIFI accounting and auditing standards, we extend the Islamic finance and emerging-market accounting literature.
Purpose This study examines whether internal audit quality (IAQ) is associated with lower income-increasing discretionary accruals and improved financial reporting quality (FRQ) in an emerging market with uneven regulatory enforcement. Design/methodology/approach Survey-based measures of internal audit (IA) competence, independence and work performance are combined with archival data from non-financial firms listed on the Dhaka Stock Exchange. FRQ is proxied by signed discretionary accruals from the performance-adjusted modified Jones model (Kothari et al., 2005), and interaction models examine variation across reporting-pressure and governance conditions. Given the cross-sectional design, the findings are associational rather than causal. Findings Higher IAQ is associated with lower income-increasing discretionary accruals. Competence is the attribute primarily associated with this relationship, whereas independence and work performance show no separate association once modelled jointly. The association is stronger among loss-making firms but weaker where audit committee independence is high, a pattern consistent with substitution between IA and audit-committee monitoring, though the interaction is only marginally significant. Evidence on audit committee financial expertise is weaker and is treated as suggestive. Practical implications In emerging markets, the findings highlight the importance of IA expertise, certification and training, and suggest that formal structural arrangements alone may be insufficient for reporting quality. Originality/value The study provides emerging-market evidence consistent with IAQ acting as a substantive monitoring mechanism rather than symbolic compliance, with its disciplining association most evident under higher reporting pressure and weaker structural oversight.
Purpose This study examines how readability and textual similarity evolve and interact in integrated reports, investigating whether narrative accessibility and textual standardisation are distinct characteristics or interconnected features of institutionalised reporting practices. Design/methodology/approach A longitudinal panel of 1,393 firm-year observations from South African listed companies over 2015–2024 is analysed. Readability is measured using Flesch Reading Ease, and textual similarity using cosine similarity between consecutive reports. Fixed-effects panel regressions are supplemented by governance-excluded similarity measures, first-difference models, persistence analysis and an alternative readability measure. Findings Readability declines over time, while textual similarity remains high, with no consistent upward trend. Textual similarity is positively associated with readability, indicating that narrative continuity can coexist with greater accessibility. However, this association becomes insignificant when governance-related disclosures are excluded, suggesting that it is concentrated within a highly institutionalised disclosure domain characterised by recurring reporting requirements and stable narrative structures. Additional analyses confirm the persistence of textual similarity and robustness of the main findings. Originality/value This study extends research that has largely examined readability and textual similarity separately by demonstrating that these characteristics are interrelated and that their association depends on the disclosure domain. Greater readability can coexist with substantial textual standardisation, complicating the interpretation of this as an unambiguous indicator of disclosure quality or transparency. The findings highlight the importance of distinguishing narrative accessibility, textual standardisation and substantive informativeness when evaluating corporate disclosure.
Purpose This study critically examines how private sustainability engagement functions as a form of dialogic accountability when Nordic institutional investors interact with publicly listed companies in a state-dominated emerging economy, challenging the implicit universalism of consensus-seeking engagement models. Design/methodology/approach The study employs qualitative content analysis of Nordic investor engagement reports documenting extended interactions with Egyptian financial and telecommunication companies. Legitimacy theory, neo-institutional theory and dialogic accountability provide an integrated lens for examining information exchange and corporate answerability. Findings Private engagements centre on political connections and human rights risks, with documented response patterns consistent with a prioritisation of political licence to operate over substantive answerability to international investors. The documented engagements record evidential burdens preventing independent verification. The response patterns across both cases constitute dialogic deadlock – a structural ceiling where genuine accountability exchange is foreclosed. Originality/value Empirically, the study provides an in-depth qualitative content analysis of investor-side engagement reports, documenting the sustainability information Nordic investors seek in two Egyptian private engagements and the patterns of corporate response. Theoretically, it proposes political licence and audience primacy as concepts for interpreting the documented exchanges and specifies the contextual conditions under which audience hierarchy may shift toward audience primacy. Conceptually, it theorises dialogic deadlock as a structural outcome arising where legitimacy incentives prove insufficient and the preconditions for genuine dialogic accountability are constitutively absent.
Purpose This paper focuses on an emerging market and investigates whether a firm’s audit engagement with a Big4 accounting firm is associated with foreign individuals’ investments. We hypothesize that Big4 accounting firms’ reputation may function as a heuristic trust signal for these investors. Design/methodology/approach We tested our hypothesis by utilizing 225 non-financial firms listed on Borsa Istanbul. The dataset covers 2005 to 2023 and contains 3,590 firm-year observations. Findings Our empirical evidence indicates that foreign individuals are more likely to invest in BIST-listed firms audited by a Big4 accounting firm (AF). Our results are consistent with prior studies showing that accounting firms’ reputation is associated with investors’ decisions. Our robustness analysis suggests that Big4 AFs’ reputation may lose importance when public governance declines. Research limitations/implications The primary limitation of this research is that investor-level data are not publicly available. We also did not incorporate audit-firm-level variables such as expertise and number of partners. Practical implications Our study has implications for managers, policymakers and accounting professionals. Managers seeking to signal trust to foreign individuals may consider the positive association between Big4 AF engagement and foreign investment. Social implications Policymakers should consider measures to enhance public governance quality to attract more foreign individuals to Borsa Istanbul. Big4 AFs should note that this reputational advantage weakens as public governance declines. Originality/value While prior studies have examined institutional investors’ and mutual funds’ preferences for Big4 accounting firms, this study contributes new archival evidence on foreign individual investors’ equity investment decisions in relation to Big4 engagement in an emerging market context.