
Established theories of the policy process explain important mechanisms of agenda setting, coalition formation, institutional constraint, policy transfer, and implementation. Their application to African cases, however, often leaves insufficiently specified how these mechanisms operate where formal state institutions coexist with customary authority, informal political networks, colonial institutional inheritances, transnational influence, and uneven administrative capacity. Drawing on research literature, policy documents, and analyses by national, regional, and international organizations, this paper assesses the explanatory reach of the stages heuristic, rational-choice approaches, the Multiple Streams Framework, the Advocacy Coalition Framework, institutional approaches, and policy-transfer theory. It argues that no single framework adequately captures the interaction among the contextual conditions that recur across the cases examined. The paper therefore proposes a contextually specified synthesis in which institutional pluralism, historical legacies, transnational authority, political incentives, and implementation capacity shape the operation of otherwise familiar policy-process mechanisms. This approach does not posit a uniform African policy process or reject existing theories. It identifies the conditions under which their concepts require combination, adaptation, and comparative testing.
Designing solar policies that effectively enable households to adopt rooftop solar photovoltaic (PV) systems remains a persistent challenge. Policy design scholarship explains household solar adoption through the alignment between policy instruments and target population attributes but pays limited attention to the residential contexts that enable or constrain households’ capacity to respond to solar policies. This study examines how parcel-level residential contexts shape households’ ability to adopt rooftop solar PV. Using data from Tallahassee, Florida, where residents share the same solar policies and citywide conditions, the analysis isolates the effects of intra-city variations in physical (e.g. tree density, roof condition, and housing density), socioeconomic (e.g. housing value, housing age, and renter composition), and regulatory (e.g. homeowner associations) contexts. Employing Firth logistic regression and hotspot analysis, the results show that physical and socioeconomic contextual factors are significantly associated with households’ adoption decisions and reveal a pronounced spatial variation in adoption potential across neighborhoods. The findings contribute to policy design scholarship by conceptualizing contextual variation as a diagnostic input to policy design, highlighting the importance of contextual fit. This study also suggests expanding the policy portfolio toward context-sensitive solar strategies that may better align policy tools with heterogeneous residential contexts.
This article examines how the calibration of policy instruments shapes disaster governance in Brazil’s National Social Assistance Policy (PNAS). In 2021, the policy incorporated disaster risk management references into its design, yet between 2020 and 2024, 75–90% of municipalities facing public emergencies carried out emergency-response actions, while only 14–46% undertook planning and preparedness activities. Drawing on a corpus of 79 federal policy documents issued between 2004 and 2025, which 21 established or specified disaster-related instruments, the article identifies the instruments, classifies them by the state resource they mobilize, and scores their calibration on coercion, automaticity, and compliance advantages. Preparedness is incorporated mainly through guidance with low coercion and no associated incentives. Response instruments, in turn, combine strong inducement mechanisms, as in the co-financing of the Service for Protection in Situation of Public Calamities and Emergencies, with operational requirements that are hard to meet when administrative capacity is most strained. The Action Plan, meant to support preparedness in this service, was provided for in the regulation but was never made a condition for federal co-financing. Because the evidence consists of design documents, the findings identify design-side conditions for implementation rather than their effects on municipal practice.
Public servants operate in a complex working environment, navigating 40 distinct factors while striving to create public value through their policy practices. This paper applies Covey’s Circles of Concern framework, a longstanding and widely regarded management approach, to explain how public servants can better control these influences upon their policy practice. In doing so it provides a guide for how public servant can enhance their ability to drive desirable public outcomes. Building on Covey’s argument that focussing on what you can control will lead to greater impact, the article argues public servants will enhance their capability to deliver public objectives if they first master the factors within their reach. This mastery will enable them to influence the expression of those factors as opportunities rather than barriers to public value creation. The paper finds individuals who recognize the constellation of factors and actively work on those within their control, will likely be more effective public servants and policy entrepreneurs.
Policy implementation under knowledge uncertainty requires governments to respond to evolving scientific evidence, professional knowledge, and implementation conditions. Yet, how institutional arrangements shape the use of diverse knowledge and its relationship with adaptive implementation remains insufficiently understood. This article examines these relationships in Indonesia’s COVID-19 response through a predominantly qualitative study combining a survey of 505 health workers in Depok, Surakarta, and Medan, six semi-structured interviews, document analysis, and policy process tracing. The analysis focuses on adjustments to diagnostic testing policies and workforce and healthcare service capacity. The survey identified multiple channels through which health workers contributed suggestions to policy discussions, including direct submissions to government (88 respondents), professional associations (87), and academic forums or conferences (61), with some respondents using more than one channel. Among the 138 respondents reporting contributions through these channels, 126 provided substantive follow-up responses, while 12 provided no substantive follow-up response. Of these 126 respondents, 42 (33.3%) reported no follow-up, 35 (27.8%) reported that their proposals remained under discussion, 22 (17.5%) reported incorporation into regulations, and 27 (21.4%) reported implementation. These self-reported findings indicate variation in follow-up but do not establish whose contributions shaped particular decisions. The findings indicate that, at the national level, professional organizations were formally involved in developing collaborative clinical guidance, providing an institutional basis for responding to evolving knowledge. However, local implementation depended on institutional capacity, resources, and socioeconomic and contextual conditions. Thus, knowledge integration may support adaptive implementation but does not automatically produce it.