
Increasing specialization has enabled marketing to develop deeper theoretical expertise, methodological sophistication, and cumulative knowledge across its subfields. However, specialization has also contributed to greater intellectual differentiation, creating boundaries that may constrain the movement and integration of knowledge across the discipline. Although recent scholarship has emphasized the importance of marketing discipline renewal, relatively little attention has been given to the conditions that enable increasingly specialized subfields to remain intellectually connected. This manuscript addresses this gap by advancing cross-subfield boundary permeability (CSBP) as a foundational enabling condition underlying marketing discipline renewal capability. Drawing on research on disciplinarity, interdisciplinarity, boundary-spanning theory, and dynamic capabilities, the manuscript develops a process framework explaining how permeable intellectual, methodological, and institutional boundaries facilitate communication, cooperation, coordination, and value co-creation across marketing’s subfields. These boundary-spanning processes enable knowledge to be shared, integrated, and combined, thereby strengthening the discipline’s capacity for continual adaptation and cumulative knowledge development. The framework further identifies relational, structural, and cognitive antecedents that foster CSBP, explains how CSBP facilitates the boundary-spanning processes that contribute to marketing discipline renewal capability, and shows how renewal capability can strengthen the conditions supporting future CSBP. In doing so, the manuscript provides a process-based explanation of how marketing can preserve the benefits of increasing specialization while maintaining the cross-subfield integration necessary for scientific and societal relevance.
Hunt’s (2022) claim that the marketing discipline is facing a ‘troubled trajectory’ has been followed by Mitchell et al. (2026) offering a theory-response for unification. This response is based on stakeholder and system theories with resource advantage and Service Dominant Logic theories integrating divergent subdisciplines. Mitchell et al.,is an attempt to provide solutions that apply academic theories to real world marketing problems.The solution requires leadership focusing on managerial relevance for implementation of theories. A case for the Marketing Science Institute (MSI) to play a major role, based on evidence that its Research Priorities have provided increasing influence in the articles published in leading marketing journals. Working with MSI, a Task Force could evaluate and offer strategic recommendations for addressing the troubled trajectory. Viewing marketing as an emergent phenomenon should encourage scholars to reconsider disciplinary boundaries.
The manifesto conversation in AMS Review asks how the marketing discipline will use its human and institutional resources to address its troubled trajectory, renew itself, and meet its responsibilities to its stakeholders. This paper argues that the question already names its own theory. The phrase human and institutional resources is the vocabulary of resource dependence theory, the organizational theory of how an entity survives by managing its dependence on the actors that control the resources it cannot supply for itself. Treating the marketing discipline as the focal organization, I order its stakeholders on a single continuum by the criticality and non-substitutability of the resource each controls, and I develop a displacement mechanism in which a stakeholder rises or falls as the criticality and non-substitutability of its resource change across eras. The troubled trajectory is recast as the observable signature of a period in which criticality diffused and substitutability rose, leaving no single resource to anchor the field. Renewal, on this account, is dependency management: re-anchoring the discipline on a resource that is both critical and least substitutable by adjacent fields, and re-subordinating borrowed resources. The account complements the stakeholder systems approach of Mitchell et al. (2026), supplying the diachronic engine that their synchronic completeness logic does not model, and it yields a principled basis for adjudicating among the candidates for marketing’s central focus.
This commentary advances that the next wave of service robot research should move toward a service-systems perspective on physical AI. Recent advances in generative and agentic AI are transforming robots from stand-alone service interfaces into embodied and networked actors that must be orchestrated with other physical AI deployments, virtual AI, employees, customers, digital platforms, and the physical infrastructure they operate in. I propose that future research should focus less narrowly on whether customers accept robots and more on where, how, and under what conditions physical AI creates value for customers, employees, firms, and society. Key research opportunities include studying robot-enabled service systems, backstage value creation, differences between special-purpose and general-purpose robots, orchestration as a core organizational capability, scalable innovation through no-code programming and fleet learning, and corporate digital responsibility (CDR), safety, and cybersecurity challenges of embodied AI. By reframing service robots as part of broader service systems, marketing and service research can develop richer theories of cost-effective service excellence (CESE), responsible deployment, and the human touch where it matters most.