
Background Depression is highly prevalent in primary care and frequently co-occurs with unhealthy lifestyle patterns. Although lifestyle interventions have shown beneficial effects for depression, their structured implementation in primary care is limited. Digital health tools may support the integration of such interventions into routine primary care. Aim To iteratively develop a personalized app-based mobile Health (mHealth) lifestyle intervention as an adjunct to routine primary care for depression, by exploring the needs and requirements of individuals with (past) depression (IDs) and primary care providers (PCPs). Design & setting A qualitative study using semi-structured interviews and focus groups in the Netherlands. Method We conducted 26 semi-structured interviews and three heterogeneous focus groups, involving a total of 34 participants, including 14 IDs and 20 PCPs. Data were analyzed using inductive thematic analysis. Insights from the qualitative findings were used to iteratively co-develop the intervention. Results Analysis revealed two main themes: (1) the intervention should reflect core elements of depression recovery, including self-management, a positive and person-centered approach, making lifestyle changes in small steps, and social connection; and (2) prerequisites for effective use, including integration within blended care, support for lifestyle goal setting, an accessible design, and attention for concerns such as data security. Conclusion Co-development of an app-based mHealth lifestyle intervention with IDs and PCPs proved feasible in primary depression care. Through an iterative, practice-based approach, key intervention elements were identified, integrated, and tested, resulting in a blended-care intervention tailored to the needs of both patients and providers.
Background Financial incentives are used in National Health Service (NHS) primary care to influence practice, yet their effects on General Practitioner (GP) behaviour and unintended consequences remain unclear. Recent UK GP contract reforms have changed the incentive landscape, highlighting the need for a contemporary, GP-focused synthesis. Aim To synthesise evidence on the impact of financial incentives on GP behaviour in high-income countries with predominantly publicly funded health systems, including incentives at GP, organisational or national level and with an effect on GP behaviour. We will assess whether effects differ across population and practice contexts, including implications for health inequalities. Design & Setting The review focuses on GPs in high-income, predominantly publicly funded healthcare systems where primary care is the first point of contact and gatekeeper to secondary care, and on evidence from 2010 onwards to reflect incentive structures. Method Seven databases will be searched from 2010 onwards. Records will be managed in EPPI-Reviewer using de-duplication, priority screening of titles and abstracts , and dual independent full-text review. Eligible studies include GPs (or outcomes attributable to GP behaviour) and financial incentives at individual, organisational or system level. Data will be extracted and combined by structural narrative synthesis, with meta-analysis if studies are comparable. Risk of bias will be assessed, qualitative evidence synthesised by meta-aggregation; and certainty graded using GRADE where feasible. Conclusion This review will synthesise the evidence on how financial incentives affect GP behaviour and health inequalities, informing clinicians and policy makers locally and nationally as incentive models evolve.
Background Commissioning and funding agencies have an increasing role in translating and implementing national policies to improve primary care access, whilst being sensitive to the needs of local contexts. Integrated Care Boards (ICBs) are meso-level commissioning organisations that sit in between national bodies and general practices in the National Health Service (NHS) in England. Aim In this study we examine the role of ICBs in facilitating improvements in access to general practice. Design & setting Qualitative rapid evaluation in three English NHS districts (ICB areas) focused on the role of the ICB in supporting access-focused improvements to primary care services. Method The study included semi-structured interviews ( n =32) with ICB and general practice staff and two focus groups with members of patient representative groups ( n =14). We used Braun and Clarke’s (2006) six phases of data engagement for data analysis. Our analysis was informed by Bate et al’s (2008) framework of six challenges in organising for quality. Site workshops ( n =3) with general practice staff supported refinement of findings as part of member validation. Results ICBs were found to perform three key roles in facilitating and implementing access-related quality improvement: 1) translational work to contextualise national funding priorities and objectives to the local level; 2) relational work to build trustbased relationships with practices and system stakeholders including local government, at-scale primary care providers, and patient groups; and 3) developmental work to establish infrastructure to support quality improvement, including knowledge-sharing and data analytics capacity. Conclusion Commissioners play a critical role in bridging national and local contexts to support quality improvement in primary care. The capacity and capability of ICBs to carry out this role are however limited by ongoing organisational restructuring initiated by national policy makers and by constrained resources.
Background Policy of the English National Health Service recently has encouraged greater diversity in professional roles. Alternative forms of ownership have developed in place of the traditional partnership model. Aim To investigate the impact of primary care structure on emergency hospital attendances. Design & setting Analysis of routine data for 766 general practice members of the English primary care sentinel network, 2019. Method Composite index analysis, using agglomerative hierarchical clustering applied to practice-level variables from the workforce Minimum Data Set, quality indicators, and hospital-linked routine pseudonymised primary care records. Logistic regression assessed whether odds of an emergency hospital attendance for an ambulatory care sensitive condition differed between clusters, controlling for patient-level factors. Results Two distinct clusters were identified. Cluster 2 (97 practices, 1.16 million patients) had 11% higher odds of an emergency hospital attendance than Cluster 1 (281 practices, 3.18 million patients) ( P <0.0001). Cluster 1 reflected a partnership training model having practice partners accounting for a higher proportion of total general practitioner FTE (63.4% vs 29.5%, P <0.001) and more practices providing training (OR 4.35, 95% CI 2.61–7.34). Cluster 2 was typified as multiprofessional, urban and more deprived having more encounters delivered by non-medical patient care staff (15.5% vs 5.7%, P <0.001), more practices in urban settings (OR 2.48, 95% CI 1.16–5.95) and greater deprivation (chi-square P <0.02). Despite workforce and care delivery differences, practice list sizes were similar across clusters. Conclusions These findings have implications for determining the optimal structure of general practices and the future of the partnership model.
Background Global healthcare systems face workforce shortages that disproportionately impact rural communities. A hybrid approach, blending in-person and virtual modalities, offers a scalable solution for resource distribution to hard-to-serve communities. Aim To compare healthcare utilization following hybrid urgent care encounters with traditional low-acuity encounters in primary care, urgent care and emergency departments (EDs). Design & setting A population-level, propensity-score matched, retrospective cohort study using health administrative data from Ontario, Canada. Method Patients who accessed a hybrid approach to urgent care between July 1, 2023, and June 30, 2024, were matched to other Ontario patients accessing care in traditional low-acuity settings. Post-visit outcomes, including ED visits, primary care follow-ups and hospitalizations, were analyzed at 30 days post index encounter. Results A hybrid approach to urgent care was associated with a higher absolute number of post-index encounter healthcare visits, overwhelmingly virtual follow-up encounters. Compared with low-acuity ED visits, hybrid urgent care was associated with lower odds of subsequent ED visits and in-person primary care visits. Among rural residents without a family doctor, hybrid urgent care was associated with 50% lower odds of an ED visit (odds ratio (OR): 0.50; 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.44-0.57), and 53% lower odds of an in-person primary care visit (OR: 0.47; 95% CI: 0.38-0.58) compared with initial low-acuity ED visits. Conclusions By diverting initial and follow-up encounters away from EDs and in-person primary care, a hybrid approach may increase access while shifting healthcare utilization away from strained local ED and primary care services in underserved communities.