
Rapid tranquillisation is frequently used to manage acute behavioural disturbance in psychiatric settings. Guidelines for safe and effective use of rapid tranquillisation exist, but anecdotal evidence suggests that adherence is poor, possibly due to lack of clarity and geographical disparity in recommended practice. We aimed to determine the clarity and consistency, both inter-rater and inter-guideline, of rapid tranquillisation recommendations.Guidelines from mental health trusts across England were obtained (N = 52), including those from 50 NHS trusts as well as from the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) and the Maudsley Prescribing Guidelines. These were reviewed by five researchers (all with medical background) using a commonly occurring fictional clinical vignette. Quantitative ratings and free-text comments were applied to each guideline by raters.Seven distinct management plans (reached by consensus among the five reviewers) were generated from the 52 different guidelines, indicating significant disparity in recommended practice within England. Agreement correlated modestly with subjective clarity ratings, but unanimous agreement betweenreviewers was present for only 19.2% of guidelines (n = 10). Qualitative analysis identified recommendations for guideline improvement, including obtaining past medical history and clear flow charts. Redundant and contradictory language and delegating decision-making to seniors were viewed negatively.Poor guideline comprehensibility and consistency negatively impact adherence and safe practice. Policymakers and NHS trusts should consider these findings when reviewing and updating rapid tranquillisation guidelines, with consideration being given to a universal national guideline being devised.
Violence and aggression are recurrent challenges in psychiatric inpatient care, including in psychiatric intensive care units (PICUs) and secure services, yet decisions about when incidents should be reported to the police remain inconsistent. This commentary revisits inpatient violence through the lens of Right Care, Right Person (RCRP). Most debate about RCRP has concerned community crisis response and the withdrawal of police from welfare checks; this paper extends the discussion to the inpatient ward. It argues that, while RCRP rightly seeks to prevent inappropriate police involvement, it may unintentionally reinforce under-reporting if it is interpreted as discouraging involvement simply because the alleged perpetrator is a psychiatric inpatient. The paper identifies three drivers of inconsistency: unclear thresholds for escalation; mental capacity being used as shorthand for criminal responsibility; and diagnostic framing that can distort judgements about accountability. It considers the consequences of under-reporting for staff, for patient victims, including patient-on-patient violence, and for perpetrators, and argues that organisational commitments to ‘zero tolerance’ acquire meaning only when translated into visible, proportionate and reviewable responses. The aim is not to increase police reporting for its own sake, but to support transparent, clinically informed decisions that recognise harm without defaulting to punishment, within a rights-based, least-restrictive and trauma-informed model of care. A practical, incident-centred checklist is proposed to structure ward-level decisions and make them reviewable.
Background : Non-suicidal self-injury (NSSI) in adolescents with emotional dysregulation is sometimes managed in psychiatric intensive care units (PICUs) using restrictive practices, such as physical restraint, chemical restraint, and/or seclusion. These practices can be distressing for young people and can adversely impact therapeutic relationships. A novel alternative approach increasingly being used in inpatient settings is positive behaviour support (PBS). Despite the demonstrated effectiveness of PBS in adult inpatient units, evidence from child and adolescent mental health services (CAMHS) PICUs remains scarce. Aim : We present a case study of a PBS intervention with a 16-year-old female presenting with emotional dysregulation and NSSI in an NHS CAMHS PICU. Methods : Multidisciplinary assessments informed a comprehensive case formulation and identified the functions of NSSI. From this, a PBS plan was cocreated with the patient, centred around three levels of interventions (proactive, active and reactive) dependent on the arousal level. The patient also completed the Difficulties in Emotion Regulation Scale – Short Form (DERS-SF) on eight occasions over a 10-week period. Results : The three main outcomes of the PBS intervention were: (1) a reduction in NSSI; (2) a reduction in the use of restrictive practice; and (3) increased use of adaptive coping strategies for self-regulation. Responses on the DERS-SF demonstrated an improvement in emotional regulation, and a review of Goal Based Outcomes at discharge demonstrated progress towards all personalised goals. Conclusion : This case study demonstrates the potential benefits of using a PBS intervention in a CAMHS PICU when delivered by a consistent and PBS-trained workforce.
Providing post-incident group support to healthcare staff following distressing events (sometimes called debriefing) is widespread and has been delivered in line with several models; however, the evidence-base for this form of staff support is in the early stages of development. In the UK, the Association for Clinical Psychologists has recently developed practice guidance for this purpose. Inpatient mental health settings present specific organisational contexts for debriefing processes and experience, yet there is little to no published evidence for the experience of staff working in this field. This study used a questionnaire design to understand staff experience of the support provided in a large inpatient mental health service in England. Staff views of immediate and follow-up support about accessibility, helpfulness, the reason for the request and the perceived effect of post-incident debriefs to support staff wellbeing in the workplace are summarised, suggesting that debriefing is perceived as helpful but that there are a range of barriers to accessing such support.
Aims: Ensuring a safe environment for individuals who self-harm is a crucial aspect of inpatient psychiatric care. In recent years, steps have been taken to reduce restrictive practices on mental health wards following episodes of self-harm. A structured, self-harm pathway was evaluated by Peasley Cross Hospital, Mersey Care NHS Foundation Trust. This pathway was adapted and implemented on an acute mental health ward in Gloucestershire. The aim of the current study was to explore patients’ experiences of the pathway. Method: 1:1 interviews were conducted with four patients who had engaged with the pathway. Interviews were transcribed and thematically analysed. Results: The analysis identified four major themes. Three of the these (‘change/breaking the cycle’, ‘multi-directional learning’ and ‘groupwork’) reflected positive feedback from patients. The fourth theme, ‘consistency/inconsistency’, reflected challenges in implementing the pathway with a large team on an acute mental health ward. Conclusions & implications for practice: Patients considered the self-harm pathway to be largely positive, supporting its use on acute mental health wards. Further evaluation is necessary to determine if the pathway has reduced levels of self-harm and restrictive practice on the ward. Future research may consider evaluating the pathway across various clinical settings.