
Abstract The issue of criminal liability for cruelty to animals lies at the intersection of law, morality, ethics, and biology. Its significance stems from the fact that cruelty toward defenseless animals is unacceptable not only from an ethical standpoint, but also poses a threat to society itself by fostering violence and cruelty toward humans. The experience of several countries suggests legal solutions suitable for adoption in Russia: clarifying statutory criteria distinguishing necessary from unnecessary suffering; prevention of animal cruelty; enhanced police–citizen cooperation; developing specialized competencies among law-enforcement personnel; maintaining offender registries; recognizing animals’ psychological well-being; and introducing additional sanctions (a ban on animal ownership for offenders and mandatory psychiatric evaluation). An analysis of the application of Article 245 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation reveals that the current regulatory framework governing humane treatment of animals does not meet the practical needs of combating such crimes, owing to the dominance in society of anthropocentric views of animals and of the environment as a whole.
Abstract The concept of Culture of Care fosters a research environment where lab animals and humans are cared for and respected. Several aspects, such as perception of suffering, time, perceived value of an animal, potential benefits of the research, and public opinion, might influence care for animals. The European Directive 2010/63/EU on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes has represented an advance in animal welfare standards and care. However, the question of how we care about animals in practice, and of why this debate is important to reflect on still exist. Therefore, we draw upon the case study of laboratory non-human primates, to illustrate how these tensions go from theory to practice. It illustrates the conflicts and emotions, by exposing the limitations of the standards and norms in the field. Debating care requires a more comprehensive notion of care, one that goes beyond normative decisions to enable care in practice.
Abstract Ethical oversight of animal research has historically prioritized vertebrate species, leaving the majority of invertebrate taxa largely excluded from formal ethical review and regulatory protection. Against this background, the objective of this review is to critically and reflexively examine interdisciplinary literature published between 2009 and 2025 addressing ethical, welfare-related, and regulatory aspects of invertebrate use in scientific research. We test the hypothesis that the continued exclusion of invertebrates from formal ethical oversight is not supported by current biological knowledge or by morally coherent ethical reasoning, thereby perpetuating ethically inconsistent research practices. A comparative critical perspective, situating the Brazilian regulatory framework alongside European legislative developments and emerging global ethical models at least for cephalopods and some crustacea was also performed. We conclude that excluding invertebrates from research oversight is no longer ethically or morally defensible, and that aligning national regulations – such as Brazil’s – with evidence-based, precautionary international frameworks is both necessary and feasible.
Abstract Research on endangered wildlife is vital to inform conservation, but may risk adverse welfare impacts. Following predictions that African wild dog ( Lycaon pictus ) populations could collapse as global temperatures rise, we initiated a thermal ecophysiology study to better understand weather impacts on this endangered species. Four institutional ethics committees approved our plan to surgically implant small (3.3g) thermal data loggers, using methods previously applied safely in similar species. One confirmed, and one unconfirmed, incident of adverse effects led us to refine our protocols and reduce target sample sizes. We experienced difficulties in detecting and responding to ill-effects, and our refined protocols approached the limit of what was possible with this wide-ranging species. Hence, any attempt to repeat our study would need to be carefully considered and strongly justified. Future projects performing novel invasive procedures on endangered species should recruit study animals gradually, using intensive post-surgery monitoring to inform recruitment decisions.
Abstract Private keeping of large wild cats remains contested in Europe. This qualitative study analyzes 19 semi-structured interviews with private keepers, accredited zoo staff, including veterinary and welfare expertise, and animal-protection NGO s in Czechia and Estonia. It examines how different actors justify or contest legitimacy and define good care. Across stakeholder groups, accounts of good care turn on the animal’s practical control over exposure, interaction, and daily routine. Three concerns recur: reliable retreat, refusal of husbandry or interaction without punishment, and routines that reduce rather than intensify anticipatory arousal. The two country contexts shape legitimacy. Czech respondents more often emphasize competence, legal compliance, experience, and calm daily outcomes, while Estonian respondents foreground precaution, institutional responsibility, public safety, and limited placement options for confiscated or unwanted animals. The article uses retreat, refusal, and routine as animal-centered practice indicators for comparing how care and control are justified and organized across private and accredited settings.