
Journalism as a profession has a centuries-long tradition behind it, which, since the mid-1800s, through the designation 'the fourth estate', has been linked to it as a prerequisite for representative democracy. The problem, however, is that democracy is a fundamentally debatable concept, and it can therefore be difficult to reach agreement on which quality standards to focus on. Journalists' tasks differ fundamentally depending on whether the democratic ideal (for example) is procedural, competitive or deliberative. Any specific journalistic product can be criticised on the basis of different ideals, and will therefore always appear unsatisfactory. This is a conundrum from which journalists cannot escape – a conundrum, it should be noted, which reflects the fact that we are constantly negotiating our understanding of democracy, thereby keeping the democratic horizon open. In this article, drawing on the work of Hartmut Rosa and Jacques Derrida, I shall argue that it is precisely these intractable problems that endow journalism with its value. Journalists must, of course, produce content that resonates with the public, but the underlying knots prevent journalists' work from being streamlined to a level where artificial intelligence could take over the task without any democratic value being lost. I would argue that journalists must learn to embrace these professional 'hard knots', because it is here that the profession finds its energy and its legitimacy.
This article examines the role that philosophical reflection can play in the acquisition and development of professional competences. The article distinguishes between philosophical reflection as a practice-oriented examination of concepts, values and assumptions, and Philosophy as an academic and institutional discipline. It is argued that philosophical reflection is neither identical to ordinary reflection nor to academic Philosophy, but can be understood as a problematising form of conceptual work that arises when the central concepts and values of a practice need to be understood and applied in specific situations. The article links this understanding to the work of professional education programmes on situated judgement and professional craftsmanship. Through a problem-based learning case from teacher training, it demonstrates how philosophical reflection can support students’ transition from proposing solutions to examining their understanding of the problem. The article also discusses the objection that philosophical reflection may contribute to an inappropriate ‘academisation’ of professional education programmes, but argues that philosophical reflection can, rather, enhance practical relevance when linked to specific practical situations. Finally, the article discusses philosophy as an academic and historical tradition serving as an institutional memory for reflection. It argues that philosophical traditions can offer a repertoire of questions, concepts and arguments that can support students’ development of critical thinking, problem understanding and professional judgement. The article thus provides a conceptual framework for understanding philosophical reflection as a practice-oriented and didactically scaffoldable dimension in professional education programmes.
This text summarises Uffe Juul Jensen’s keynote lecture at the ProFilViN conference in August 2025. Starting from the question of why society should care about philosophy and the philosophy of science, Jensen distinguishes three forms of Bildung: as action, as reflection and the search for truth, and as personal development through experience with societal relevance. He argues that philosophy can remain relevant to the professions only if it receives help from them in identifying the problems it does not currently address, and he gathers the point in the notion of a ‘philosophy just in time’: a philosophy that participates in the practice on which it reflects and changes itself through that participation.
This article develops a practice-ontological and care-oriented reconstruction of Bildung in professional education in an AI-mediated contemporary context. Building on a critique of the dominant competence-based approach, the article argues that a one-sided focus on measurable skills and adaptation to technological change risks reducing education to functional optimisation. Drawing inspiration from John Dewey's pragmatism and recent practice theory, normativity is understood as immanent in social and socio-technical practices. AI is analysed not merely as a tool for professionals, but as a co-constitutive participant in the normative organisation of practices. Against this backdrop, 'care' is introduced as a normative infrastructure that binds professional competences together and transforms the concept of competence into an understanding of personal development. The article argues that professional education must cultivate professionals as stewards of collective exploration and accountability within socio-technical practices. This shifts the focus from individual performance to a shared normative orientation, and from technological adaptation to democratically committed participation in shaping desirable socio-technical futures.