
Purpose To highlight discrepancies in the reporting and interpretation of studies included in a systematic review and meta-analysis comparing CAD/CAM and conventional surgical splints in orthognathic surgical planning.Materials and Methods A critical appraisal of three included studies by Chen et al. (2021), Hanafi et al. (2020), and Zinser et al. (2013) was undertaken by comparing the reported data with their original publications.Results Discrepancies were identified in sample sizes, group allocation, and outcome assessment. Additionally, the exclusive evaluation of maxillary accuracy in one study and the predominant focus on intermediate splints and maxillary landmarks were noted as important methodological considerations.Conclusion Accurate reporting of primary study characteristics and transparent data interpretation are essential for the reliability of systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Clarification of these inconsistencies may improve the validity, transparency, and clinical applicability of the reported findings.
Background The In-House clear aligner system has gained popularity with the advent of easily accessible In-House aligner fabrication setups. Presently, there are numerous commercially available thermoplastic aligner sheets on the market.Objectives To assess physicochemical properties, mechanical properties and microbial biofilm formation on three thermoformed commercially available clear aligner materials.Methodology Polyethylene Terephthalate Glycol, Polyethylene Terephthalate Copolymer and Polyurethane (PETG, PETC and PU) were tested for X-ray diffraction (XRD), Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC), Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR-ATR), UV–vis spectroscopy contact angle and tensile strength. Further, the aligner biomaterials were tested with microbial assays to assess biofilm formation.Results PETC demonstrated the lowest degree of crystallinity by exhibiting the highest full-width at half maximum. FTIR spectra showed the presence of – NHCOO – groups in PU, with hydrogen bond; this may enhance surface polarity and promote the adsorption of pigments. DSC results indicated that all three thermoplastic aligner materials could withstand the rise in temperature generated during thermoforming and intraoral temperature variations. UV absorption spectra of PETG, PETC and PU showed a similar pattern of absorbance. Contact angle measurements indicated the hydrophobic nature of the materials. Additionally, mechanical testing demonstrated the stiffness of the material in the order of PU > PETG > PETC. During the microbial evaluation, PETC exhibited the least biofilm adhesion compared to both PETG and PU.Conclusions Based on the combined thermal, mechanical and biological performance, PETC may be regarded as a promising candidate for In-House aligner fabrication; however, further clinical validation is required.
Purpose Health-insurance coverage for orthodontic treatment in patients with congenital disorders has expanded in Japan; however, many conditions remain unrecognized. Therefore, this study aimed to clarify the clinical characteristics and health-insurance eligibility for hereditary craniofacial anomalies in Japan.Materials and methods We included patients with congenital craniofacial anomalies (excluding nonsyndromic cleft lip and/or palate) who visited the Departments of Orthodontics at nine university hospitals up to December 2024. Disease names and insurance eligibility data were collected using an electronic data-capture system.Results Of the total 1,224 patients (640 males and 584 females) registered, 1,107 (90.4%; 95% confidence interval [CI], 88.6–92.0) were diagnosed with one of the 65 health insurance-covered disorders. The most frequent diagnoses were congenital absence of ≥6 teeth (343, 28.0%), followed by Down syndrome (102, 8.3%), craniofacial microsomia (67, 5.5%), craniosynostosis (53, 4.3%), cleidocranial dysplasia (50, 4.1%), Turner syndrome (46, 3.8%), osteogenesis imperfecta (36, 2.9%), Pierre Robin sequence (34, 2.8%) and achondroplasia (34, 2.8%). Among the 117 patients (9.6%; 95% CI, 8.0–11.4) with other disorders, 58 (4.7%; of total cohort) were eligible for health-insurance coverage owing to symptoms overlapping those of the 65 designated disorders or diagnosis of cleft lip and/or palate or jaw deformities. The remaining 59 patients (4.8%; 95% CI, 3.7–6.2) were ineligible for health insurance.Conclusion Although most hereditary craniofacial anomalies are currently covered by health insurance, many rare conditions are excluded. Continued data collection and expansion of participating institutions are essential for establishing a more comprehensive support system.
Objective The objective of this systematic review was to evaluate the accuracy between CAD/CAM and conventional splints.Search methods/Selection criteria Online databases (PubMed, Dental and Oral Science, CINAHL, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials) were systematically searched. Randomized and non-randomized control trials on human subjects were considered regardless of language or year of publication. Orthognathic patients in which both CAD/CAM and conventional splints present were included. The outcome assessed was accuracy of splints. The risk of bias in clinical trials was assessed using the Cochrane Collaboration tool. The meta-analysis was conducted using the RevMan software V.5.4. The outcome was estimated using weighted average difference and 95% confidence intervals (CIs). The studies’ heterogeneity was assessed using Cochrane’s heterogeneity test (I2 Test).Results A total of six articles fulfilling the inclusion criteria were included, out of which four were included in the quantitative synthesis. Accuracy of splints was analyzed in a total number of 203 patients. It was found that the CAD/CAM splints were more accurate in comparison to conventional splints. However, this difference was not statistically significant.Conclusions In this systematic review and meta-analysis, we assessed the accuracy of CAD/CAM splints in comparison with conventional splints among orthognathic patients, and we found no significant difference with any point in the three planes Frankfort horizontal, coronal and sagittal in the meta-analysis, but the position of the diamond in the forest plot is closer to the CAD/CAM side, thus favouring the prototype 3D-printed (CAD/CAM) splints, even though non-significant.
Objective The objective of this study was to clarify the structural characteristics of awareness of and attitudes towards aligner orthodontic treatment among orthodontists affiliated with 29 Japanese academic dental institutions.Participants and methods A questionnaire survey, including open-ended questions, of orthodontists affiliated with 29 Japanese academic dental institutions was conducted. Text mining of the verbatim responses was carried out, and following feature extraction, principal component analysis (PCA) and k-means clustering analysis were used to extract the latent structure inherent in the responses.Results Awareness of aligner orthodontic treatment was structured along the two principal axes of engagement and evaluative orientation. PCA showed that PC1 reflected the degree of engagement, whereas PC2 reflected differences in how respondents evaluated and expressed their views on aligner orthodontic treatment. K-means clustering (k = 5) identified five response patterns with varying degrees of engagement and evaluative orientation. Diagnostic accuracy and patient selection were more frequently emphasized than advantages such as aesthetics.Conclusions Awareness of aligner orthodontic treatment was multidimensional and characterized by differences in engagement and evaluative orientation. Perceived limitations were related primarily to diagnosis, patient selection, and treatment planning, rather than appliance features.