
From Aristotle’s scala naturae to the vast scales of animal agriculture, from cognitive scales to moral scales to deathly scales of devaluation, from the world-historical scale of what modernity called “progress” to the “permanent present” to which evolutionary scales condemn animals — in these and countless other ways, animal lives have been and continue to be shaped by different kinds of scales and their positions on them. Yet it is difficult to think about scales without the thresholds they skirt and implicate. In this opening essay, we approach the multiple scales through which animal lives are traversed by probing something of what may be involved in thinking animal life at the threshold. What does it take to cross — or be crossed by — a threshold? What does it mean to create and inhabit a scale? And what is at stake in becoming out-scaled? Articulating pathways through the interventions and conversations that make up this collection on animal scales, and at the same time complicating what we think we know of the politics of scaling, this essay explores how animal lives are made and unmade at the threshold between human mastery of the earth and the planetary upheaval of human ends; at the threshold between human and animal translation and unbridgeability of scale; and at the threshold where scale and perspective connect and disaggregate, giving way to the paradox of “an animal Anthropocene” as a riotous scrambling of scales.
Sue Donaldson and Will Kymlicka do us a great service in reminding us that when thinking about the relevant scales of our political relations with animals, it is crucial that we are not stymied by limiting ideas of unitary nation-states. We ought to embrace the very different and often overlapping political relations and affinities that humans share with animals. And these in turn invite thinking through what new forms of polity might facilitate human-animal flourishing. But in so doing, we must confront the first question of politics: how can these new forms of polity be rendered legitimate to the individuals subject to them? In this paper, I focus primarily on how such polities might be rendered legitimate to the human members who will be burdened by such new forms of community. This, I argue, invites consideration of the important interplay between the individual and collective scales of our political relations with animals, and the importance of cultivating solidaristic feelings of affiliation and sacrifice between members.
This interview with writer and director Andrea Arnold reflects on her documentary Cow (2021) in the wider context of Arnold’s distinctive body of work. Although Cow is her only documentary so far, it engages many of Arnold’s recurring themes and aesthetic sensibility. We discussed Arnold’s deep attachment to animals, in life and in art, dating back to her childhood; the importance of place and environment in her filmography; and the role animals play in her imagination as beings at once vulnerable and courageously yearning for freedom. Arnold resists theorizing her own work and described filmmaking as an instinctive, forward-moving process. We spoke about the tensions in her films between tenderness and toughness, beauty and cruelty, and between the commitment to not look away and the violence that such looking invariably yields. For Arnold, Cow is not an exposé or an animal rights film. Still, in its unflinching depiction of dairy’s repetitive cycles of calving, lactation, separation, impregnation and, eventually, death, Cow becomes a searing portrait of industrial animal agriculture.
This visual essay responds to Donaldson and Kymlicka’s “Scale Political”, by mapping different political scales in and around Knockvologan Studies, a space for art, literature, research and nature preservation, on the Isle of Mull (Scotland). Focusing on the agency of more-than-human animals and plants, it shows how different political relations, communities and encounters exist simultaneously in one place. The essay zooms in on nonhuman forms of resistance, solidarity, belonging, and building community, by looking at the practices of sheep, mink, plants using rocks and many others. Instead of explicating these different political scales in human words, the essay shows different forms of being and relating. As such, it invites the reader to attend more closely to nonhuman and multispecies forms of meaning-making, beyond human language and existing forms of democracy.
This article traces the figure of the insect across the cultural production of Greater Mexico to examine how bugs have shaped representations of gender and sexual dissidence from the colonial period to the present. Drawing on cuir/queer studies, animal studies, and trans* theory, I analyse the shifting meanings of mayates (figeater beetles), mariposas (butterflies), mariquitas (ladybirds), and cockroaches in literature, performance, and visual culture. I argue that while insects have historically functioned as symbolic markers of jotería and non-normative gender expression, contemporary trans* and cuir cultural production increasingly attends to their materiality, opening new ways of thinking about embodiment, affect, temporality, and memory. The first section reconstructs a genealogy of insect imagery in works by Juan Carlos Bautista, Luis Felipe Fabre, Luis Montaño, Rigoberto González, and others, showing how insects operate as liminal figures that both reproduce and destabilize heteropatriarchal norms. I then examine the work of Mixe performer Lukas Avendaño, whose engagements with the butterfly move beyond metaphor to imagine trans-species forms of belonging that connect muxeidad, migration, and queer futurity. Finally, I analyse Mexican trans* artist Lía García’s reclamation of the cockroach through “ternura radical” (radical tenderness). I propose that the cockroach functions as an affective chronotope through which touch and interspecies encounter render trans* memory palpable, challenging narratives that erase trans* histories and opening space for more-than-human cuir futures.