
This article examines the historiographical problem of municipal bankruptcy law, in particular, the legislative history, passage, and experience of the First and Second Municipal Bankruptcy Acts, called Chapter IX, over the period 1933-1979. First, I identify the problem. An authoritative account has been lacking, and it has been academicians of the law and economics (L&E) school who have sought to tell the story of the genesis of municipal bankruptcy law in connection with their advocacy for inclusion of municipal bankruptcy within the "creditors' bargain" paradigm. Legal history provides, however, better tools and a clearer lens for learning and telling the story of this law and its effects. Second, the article solves the problem by providing the first archivally researched history of the beginning and early evolution of Chapter IX. House Judiciary Committee chair Hatton Sumners was the key actor. The lengthy legislative process, punctuated by a pair of Supreme Court decisions, was a laboratory for new forms of relief under the Bankruptcy Clause for the insolvency in the 1930s of Texas irrigation districts, Florida towns, and elsewhere all types of political subdivisions that could not pay their bonds. The Municipal Bankruptcy Acts solved two conundrums, the "holdout problem" that had prevented voluntary restructurings, and the helplessness of State governments under the Constitution's Contract Clause. The device of composition with creditors succeeded politically. From 1933 to 1938 Congress legislated that device in the First and Second Municipal Bankruptcy Acts. L&E scholars credit freshman Florida congressman Mark Wilcox, who collaborated with a bondholders' group, as the critical actor, but it was Sumners who believed that the composition model was not only constitutional but also politically feasible. Sumners navigated through opposition that insisted "bankruptcy" required turnover of a debtor's assets in exchange for a discharge and that such legislation would destroy the credit market. Municipal bankruptcy did leave all assets in the debtor's hands; it granted a discharge; and the credit market survived. Chapter IX succeeded. And relevant to mass tort chapter 11 bankruptcy now, Sumners crafted the first and only statutory injunctive relief applicable in the case of an artificial entity for the protection of nondebtor third parties-here, all officers and inhabitants of a municipal debtor-against litigation by a debtor's claimants. President Franklin Roosevelt pushed the legislation to enactment in spring 1934. The Supreme Court invalidated the first Municipal Bankruptcy Act in 1936's Ashton case, but Justice Cardozo dissented, suggesting small changes that Sumners and Congress utilized in the Second Municipal Bankruptcy Act in 1937. Sumners then, in 1938, successfully argued the merits and constitutionality of the Second Municipal Bankruptcy Act before the Supreme Court in the Bekins case. Municipal bankruptcy law succeeded in effectuating municipal bond restructurings, and it lives in today's Bankruptcy Code as chapter 9, providing discharge of unpayable debt and as a platform for towns and taxing districts to negotiate such deals. Chapter IX worked in the past, and chapter 9 works today. The story demonstrates change over time, which is the essence of the study of history, with Sumners as the key actor.
In 2025, more than 200,000 Americans chose chapter 13 bankruptcy because they could pay their debts, not because they couldn't. They used it to cure mortgage defaults and address obligations that could not be discharged in any other proceeding. If a recent dissent from the Fourth Circuit is correct, every one of those cases was unconstitutional. This article examines the dissent's claim and rejects it. The article looks at the meaning of the Bankruptcy Clause of the Constitution ("Bankruptcy Clause") and concludes it authorizes Congress to enact bankruptcy laws that may be used by solvent debtors.1 First, the article considers the history of the Bankruptcy Clause and its application to federal bankruptcy laws from 1800 to 1978 with respect to a solvent debtor. In particular, the article focuses on individual debtors and the development of chapter 13, an option designed for solvent individuals. Next, the article provides a review of the statutory developments culminating in chapter 13. Also, the article surveys important Supreme Court interpretations of the Bankruptcy Clause with an eye to whether bankruptcy laws open to solvent individuals are constitutional. Finally, the article defends the current structure of the Bankruptcy Code allowing a choice for solvent individual debtors. The article clarifies the original meaning of the Bankruptcy Clause by looking to the words of its drafters, The Federalist Papers, the commentaries of Justice Joseph Story, and the expressions of the Supreme Court. The article warns that if the Bankruptcy Clause is a limitation on Congress's authority to draft laws on the subject of bankruptcies to be used by solvent persons, then chapter 13 (and, by extension, individual chapter 11 provisions) are unconstitutional.
Domestic commentary increasingly portrays chapter 11 as captured, coercive, and lawless, while reformers abroad treat it as the "gold standard" and borrow its core features. This article argues that the critics have mistaken the noise of a few salient cases for systemic failure and missed chapter 11's quiet competence: in most large cases, courts shepherd sophisticated parties through hard bargaining to consensual resolution. Responding to Professor Laura Coordes's proposed complex-case guardian and Professor Stephen Lubben's proposed revival of Chapter X, the article contends that both draw the wrong institutional inference. Chapter 11 is a structured renegotiation framework designed for settings where bargaining is expected to fail. It imposes guardrails to constrain opportunism while intruding as little as possible on private ordering. The hard question—whether parties are bargaining around the guardrails rather than in their shadow—is one judges must answer themselves, and chapter 11 gives them the tools to do so.