
What do workers think should determine their pay? And what do they think does determine their pay? We analyze prior surveys of U.S. workers and an original 2025 survey to assess pay beliefs, finding widespread and long-standing support for meritocratic pay principles. Since the early 1990s, majorities of full-time workers subscribe to the idea that pay should be based at least in part on job performance, and in 2025 nearly half of workers report that individual performance should be the main factor determining their pay. Results are generally consistent across key sociodemographic and labor market characteristics, although women are significantly more likely to believe their performance should be the most important determinant of their pay, and public sector workers and union members are less likely to believe that their pay is performance-based. We conclude by assessing the policy implications of these meritocratic pay norms.
The caste system in India acts as a barrier to meritocracy. For centuries the lowest castes were disadvantaged socially and economically. Evidence from the colonial censuses of the early twentieth century shows large differences in literacy and occupation between the highest and the lowest castes. After independence, India adopted affirmative action in state-funded education and public sector jobs that benefited people in the so-called scheduled castes and tribes, who were the disadvantaged groups. We show that since the 1980s, there has been convergence in education and occupation between the upper castes and that population.
This article disambiguates different conceptions of merit to consider whether higher education is currently, or could plausibly become, meritocratic. We argue that contemporary societies are not meritocratic in the commonly popularized sense and that because society is not meritocratic, college admissions could not be. Calls for college admissions to be meritocratic demand that they reward developed abilities, not native abilities, which makes meritocracy impossible in societies that maintain the institution of the family. Next, we explain why meritocracy, so understood, would be undesirable even if it were possible. Further, we argue that even societies that are not meritocratic may instantiate some of the damaging features associated with meritocracy, because those features are a consequence of people believing their society is meritocratic—thus, the irony that basing elite college admissions on “merit” may cause further harms because it exacerbates the (false) belief that society is meritocratic.
To advance understanding of how cultural notions of merit in professions perpetuate inequality, we introduce the novel concept of “inhabited professions.” We argue that notions of professional merit play out within day-to-day interactions among workplace colleagues in ways that generate negative consequences for those who deviate from predominant conceptions of excellence. As a case, we focus on how a particular professional norm, the (de)valuation of diversity concerns, shapes gender inequality in STEM departments. Using data from 266 academic scientists nested in 14 departments, we find that women with a substantial gap between their personal concern for diversity and their colleagues’ beliefs about the importance of promoting diversity are significantly more likely to report chilly departmental climates, to feel disrespected, and to intend to leave the university than men in their departments. While women defenders of diversity are treated as less worthy, men diversity proponents are buffered from these negative consequences.
The notion of meritocracy is in crisis in the Western world, with scholars and citizens arguing that it creates a divisive equilibrium with high levels of inequality and cultural polarization. We argue that the meritocratic equilibrium that is currently being scrutinized is more culturally embedded than its critics recognize. We show that in Africa, for example, beliefs, practices, and norms allow for the existence of an equilibrium that is genuinely meritocratic and also redistributive. We show how African cultures tend to combine individualism and communalism, and that in achieving this balance, Africans innovated different norms and mechanisms that attempt to harmonize the interests of the individual with those of the community. These mechanisms do appear to break down in parts of Africa where witchcraft is used as a mechanism for enforcing the social contract.