
A 1976 review of use of the IUD, which has been available for decades in the UK, included the recommendations that IUD service undergo continued monitoring and that service providers undergo insertion training to become accredited. Today, a training schedule for IUD fitting is in place, but the requirement that a log be kept available for clinical and multiprofessional audit has been dropped. This is unfortunate because a log book is a useful data collection and monitoring tool, especially as it permits monitoring of IUD removal rates. Correct fitting of IUDs as well as correct counseling can minimize removal rates. A chart is, therefore, provided to illustrate the use of monitoring of IUD service provision by listing reasons for removal (pregnancy, infection, discomfort/unacceptable bleeding; dyspareunia, or shock) and relevant standards and changes that can be monitored in each case.
Nurses in the UK play a significant role in the delivery of family planning (FP) services, especially in the areas of counseling and provision of routine health checks. Clinical audits of delivery of FP services, therefore, should follow a whole team approach which includes nurses. It is also easier to achieve the desired changes in practice after an evaluation if the whole service delivery team is involved in the audit. Audits of nursing practice available in a database include 1) administration of hormonal contraception and hormonal postcoital contraception, 2) the role of nurses in clinics, and 3) nurse-only clinics. Audits may also be considered to evaluate nurse counseling on topics such as choosing a contraception, effective condom use, and effective oral contraceptive use.
Family planning and reproductive health providers are struggling to handle the effect of the latest and second oral contraceptive (OC) scare of 1995. Neither scare is based on significant published data or data in the public domain. Data for the latest scare do exist, which are still unpublished. These data appear to completely contradict the earlier allegation of a differential risk for venous thromboembolism (VTE) between desogestrel- and gestodene-based combined OCs. They show that second generation OCs have a lower excess risk of VTE than desogestrel- or gestodene-based OCs. An October 1995 letter recommended that providers should change women using desogestrel- or gestodene-based OCs to alternative OCs containing levonorgestrel, norethisterone, or ethynodiol. It is impossible to know whether the effect for clients and providers would have been greater or lesser had the information not leaked to the press before publication. Regardless, other OC scares are likely to occur. Providers should not overlook the opportunity to learn lessons that may benefit them and their clients in the future. They can examine the effect of previous OC scares by examining national abortion rates. For example, after each of the OC-related scares in 1977 (thromboembolism), 1983 (breast and cervical cancer), and 1987 (breast cancer), the abortion rate in most age groups (not in those aged less than 16 or 35 and older) increased. Some other ways to examine the effect of and providers' response to such scares are additional attendances to clinic, contraceptive switching, and increase in unplanned pregnancies. Providers should help colleagues, government agencies, and the media understand their impact.
In the UK, recent changes to prescribing oral contraceptives (OCs) have contributed to acute difficulties in providing clinical services, interruptions or discontinuations of audit and research projects of the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists' Faculty of Family Planning and Reproductive Health Care, and criticisms of the way its audit unit has handled nationally important information. Professional auditors should consider the problems caused by the sudden change in a long accepted gold standard as an opportunity. The unit has already received audits of the effect of changes concerning the risk of thromboembolism from gestodene and desogestrel containing OCs. Family planning providers need to consider whether their cascade system of information dissemination did not inform them quickly and completely of a necessary change in practice or whether it followed the information system available to clients (i.e., the national press) so that family planning providers are not prepared for consumer reports both qualitatively and quantitatively. Some potentially long-term difficulties have occurred, which probably could not have been avoided regardless. Some clinics had to dispense only a two-months supply of second generation OCs at a time. Problems linked to a large increase in clinic attendances (potentially longer waiting times, counseling time, poorer attendance rates, and possibly more OC discontinuations) will recur at two months and at regular intervals thereafter until new stocks are available to allow staggered follow-up appointments. Thus, the audit unit can refer to its on-going audits for these figures. The most difficult step of the audit cycle is to initiate a change in practice. The audit unit must first acquire data to handle appropriately OC scares from articles in the national press.