
The findings presented in this article present a portion of my thesis, "Cosplay: Community, hierarchy, and the Acafan methodology" (Skentelbery, 2023), completed at Keele University on March 15, 2023.My research, influenced by the work of Bainbridge and Norris (2009, 2013), Gn (2011) and King (2013King ( , 2016)), began optimistically.Initial data collected suggested that cosplay subcultures regularly create storms and disrupt the gendered norms of modern Western society by creating transformative spaces at fan conventions.My research, however, revealed that something much more complicated was occurring.My research findings, which combined auto-ethnographic participation and interviews, drew on a broad swathe of traditional audience scholarship, and post-feminist criticism.These data sets and theoretical frameworks suggested that there were in fact complexities and contradictions that exist within cosplay communities, and that cosplayer also replicated gendered and sexual norms.In this article, cosplays of DC Comics' iconic cat burglar Catwoman are the focal case study.Through the case study, in relation to Catwoman's long history across comics, film, and games, I examine how cosplayers not only create storms, but also replicate norms and gender power imbalances. 1: COSPLAY AND GENDERED PERFORMANCE'Gendered norms, ' in its simplest terms, refers to the ways in which men and women (in the dominant gender binary) are expected to present and behave on a day-to-day basis.Cosplay scholars have suggested that cosplayers, through their elaborate dress and performances, can threaten day-to-
AB: Thank you so much for agreeing to have this conversation with me, Leila.The first thing I'd like to discuss with you is around the norms of participation -what we might consider the implicit rules of participation in the context of culture.LJ: There are so many different meanings of participation, in so many different contexts, that it's quite hard to say whose norms or rules we are talking about.In my research I have argued that the word risks becoming meaningless because of its ubiquitous use (Jancovich, 2015).But in terms of political science theories, which is what I draw from, participation is about having the power to influence change (Bevir and Rhodes 2010).So participation should be about breaking norms, not reinforcing them.But of course that's not the definition that's commonly used in the cultural sector, where "participation" often means "taking part" in something that's being created for you, rather than shaping it (DCMS 2023).So in the cultural sector it is often about "fitting in" to social norms.This of course varies across the sector: cultural participation can also be about, as Nora Sternfeld (2013) said, "having the ability to change the rules of the game." So even that question -"What are the norms?" -it depends for whom.For participatory artists, their norm might be to direct the experience and retain authorship, and the participants might be their props, whereas for the socially engaged or community artist, the norm might be about the participants having agency and some control over the content itself.But in both cases, the norm is to start with artists, who then reach out to find participants to engage with.What if the new norm was to fund communities to decide what kind of cultural offer they want?AB: I think that this resonates quite a lot with some of the things I have been thinking aboutthat participation in culture is not just about participation in cultural activities, but rather in cultural governance and decisions around culture.To me this sounds like one of the key challenges when we think about participation.Of course, there is a wealth of history of participatory practices in the arts and culture (Matarasso, 2019), but as you were saying, the issue of agency in this context is quite problematic, because in my opinion, without building spaces and capacities for agency, very often we also have issues around the sustainability of participation.LJ: The shift from participation in activity to the shift in decision-making that you have introduced is literally what all my research is about.I have a lecture with that title in my module on participation, because rhetorically, at least, that is the shift that we've seen in cultural policy discourse and in cultural practice, to some extent, internationally over the last twenty years.I started doing research on this topic in
Abstract The paper addresses the political and cultural problem underpinning mainstream narratives on homelessness. The absence of data, in conjunction with the misconceptions associated with homelessness, translate into the criminalization and stigmatization of homelessness, both at the local level and in fragmented policies at national and international levels. Section one presents an overview of homelessness as a cultural and political problem; section two then introduces the Italian situation and Bologna as a case study. After a presentation of the method followed in section three, sections four and five describe and then discuss two projects initiated by a political collective in the city of Bologna that directly involve homeless people in the deconstruction of imageries and narratives around homelessness. Finally, section six draws conclusions about the need to generate new narratives capable of accounting for the intersectional and complex nature of the phenomenon of homelessness: new narratives capable of restoring to the homeless their articulate human identity.
Abstract Participatory arts can invite stormy and violent forms of participation when they are commissioned for sites where frustration, territorial control and pre-emptive self-defense involve practices of accepted street codes by those living within racialized, febrile territories. Through the case study of Aroma Home, a participatory art gardening project, in Paris’s northern peripheries, I analyze instances of affective, symbolic, performative and territorial violence as non-normative political acts of participation. Examining the underlying contexts and logics that led to these incidents, I argue that the most insidious act of violence in the project was the creation of our invasive, extractive garden on a hitherto unclaimed and unidentified patch of ‘free’ public ground. In creating a new identity for this wasteland and defining its use, we effectively limited, and implicitly prescribed, modes of participation that were culturally alien to those we most wanted to involve.