
Each year, choosing Christmas presents for the people I am closest to reveals in all its poverty my slender understanding of what pleases them. The problem is multiplied tenfold when attempting to choose for people with learning disability, particularly when choosers are service staff whose relationship with the person is relatively recent and the person has little or no speech. In recent times this problem has apparently been addressed by enabling people to choose for themselves. Offering choice to users has almost become a byword for ethical p ractice: people unable to do are construed merely to lack experience. This paper considers the situation o f people w ith severe and m ultip le disabilities whose range o f choicemaking is extremely limited even when they get plenty o f practice. It assumes there are topics on which they need someone to speak for them, a proxy, and that it is important to theorise how that person can do their task as well as possible.
Keene v. Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Inc. is a medical malpractice case brought by the parents of Dylan Keene who suffered severe brain in jury at birth. On April 30,1999, the Superior Court of Commonwealth of Massa chusetts ruled that the hospital, which was the defendant in the case, was negligent. At issue is how the court calculated the award of damages in its March 13, 2000, opinion. This article presents a brief of the Keene case, the calculus used in court’s damage award, and some commentary on the court’s ruling.