
In this article, the authors develop the framework of panoptic pain to theorize how women experiencing persistent pain regulate their presentations of pain and patienthood to negotiate credibility in the clinical encounter. Drawing on Foucault’s account of disciplinary power, the authors argue that women internalize clinical norms and engage in strategies of ideal patient embodiment and credibility work to secure recognition. Although these strategies can yield short-term epistemic gains, they ultimately reproduce the very standards that exclude nonconforming illness experiences and patient identities, rendering women’s strategic agency complicit in epistemic injustice. By positioning credibility as governed by disciplinary power, panoptic pain reframes agency in the persistent pain clinic and shows that meaningful resistance requires structural—rather than merely individual—transformation.
Ethics literature that engages with the lived experiences of mental health and substance use has not been unified as a body of knowledge. The authors therefore conducted a critical interpretive review of 371 articles that explicitly indicated that mental health and/or substance use service users were involved as authors, researchers, research participants, and/or as patients and claimed or implied a contribution to the academic bioethics literature. The authors found a spectrum of contributions, with service users less well represented in roles with apparent influence over ethical interpretations. The authors suggest six disciplinary norms in bioethics that may be impeding service user contributions, discuss how they might be addressed, and propose future directions for cultivating Mad ethics to their fullest potential.