
How do medical students learn to make impossible decisions every day? They can share their problems with their colleagues and seniors, and learn decision-making skills which will carry over into their practice once they graduate. At the MGIMS, a group of residents and interns has started informal discussions of case study scenarios. The idea is to encourage students to discuss their dilemmas, identify the reasons for their decisions and thus clarify the decision-making process. The first case study was based on a real life scenario at the MGIMS.
There is no doubt that the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) epidemic has added to the professional hazards of some doctors and other health professionals. HIV infection is fatal and without a cure, though there are chances that it can be eradicated if drug therapy is started immediately after the onset of the infection. Hence, it is quite natural that medical professionals are afraid of acquiring HIV infection from patients. This issue of risk to medical professionals is serious. Despite these facts, I believe doctors and hospitals should not be allowed to refuse treatment to patients for the reason that they are HIV positive. Unscientific and unethical policy Unscientific and unethical policy Unscientific and unethical policy Unscientific and unethical policy Unscientific and unethical policy The boycott policy is unscientific. It is neither an effective way to slow down the HIV epidemic nor does it achieve its purported aim of protecting doctors from being infected by HIV-positive patients. First, doctors will certainly come in contact with an HIVpositive patient’s blood in emergency situations, before the patient undergoes a blood test. In non-emergency situations, the attending staff will come in contact with the blood, urine and stools of patients who are HIV infected before they are tested. Second, a test conducted in the early stages of HIV infection will not show a positive result. During this ‘window period’ the person can transmit the infection to others, despite a negative test result. It is for this reason that all health professionals are advised to take universal precautions and assume that all patients they treat are HIVpositive. Overall, the boycott policy is based on the irrational panic of doctors.