
The well publicized legal imbroglios that surrounded Karen Quinlan and Nancy Cruzan's terminal care have led to a brave new era of patient self-determination. That era began on April 14, 1975, when twenty-one year old Karen Quinlan sustained an enigmatic brain injury described as a chronic vegetative which resulted in ventilator dependence. Her family filed a plea in New Jersey's Superior Court to gain legal permission to disconnect Karen from the Ventilator. Karen's mother, sister, and friend testified that Karen often spoke about her desire not to be kept alive by machines.1 After being weaned from the ventilator, Karen now spontaneously breathing was transferred to an extended care facility on June 9, 1976. Nine years later, Karen Quinlan died. She brought the disturbing and very painful questions surrounding end-of-life care, autonomy and persistent vegetative state to national prominence.
On August 3, 1993, in preparation for house debate of his economic package, President Bill Clinton observed that his plan would, cut health care costs without hurting the His statement, at least for now, ended ten years of debate concerning the of medical care to the elderly. The debate began in 1983 ostensibly with economist and later Federal Reserve Board chairman, Alan Greenspan, responding to the statistic that people over 65 comprised 12% of the population but consumed 1/3 of our nation's health resources. He addressed this disparity with the rhetorical question, Whether it is worth it?2 This is the crux of the elderly-rationing question is the allotment of extensive Medicare monies to the elderly associated with a verifiable reduction of morbidity/mortality in the later stages of life? Is a continued disparity worth it? This is the subject and question that will engage our discussion. The debate concerning the elderly and should begin with an outline of the project at hand. First, I will review the definition and description of the rationing enterprise. This description will include discussion of de facto and de jure medical rationing, with the Oregon state Medicaid program serving as the latter example. Second, I will develop a rationale in an attempt to answer why appears attractive, especially if it is specifically applied to the elderly. Third, I will review three different attempts to justify to the elderly what is now the minority view which include Daniel Callahan's Setting Limits3, a paper I coauthored, Teach Us To Number Our Days, (Ps. 90:12): Age and Rationing of Medical Care: Use of Biblical Valuation of Personhood,4 and a counterpoint to the coauthored paper which was written by Dr. Ed Payne.5 Finally, a review of these three sources will culminate in a synthesis extracted from the pro-rationing arguments and consideration of their impact on the elderly.