
This study provides a causal analysis of the impact of data center expansion on local labor markets in Texas from 2000 through 2024. Using a panel of 254 counties, we employ staggered Difference- in-Differences (DiD) and event study frameworks, supplemented by Callaway and Sant’Anna (2021) diagnostics, to estimate the effects of these capital investments on employment growth. While traditional input-output (I-O) models often project significant job multipliers, our causal estimates find that data centers experience negligible long-term increases in labor demand. We find no statistically significant impacts to employment growth in Information (NAICS 51) or Professional and Technical Services (NAICS 54) sectors beyond a transient, pre-operational pulse and only a short-term increase in Construction (NAICS 23) employment growth following treatment. Furthermore, neither large nor small data centers appear to act as anchors for high-tech employment clusters, likely due to the proximity-agnostic nature of AI training workloads. Given that Texas tax incentives for these facilities are projected to cost $9 billion by 2030, our findings suggest that such fiscal outlays are an inefficient mechanism for local job creation.
Volunteer labor plays a critical role in supporting nonprofit organizations, prompting nonprofit scholars to develop various methods for quantifying the monetary value of volunteer hours. Unfortunately, this monetary valuation has been inappropriately extended into regional input-output models, creating highly exaggerated economic outputs. This Economic Letter shows how treating non-monetized hours as direct sales, output, or labor income generates phantom secondary spending and overstates economic impact. We argue that economists must isolate non-market civic contributions from actual regional cash flows, applying impact models strictly to observable shifts in market transactions, cost savings, and disposable income.
Volunteer labor plays a critical role in supporting nonprofit organizations, prompting nonprofit scholars to develop various methods for quantifying the monetary value of volunteer hours. Unfortunately, this monetary valuation has been inappropriately extended into regional input-output models, creating highly exaggerated economic outputs. This Economic Letter shows how treating non-monetized hours as direct sales, output, or labor income generates phantom secondary spending and overstates economic impact. We argue that economists must isolate non-market civic contributions from actual regional cash flows, applying impact models strictly to observable shifts in market transactions, cost savings, and disposable income.
Fatal vehicle accidents impose large direct and indirect costs on the economy, underscoring the need for research on factors that affect these crashes. Drunk driving represents one key factor affecting fatal vehicle crashes. We exploit exogenous variation in the availability of alcohol in states, the legalization of brewpubs, to develop causal evidence on the impact of alcohol availability on fatal vehicle crashes. Results from event study models using a state-year panel over the period 1975-1998 show that the legalization of brewpubs in a state had no impact on fatal vehicle accidents. This likely reflects existing consumers of alcohol changing the location where they consumed alcohol from other bars an restaurants to brewpubs.
The closure of a dominant economic activity can permanently alter rural communities, reshaping labor markets, fiscal capacity, and development trajectories. One such community is the village of Questa, New Mexico, a town of about 2,000 residents in Taos County, New Mexico, roughly twenty-five miles north of the city of Taos. For nearly a century, Questa’s economy revolved around a molybdenum mine that provided employment for about 400 workers until its closure in 2014 Parker (2008). Building on community interest in creating jobs, attracting new economic activity, and reusing former mine assets, a coalition of village stakeholders partnered with the U.S. Department of Energy’s Communities Local Energy Action Program (LEAP) and the National Laboratory of the Rockies (NLR) to evaluate options for electrolytic hydrogen production. Beyond leveraging existing infrastructure, the assessment was also motivated by the availability of local resources, particularly water, and by Kit Carson Electric Cooperative (KCEC)’s goal of meeting its 100% renewable energy commitments, including addressing nighttime loads and exploring long-duration energy storage solutions. As part of this broader effort, the present study examines the potential economic impacts of a proposed solar-powered hydrogen facility in Questa. Drawing on locally validated data and stakeholder feedback gathered during late 2023 and early 2024, this study estimates the short- and long-term economic contributions of constructing and operating the proposed facility under three scenarios (Least-Local, Mid, and Most-Local ) which differ by local sourc- ing assumptions. The locally validated information included the confirmation of industries present in Questa, employment levels by industry and occupation, and output values for known local sectors, drawing on the Questa Economic Development Fund and local officials. These inputs complemented national datasets from the IMPLAN model IMPLAN Group LLC (2019) and occupational characteristics from 33 the O*NET’s database1(Version 25.1). The analysis employs the 20192 IMPLAN input–output (I-O) model (IMPLAN data for Questa, a region formed by the rest of Taos County, and a region formed by the rest of New Mexico), modified to reflect Questa’s economic structure using locally validated data alongside national workforce information. Hydrogen plant construction and operation costs assumptions for the project were informed by a prior techno-economic assessment (TEA) study Topolski et al. (2023), NREL’s Jobs and Economic Development Impact (JEDI) Solar Photovoltaics Model National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) (2023) and cost breakdown data from a recent solar project provided by KCEC Reyes (2024). These empirically grounded cost inputs and locally validated data provide a robust framework for assessing the potential economic impacts of emerging solar-powered hydrogen projects and to evaluate how different supplier choices influence local value retention and overall economic outcomes.