
As the first nation in the world to introduce a freedom of information policy, Sweden has attracted relatively little attention in the historiography of information. This article analyzes conflicting ideas of governmental information in public discussions in Sweden between 1969 and 1973. The purpose is to highlight alternative ideas that challenged the government's notion of governmental information. Findings show that the main conflict concerned the interpretation of the desired level of citizen participation and the degree of equality between bureaucracy and citizen, which also caused differing opinions of goals and methods related to governmental information.
Since the advent of scholarly publishing many years ago scholars have relied upon the existence of rationalized venues for their scien tific research and scholarship. Indeed, professional life, if not exist ence, may well depend upon a foundation free of destructive intru sion or philistine interests. As libraries have attempted to cope with rising costs of serials and library service, journals have seen massive increases in costs along a long spectrum of economic measurement. Stresses and concerted attempts at keeping the economic whirlwinds from blowing away the temple of knowledge have left many librar ies holding their own, only to wonder within the inner sanctum what remains to be seen. Not long ago a masterful and deeply committed attempt to meet at least some of academe's needs led to a rebirth, in nearly Alexandrine terms, of scholarship, at least as it manifested itself in journal form. Many journals have inhabited the shelving ranges of many libraries only to be lost, in a purely illusory sense. Dusty and lost to memory, titles such as Mind and the American His torical Review were relegated to a shadow life on shelves and in li brary facilities not often visited. Today such is no longer the case?and for very excellent reasons. If the above scenario is a little overdrawn, it remains closer to the truth than not. As JSTOR has grown in use and more titles have been added at specific intervals, the richly layered database
Reviewed by: The List: The Uses and Pleasures of Cataloguing Robert N. Matuozzi The List: The Uses and Pleasures of Cataloguing. By Robert E. Belknap . New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 2004. xviii + 252 pp. $27.50. ISBN 0-300-10383-2. The universe may be defined as a random series of interminable lists. Robert Belknap posits the list and its ordering structure as both a literary and utilitarian construct, with some overlapping and shading among various literary lists that link "dissimilar modes of factual and poetic thinking" (182). To an obvious degree all lists are disjunctive and combinative, "organized blocks of information . . . the sum of its parts and the individual parts themselves" (15). Apparently simple, the list is implicated in a broad array of epistemic, rhetorical, and cultural constructs. Lists usually transform meaning through accretion, juxtaposition, and contrast, to mention only their most salient features. This is an old theme. The Homeric list of Greek forces in book 2 of the Iliad, for example, described the individual ships of a vast naval armada soon to be hurled into war. Bibliographic lists in the Alexandrian Library provided access to different versions of Homer's epics as well as access to Homeric commentaries. For millennia census lists have provided summary information on people and property. Today, lists have exploded on the World Wide Web, shaping our engagement with commerce, art, popular culture, and learning. The list is a ubiquitous feature of cyberspace, generating automatic algorithmic responses to"queries" in electronic library catalogs and Google-like search engines. It is omnipresent in commercial bibliographic databases, online booksellers, and innumerable proprietary websites. Lists are implicated in surveillance; to be added to or stricken off a list might spell disaster or salvation. In a bureaucratic twist on Bishop Berkeley, it might be claimed that to be is to be listed. With the enormous impact of Gutenberg the list, in addition to its diverse imaginative uses, began to function metaphorically as a kind of textual maneuver against information overload and the geographic dispersal of books. Specific examples of this include Rabelais (gastronomy and scatology) and Conrad Gesner (protobibliography). Francis Bacon's empiricism is in some measure a by-product of his brisk accumulation and listing of facts. The droll logorrhoeic carnival in The Anatomy of Melancholy is heightened by an encyclopedic accumulation ofdefinitions and allusions, presumably enlisted by Burton to elude the onset of melancholy in himself and the reader. A little later nature itself comes under the simplifying gaze of Linnaeus's famous taxonomic list, a precursor to other scientific lists like the periodic table or what Belknap calls the pragmatic list, "whose finely distinguished categories, with the official validation of science, could be shuffled and arranged with analytical precision" (168). Some five hundred years after Gesner, modern bibliography posits specialized lists to encompass the book as both a material and a cultural/historical artifact. Robert Belknap situates the story of the literary list in the American Renaissance, taking as his starting point the Transcendentalist catalog, with its panoramic dynamism and philosophical assumptions about the commonalityunderlying seemingly discrete objects. The foundational text, Emerson's Nature, [End Page 283] dates from 1836. The American literary list thus parallels the rise of an emerging society where raw democratic energies and all-consuming material ambitions swept aside static hierarchy and received opinions. Such lists embody a kind of political self-mastery. Taking his cue from Emerson, Whitman in Leaves of Grass embodied a poetics of listing that is rich in sensual detail and incantatory exuberance. With Whitman, the poem as literary artifact became an unprecedented space flung open to objects, details, and references whose artful inclusivity, says Belknap, "becomes universally welcoming, open to all facets of life, according to his vision of a plural America" (74). Whitman's richly modulated catalogs are, with Emerson's Essays, radical literary expressions of the American democratic experiment. The lists in Moby Dick, by contrast, supply material density as a counterpoint to an unseen core of metaphysical nothingness. With his lists and symbolism Melville accentuated a Gnostic parable with the practical concerns of anineteenth-century ship's chandler and factoids about whales and whaling. And with regard to whales and the...
The Woman's Building Library at the World's Columbian Exposition of 1893 included many texts that could be classified as "religious." In bringing a large body of women's publications together in one place, the Woman's Building's organizers called attention to women's past achievements in order to carve out a larger space for women's public participation. Yet the project of expanding women's sphere coincided imperfectly with the domestic model of piety that most religious publications embodied. This essay explores tensions between the Woman's Building's goals of advancing women's power to shape the public sphere and the library's religious contents.
The figures range from portraits of notable individuals connected to the library, such as the eponymous Harry Elkins Widener, to architectural schematics, outmoded library documents such as a “stack pass,” and, of course, interior and exterior shots of the Widener itself. The illustrations serve to make the accompanying narrative more concrete and tangible than it might otherwise have been. In general, this is an interesting and well-executed book. The text suffers from uneven proofing, as evidenced by the surprising number of spelling errors that slipped through. A more serious issue has to do with a lacuna in the information. The book repeatedly draws attention to the fact that for much of its early history the library was closed to women (vii, 86, 113, 115, 126). It therefore seems a curious omission that it never mentions when or how these restrictions were lifted. Suddenly on page 143 a quoted letter refers to “the coeducational nature of the reading room” as an established fact, which is the first that the reader learns of this development. Similarly, the changes wrought by the opening of the stacks are discussed without giving any more specific information about the circumstances of that change than that it happened at some unspecified time during the tenure of Keyes Metcalfe. Despite these oversights, Widener: Biography of a Library will be useful to anyone interested in the history of Harvard, the development of large academic libraries in the twentieth century, or the Widener in particular. If the tone is more emotional than analytical, that is no great flaw in a book intended to celebrate the Widener’s turbulent years of service. The author writes, “Widener’s story is that of higher education in the midst of the social, political, and cultural tumult of the twentieth century; it is a story best told by more accomplished voices than mine” (x). Perhaps one of those voices will take up this modest refrain and raise it to further heights.