
A chronological history of precedents relative to the position of the Catholic Church on abortion is summarized. The study is comprised of 6 sections: 1) context in the Greco-Roman world; 2) first Christian t eachings, 50 A.D.-450 A.D.; 3) liturgy, canons and theological analysis, 450-1450; 4) theraputic abortion, papal legislation and opinion on ensou lment, 1450-1750; 5) sensitivity to life, papal rulings and exceptions, 1750-1965 and 6) conclusion.
"Natural law," which has been appealed to by catholic theologians in their arguments against both usury and contraception, is examined in this essay. Usury was "tokos" to the Greeks, while what caused contraception was "atokion." Beyond this verbal link, usury and contraception share the bond of having both been condemned as contrary to the natural level of generation. An act of lending is naturally sterile; an act of intercourse naturally fertile. These 2 propositions appeared to be the chief rational support of the absolute prohibition by Catholic theologians of any profit on a loan or of any act preventing intercourse from being fertile. The question arises as to why the argument based on nature seemed so superior; psychological and rhetorical satisfactions would seem to account for the choice. The sacral character of coitus to which the argument finally appeals seems no stronge than the usury argument's appeal to the sacred character of time. The claim that coitus was naturally fertile continued long after acceptance of the marriage of sterile individuals, intercourse during pregnancy, and use of the rhythm method. The argument asserted that contraception was an evil which man could grasp. Values dear to all people were endangered by the practice of contraception, and the argument base on nature stood for this proposition.
Journal Article NOMOS VI — JUSTICE. Yearbook of the American Society for Political and Legal Philosophy. Edited by Carl J. Friedrich and John W. Chapman. New York: Atherton Press, 1963. Pp. x, 325. $6.00. Get access NOMOS VI — JUSTICE. Yearbook of the American Society for Political and Legal Philosophy. Edited by Carl J. Friedrich and John W. Chapman . New York : Atherton Press , 1963 . Pp. x, 325 . $6.00. Ch. Perelman Ch. Perelman Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Google Scholar The American Journal of Jurisprudence, Volume 9, Issue 1, 1964, Pages 122–135, https://doi.org/10.1093/ajj/9.1.122 Published: 01 June 1964