
EU research and innovation frameworks increasingly promote co-creation while simultaneously requiring projects to deliver predefined policy objectives and solutions. This article examines the tensions arising between these ambitions, using nature-based solutions as an empirical lens. Drawing on six transition coastal labs in the Horizon Europe project EmpowerUs and Aristotle’s distinction between episteme, techne, and phronesis, we examine how universal scientific knowledge, institutional requirements, and contextual forms of knowledge/experiences interact in co-creation processes. The findings show that scientific criteria, funding structures, timelines, and evaluation requirements can constrain the extent to which local priorities are addressed. The tension is therefore not inherent to nature-based solutions but reflects a broader governance dilemma: Projects promise ambitious co-creation while operating within institutionally predefined solution spaces. Through a blue justice lens, we show that these conditions have implications for recognitional, procedural, and distributional justice. We argue for greater transparency about the boundary of co-creation and better alignment between participatory ambitions and institutional conditions.
In marine research, diverse teams are needed to understand and tackle global environmental issues. Often, it is early-career researchers (ECRs) who are tasked to lead these larger interdisciplinary research initiatives. There are a number of reasons for this: passion for the topic matter, desire to further their careers, or because ECRs may be perceived to have more time available. Whilst positioning ECRs in leadership roles can improve research inclusivity and innovation, they may lack the experience or training needed for such roles, or may not have access to essential support frameworks, such as mentorship, to help them navigate the challenges of research leadership. This perspective article offers shared insights from a team of diverse researchers who have led large interdisciplinary research teams as ECRs. Drawing on our experiences as ECRs in research leadership, we provide guidance for ECRs, their mentors, and collaborators on how to foster supportive environments that enable positive experiences for ECRs leading interdisciplinary research teams. Our recommendations include diversifying support networks, setting boundaries, and maintaining regular communication among team members. We highlight that while ECR leadership in interdisciplinary research can be a positive experience that is beneficial for professional development and career progression, strong mentorship is a key ingredient for a positive experience. This article identifies the need for research environments that allow emerging ECR leaders to grow, take risks, and make productive mistakes without jeopardising career progression. We offer prospective thinking on preparing emerging marine research leaders to shape and advance interdisciplinary marine research.
Marine science has not been designed to support everyone equally. Women are under two-fifths of ocean science researchers globally and a far smaller share of senior leaders. The barriers are structural and well documented (including caring burdens and unrecognised service, biases embedded in publishing and funding, and unequal access to networks). These barriers are particularly challenging for women with multiple disadvantaged or minoritised statuses (e.g., ethnic minorities and leaders in the global majority). Yet women continue to build careers, lead, and reshape the field within and despite these systems and, their strategies are a valuable source of knowledge. That knowledge, however, has rarely been translated into actionable guidance for women early career researchers navigating these conditions, particularly those working from the global majority and working across disciplines and/or at science–policy interface. This reflective article addresses that gap. Each author documented the conditions that shaped their career, and we compared these accounts collectively to identify shared experiences across career stages, disciplines, and countries. Five domains emerged, and each was read against the published literature and framed as a lesson: (a) build the networks that carry your work forward, (b) working across fields is a strength worth growing, (c) caring for yourself keeps you in the field for the long term, (d) publishing is a skill best learned together, and (e) your voice belongs in the policy room. We synthesise these into a practical action agenda organised by actor and theme.
The blue economy is commonly framed as a pathway to sustainability, promising the reconciliation of economic growth with environmental protection and social equity. In practice, however, industries seeking to operate blue face significant challenges translating high-level principles into practice. The study examines how the Tasmanian aquaculture sector (i.e., salmon, oyster, and seaweed industries) operationalise blue economy principles on the ground, and where gaps and burdens emerge. Survey data were drawn from the CSIRO Tasmanian Coastal Waters and Seas Survey 2025, a statewide stakeholder survey (n = 931). Results suggest widespread stakeholder concern in relation to environmental decline, strong expectations for transparency and accountability, and low perceived public influence over marine decision-making. While these conditions appear to have intensified social risk, the response by industry has been varied and includes enhanced environmental monitoring, regulatory compliance beyond minimum requirements, third-party certification, community engagement, and investment in mitigation and adaptation measures. However, stakeholder perceptions of the effectiveness and legitimacy of these actions vary markedly. Salmon aquaculture remains highly contested, with polarised views reflecting tensions around environmental performance and governance, while oyster and seaweed farming sit in lower conflict but more uncertain spaces. The findings suggest that navigating social risk in the blue economy requires industry-specific strategies that extend beyond formal policy alignment and regulatory compliance to provide the nuance and innovation needed to address cumulative impacts, accountability, and community expectations.
Fieldwork is often a defining experience for early-career marine scientists, yet it represents one of the highest-risk and least scrutinized spaces for inequity and harm. For early-career researchers, marine field settings often bring together diverse communities (e.g., on research or commercial vessels or in coastal communities) where steep power gradients, unclear roles, and unfamiliar cultural contexts can shape both safety and scientific outcomes. While awareness of heightened risk of gender-based harassment in ocean-based field settings is increasing, interventions continue to focus on compliance and individual behavior rather than addressing the structural power dynamics that enable these harms. Competence in power-aware field team leadership is a core skill for early-career researchers engaged in collaborative ocean research. Drawing from eight years of harassment prevention training experience, organizational psychology, and lived experience, in this commentary I outline three practical shifts necessary for harassment-free marine fieldwork: (a) redistributing power in marine fieldwork toward early-career researchers, (b) treating field sites as workplaces, not exceptional spaces, and (c) building collective power through alignment with complementary social movements and institutions. Reducing gender-based harassment is one critical piece of a larger project to dismantle the social and institutional power structures that produce exclusion in field sciences more broadly. By reframing field safety as a matter of power, this commentary offers actionable guidance to expand who gets to participate in marine research and elevate its social and scientific impact.