
Transformative innovation policies (TIPs) aim to address grand societal challenges by reshaping socio-technical systems rather than optimising individual technologies or markets. As innovation policy has increasingly emphasised directionality, missions, and systemic change, concerns have emerged about the adequacy of prevailing evaluation approaches. Conventional evaluations - focused on impacts and compliance with predefined targets - remain well suited to accountability purposes but may be less well equipped to capture the complexity, uncertainty and normative dimensions of transformative change. Recent scholarship has therefore proposed principles for transformation-focused evaluation that emphasise systems approaches, learning, reflexivity, power relations, and long-term societal outcomes. However, there is limited empirical evidence on the extent to which these principles are reflected in contemporary evaluation practice. This paper addresses this gap by examining evaluations of innovative public procurement, and more explicitly innovative green public procurement (IGPP), which directs innovation towards improved environmental performance and may contribute to broader sustainability transitions. The study conducts a meta-evaluation of 75 peer-reviewed evaluations of innovative and green public procurement initiatives focusing on the built environment across OECD countries. Each evaluation is analysed using a transformation-focused evaluation framework, organised around the dimensions of complexity, power, and purpose. The results indicate partial and uneven alignment with transformation-focused evaluation principles. While some principles are reflected in current practice, evaluations remain largely accountability-oriented and project-centric, with limited attention to system dynamics, contextual mediation, power relations, reflexive learning, and long-term transformation. By empirically operationalising principles of transformation-focused evaluation, the study identifies three practical leverage points - methodological purposefulness, theories of transformation, and evaluation proportionate to the challenge - that can strengthen evaluation where procurement carries broader transformation-oriented ambitions. In doing so, the study demonstrates how transformation-focused evaluation principles can be used diagnostically to examine contemporary evaluation practice without assuming that all procurement interventions are themselves transformative.
Ecological sustainability depends on the compatibility of demand arising from human activities with ecosystems’ biological regenerative capacity. The consumption-based load capacity factor (LCF) represents this balance as the ratio of domestic biocapacity per capita to the ecological footprint of consumption per capita. This study examines how income, capital formation, and energy use are associated with LCF in Iran and whether the energy–LCF association differs across levels of sanctions intensity. Annual data for 1965–2024 were analyzed within an autoregressive distributed lag framework and its error-correction representation, with lag selection based on the Bayesian information criterion and conditional bootstrap inference. LCF declined from 1.362 to 0.188, and Iran transitioned from an ecological reserve to an ecological deficit; the ecological sustainability gap also widened in relative terms. In the primary model’s conditional long-run estimates, higher real gross domestic product (GDP) per capita was associated with higher LCF, whereas greater primary energy use per capita and a higher gross fixed capital formation share of GDP were associated with lower LCF. In the primary model, the negative energy–LCF association was stronger at higher levels of sanctions intensity, but this finding was sensitive to model specifications and sanctions coding. The bootstrap supF test also rejected coefficient constancy in the primary model. The estimated relationships are conditional associations, and the study does not identify the causal contribution of sanctions to the decline in LCF. The findings support considering energy and resource requirements in investment appraisal and monitoring LCF alongside economic indicators.
Although sustainable management literature extensively addresses the link between organizational performance and sustainable practices, evidence on the mechanisms through which environmental regulations translate into firm performance remains inconsistent. Findings on whether circular practices mediate this relationship are mixed, particularly within SMEs, where these mediating pathways remain largely untested. The circular economy has arisen as a solution to address sustainability concerns. This study examines the influence of environmental regulations and circular supply chain management on sustainable firm performance. It emphasizes the mediating role of circular economy practices and the moderating impacts of top management green commitment. Employing Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling on survey data from 482 Vietnamese SMEs, the results indicate that both environmental regulations and circular supply chain management positively influence business performance, with circular economy practices acting as a partial mediator. Moreover, top management green commitment moderates the relationships between environmental regulations and circular economy practices and between circular supply chain management and circular economy practices, showing that top management green commitment determines how effectively environmental regulations and supply chain practices lead to circular economy actions - a finding that adds new insight beyond the widely recognized direct effect of leadership on sustainability outcomes. The results have significant implications for researchers, government officials, and company executives by elucidating how SMEs should adhere to environmental regulations and leverage circular supply chain management to enhance circular economy practices for sustainable efficiency in the context of developing countries. By integrating Institutional Theory and the Natural Resource-Based View, this study clarifies the regulatory and supply-chain pathways through which circular economy practices emerge, and how these practices translate into sustainable firm performance under varying levels of top management green commitment.
Single-use plastics are embedded in daily life and contribute heavily to environmental impacts. Circular initiatives such as deposit return schemes aim to curb this problem yet remain under-researched despite their growing popularity. This study explored the barriers and enablers of engagement within a piloted deposit return scheme at University College London (UCL), in which participants paid a £1 deposit on reusable cups, receiving this refund upon return. Nine semi-structured interviews were conducted with UCL students and staff and analysed inductively to identify influences on behaviour, with themes subsequently mapped onto the Capability Opportunity Motivation-Behaviour (COM-B) Model. Thirteen themes were developed and organised under five COM-B constructs: Psychological capability (understanding the scheme; forgetting to return cups), Physical opportunity (cup design; accessibility of drop boxes; posters and instructions), Social opportunity (social interactions regarding the cups), Automatic motivation (habits; positive feelings) and Reflective motivation (perceived ease; perceived usefulness; perceived reliability; perceived hygiene; alternative goals for using the scheme). For example, for the scheme’s uptake, participants reported needing to understand the scheme, as well as perceiving it as hygienic and useful, and having constructive social interactions about it. Accessible drop locations were noted as particularly important for return behaviours, while forgetting cups or using them for other purposes (e.g., mementos) prevented reusable cups from functioning as shared, reusable assets. By applying a behaviour change framework, this study provides recommendations into how circular initiatives can be strengthened, for example, by providing clearer step-by-step instructions, enhancing communication by staff delivering the intervention and offering timely reminders to encourage cup returns. These insights can be used to inform similar schemes aiming to reduce single-use plastic consumption. The work also contributes to the growing body of evidence highlighting the need for strategies to manage packaging items at the sources, such as reducing and reusing cups, beyond recycling initiatives.