
In this article, I present and analyse arguments and theory about what is beautiful and what is beauty, according to bishop Mahnić (1850–1920) from his article “Što je lijepo?” [“What is beautiful?”]. Mahnić advocates traditional thory of beauty and the beautiful, which is drawn mostly, but not exclusively, from St. Thomas Aquinas. Mahnić gives reasons and examples that beauty consists in unity in diversity, and that it is defined by three conditions which he took from st. Thomas Aquinas: integrity or perfection, due proportion or harmony, brightness or clarity. Mahnić also claims that what is beautiful has subjective and objective properties.
This paper examines the notion of the “authorship of the future” in the philosophy of Blaženka Despot within the context of the crisis of the modern idea of progress and its subject. Starting from Despot’s critique of the teleological conceptions of history and the privileged agents of social change, the paper shows that she relocates the concept of progress from the sphere of historical necessity to that of an open, politically contingent social practice. Within the tradition of the Praxis School, Despot develops a conception of the revolutionary subject that does not arise automatically from an objective class position but from the development of self-consciousness, education, and the capacity to reflect upon concrete historical relations. Particular attention is devoted to her feminist critique of Marxist universalism, which reveals that the presumed subject of emancipation is gendered and that the hierarchical structure of emancipatory theories systematically produces the invisibility of women as historical actors. The paper argues that Despot thereby not only expands the subject of social change but also reconsiders the very concept of historical authorship and its philosophical presuppositions.
Andrija Štampar bio je liječnik koji je djelovao u prvoj polovici 20. stoljeća i prethodio je etabliranju filozofije medicine kao discipline kakvu poznajemo danas. Promatranje ideja Andrije Štampara u kontekstu filozofije medicine daje njegovim idejama novi značaj i vrijednost ali i doprinos suvremenim raspravama. U ovom radu pridružujem ideje Andrije Štampara dvjema raspravama iz filozofije medicine. Jedna od rasprava je o medicinskim modelima, posebice o biomedicinskom modelu i njegovim kritikama. Druga rasprava je o pojmu bolesti te o odmaku prema pojmu zdravlja. Andrija Štampar nam pruža uvid u društvene, psihološke i okolišne čimbenike zdravlja koji izlaze izvan vidokruga biomedicinskog modela i pozivaju na njegovu nadopunu. Također, Štamparove ideje o zdravlju i definicija zdravlja predstavlja alternativu raspravi o definiciji bolesti. Štampara tako smještam u središte suvremenih rasprava i struja unutar filozofije medicine. Prvo ću predstaviti rasprave o biomedicinskom modelu i definiciji bolesti. Zatim ću predstaviti Štamparovu socijalnu medicinu koju smatram njegovim teorijskim okvirom medicine. Osvrnut ću se na psihološke čimbenike zdravlja, predstavit ću socijalnu medicinu kao alternativu individualnoj medicini. Naposljetku ću izložiti Štamparovu pozitivnu definiciju zdravlja i njegovo gledište na zdravlje općenito.
Petar Grabić has on several occasions criticised the philosophical insights and views of Albert Bazala, and present-day researchers have not been indifferent to this critique. In one such article, Barbara Ćuk examines Grabić’s critique of Bazala’s perspectives on scholastic philosophy and John Duns Scotus. However, this was not the only occasion on which Grabić challenged Bazala’s philosophical and cultural positions. In the 1914 issues of the journal Naša misao , there appears a three-part text entitled “A New Form of Thought and Faith”, in which Grabić criticises both Bazala and Aškerac. In a similar vein, the 1915 issue of Hrvatska straža featured Grabić’s article “Moral-Cultural Perspectives and Dr. A. Bazala”, which critically examined Bazala’s positivist and materialist perspectives, as outlined in the 1907 Hrvatsko kolo article “National Culture”. The subsequent discussion will concentrate on this latter critique, which pertains to Bazala’s moral and cultural views. First, an outline will be provided of Bazala’s philosophical and cultural positions. The paper then presents Bazala’s philosophical and cultural views, as well as Grabić’s objections and critiques, and finally we will evaluate the justification of this critique.
U ovom su radu izloženi i komentirani rani Zimmermannovi nazori o spoznajnim stanjima (dvojbi, mnijenju i sigurnosti). Glavni su zaključci pritom sljedeći: prvo, Zimmermannova su rana razmatranja o spoznajnim stanjima barem dijelom prožeta razlikovanjem između stvarne i objektivne istine; drugo, Zimmermann drži spoznajne razloge kako objektivnim kriterijima istinitosti tako i objektivnim motivima spoznajnog pristanka; treće, Zimmermannove definicije dvojbe, mnijenja i sigurnosti ujedno su i epistemološkog i psihološkog karaktera.