
Background: Reading comprehension remains a significant challenge in South African primary education. The Progress in International Reading Literacy Study of 2016 indicates that 78 % of Grade 4 learners cannot read for meaning. Folklore, a culturally embedded pedagogical resource, remains underexplored as a response to this challenge in indigenous language classrooms in the Intermediate Phase (Grade 4 – Grade 6). Objectives: This article analyses the theoretical basis for using Sepedi folklore as a pedagogical tool to enhance reading comprehension and critical thinking skills among Sepedi-speaking Intermediate Phase learners in South Africa. Method: A conceptual analysis synthesised international, African and South African literature on reading comprehension, critical thinking and folklore-based pedagogy, following a funnel approach from global perspectives to context-specific South African applications. Results: Folklore engages cognitive processes crucial for comprehension and critical thinking, such as interpretation, inference, evaluation and metacognition. Culturally familiar narratives reduce learners’ cognitive load, freeing capacity for higher-order analysis. African oral literature traditions incorporate dialogic and participatory pedagogies consistent with constructivist learning theories. Conclusion: Folklore-based pedagogy offers a theoretically informed and culturally relevant method for addressing comprehension and critical thinking challenges in South African Intermediate Phase classrooms. The proposed framework is a first stage that should inform subsequent empirical investigation in classrooms. Contribution: This article contributes to culturally responsive literacy pedagogies by synthesising reading comprehension theory, critical thinking frameworks and indigenous knowledge systems, and presents a preliminary conceptual model for Folklore-Based Critical Literacy Instruction as a foundation for future empirical validation.
Background: Problematic digital information increasingly shapes the literacy demands placed on first-year undergraduates, yet limited evidence explains how students demonstrate critical evaluation in written responses to unsupported claims, partial news items and distrust narratives expressing distrust of mainstream media. Objectives: This study examined how critical digital literacy was manifested in written evaluative discourse of Indonesian first-year undergraduates and how those patterns varied across stimulus types and study programmes. Method: A cross-sectional descriptive quantitative design was used with 70 first-year students in their first semester from seven study programmes at two Indonesian higher education institutions. Participants were recruited through classroom-based non-probability quota sampling. Each participant produced three written responses, yielding 210 texts and 41 864 tokens. Quantitative content analysis of four binary dimensions and descriptive statistics were complemented by corpus-assisted concordance analysis. Results: Most responses were classified at the moderate Critical Digital Literacy Score level. Credibility evaluation was the most frequently observed dimension, whereas bias awareness was the least frequent. Unsupported health claims elicited more high-level responses than narratives expressing distrust of mainstream media, and higher-scoring responses contained a greater density of evaluative lexical markers. Conclusion: Critical digital literacy was not uniform. It appeared to be a multi-layered, partial, and context-specific literacy practice, as observed in students’ written evaluations and distinct from their real-time online verification behaviour. Contribution: This study provides a literacy-oriented, corpus-assisted account of how credibility judgement, verification, reasoning, and bias recognition became visible in undergraduate writing in a Global South higher education context.
Background: Teaching reading in African languages has been challenging in the South African context, given the poor performance of South African learners in international literacy assessments such as the Progress in International Reading Literacy Study PIRLS and, more recently, in the 2025 Funda Uphumelele National Survey (FUNS) by the Department of Basic Education. The continuous poor results are a serious call to action to address the reading crisis in South Africa. We argue that investigating teachers’ pedagogical practices can provide insights into how they teach initial reading in African languages. Objectives: Using the active view of reading as a theoretical lens, the study explores the preparedness of four foundation phase Setswana teachers to teach reading in Setswana in Gauteng. Method: The study employed a generic qualitative approach, with a case study design. The data were collected through semi-structured interviews and classroom observations with a sample of four Setswana foundation phase teachers. The data were analysed thematically to derive the themes. Results: The data analysis revealed that teachers spent more time teaching phonics and oral language activities in Grades 2 and 3. Less time was spent on teaching language comprehension skills that support reading comprehension. Conclusion: This finding highlights the problematic nature of overly teaching decoding skills at the expense of language comprehension skills. Contribution: The contribution of this study is to highlight the awareness of teacher readiness, training and the importance of both word recognition and language comprehension skills for the development of skilled reading.
Background: Early literacy teaching in South Africa has been shaped by policy reforms aimed at improving Foundation Phase reading outcomes. Although the revised national framework for teaching reading in African languages addressed longstanding curricular inconsistencies, concerns remain about its strong emphasis on phonics and the implications for reading for meaning in African language classrooms. Objectives: This study examined how a phonics-centred orientation shaped Grade 2 isiXhosa Home Language literacy practices and its implications for meaning making, learner creativity, and the use of learners’ multilingual resources. Method: A qualitative case study was conducted in two mother tongue-based multilingual primary schools in the Eastern Cape, South Africa. Data were generated through classroom observations, document analysis, and semi-structured interviews with three Grade 2 isiXhosa Home Language teachers. Data were analysed using a social practices perspective on literacy. Results: Literacy instruction strongly privileged phonics and code-breaking, with limited opportunities for sustained meaning making, learner creativity, and heteroglossic engagement. Despite teachers’ commitment and close adherence to curriculum guidelines, classroom interactions largely prioritised standardised language and teacher-led instruction. Conclusion: A dominant focus on phonics may unintentionally constrain socially situated literacy practices by positioning reading primarily as a technical rather than a meaningful communicative activity. Contribution: The study contributes empirical evidence to debates on early literacy teaching in African languages by demonstrating the pedagogical implications of phonics dominance and highlighting the need for more balanced literacy practices that integrate decoding, meaning making, and learners’ linguistic resources.